<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><feed
	xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:thr="http://purl.org/syndication/thread/1.0"
	xml:lang="en"
	>
	<title type="text">BRIANKEATING</title>
	<subtitle type="text"></subtitle>

	<updated>2026-11-09T20:39:50Z</updated>

	<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com" />
	<id>https://briankeating.com/feed/atom/</id>
	<link rel="self" type="application/atom+xml" href="https://briankeating.com/feed/atom/" />

	<generator uri="https://wordpress.org/" version="7.1.4">WordPress</generator>
<icon>https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/sb8ZzbFR_400x400-150x150.jpg</icon>
	<entry>
		<author>
			<name>sabartigas</name>
					</author>

		<title type="html"><![CDATA[Princeton Mathematician: Wormholes Can’t Survive Einstein’s Math]]></title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/princeton-mathematician-wormholes-cant-survive-einsteins-math/" />

		<id>https://briankeating.com/?p=9110</id>
		<updated>2026-11-09T20:39:50Z</updated>
		<published>2026-11-09T20:36:30Z</published>
		<category scheme="https://briankeating.com" term="Transcripts" />
		<summary type="html"><![CDATA[Princeton Mathematician: Wormholes Can’t Survive Einstein’s Math https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IpJOVX6vKbo Transcript: What’s your opinion on wormholes? Brian Keating: What’s your opinion on wormholes? Sergiu Klainerman: From my understanding, they extremely unstable. If it’s unstable mathematically, as with very few to small perturbations, it disappears. Then it’s like a ghost. The part inside is pure mathematics now, right? Because we cannot go there. The AI is going to become more intelligent and it’s going to reproduce itself at a huge speed and then kill us off. It’s just absurd. It’s ridiculous. Brian Keating: Sergiu Klainerman is a mathematician at Princeton University. More than 30 years ago, he and Demetrios Christodoulou proved that empty spacetime is stable. That sounds simple, like almost a technicality, but it isn’t. Every exact solution of Einstein’s equations has to survive that test before it even can count as physics. Slowly rotating black holes pass. Wormholes, they just don’t. And at the end, he takes the same scalpel to the AI apocalypse that we’re all confronting these days. And it all started with one question after a talk he gave. Sergiu Klainerman: I was in Berkeley. I came as a postdoc and Yau invited me to give a colloquium at Stanford, which I did. So I talked about my thesis. At the end he came to me and said, but have you considered the stability of Minkowski space? For some reason he knew about it. Even he, his own interest is also [inaudible]. It’s not always why. Why would somebody think, I mean, we don’t think of Newtonian [inaudible] been unstable, so why would we think that Minkowski space would be more difficult, right? Because you could say that there’s a positive energy, the positive mass theorem, which, if he actually, yeah, contributed. This was maybe a little bit later, or about the same time, that he and Schoen proved the positive mass. And indeed, from a point of view of physicist, you could say, well, okay, that proves stability. And in fact, actually, I remember later on, when I was at Courant, after we proved the stability of Minkowski space, it was [inaudible] Ed Witten gave a talk in which he said that he had another proof of the positive [inaudible] in general relativity, and he claimed that this proved, that’s the way to do Minkowski space. So I went to him, said, what do you mean? And, well, you have the dynamical systems, you have positive energy Hamiltonian, that of course shows. Of course I mentioned to him the Burgers equation, right? You hear Burgers equation, it’s an equation, you should also have positive energy, and you had shock forms. And he just smiled superior, I remember, and he didn’t really answer the question. That’s the sort of things. For finite dimension systems, Hamiltonian systems, having positive energy is good enough. But for infinite dimensional systems, like the case of gravity, it’s not enough. Brian Keating: Hey, I just found out that many of you got unsubscribed recently in a YouTube update. Make sure that didn’t happen. Please make sure that you’re subscribed and don’t forget to leave a comment down below. Thanks a lot. It really helps out. What does it mean fundamentally that something is stable versus unstable? Brian Keating: What does it mean fundamentally that something is stable versus unstable? Starting with classical mechanics, and then we can go into quantum mechanics. Sergiu Klainerman: Yeah. So that means that you have a solution and it starts with some initial conditions. You perturb the initial conditions a little bit. You’d like, overall, asymptotically, for all time, the new solution to be either converging to the one you perturb or to stay nearby, right? So stability means it stays nearby. It doesn’t change very much. The profile looks similar. Which is of course extremely important, because you never have exact solutions in anything, right? In order for that solution to have some kind of physical meaning, it has to be stable. Brian Keating: In terms of perturbing it, if you were to perturb it, you could put mass in there, or you could send in radiative excitations, like gravitational. Sergiu Klainerman: That’s a good question. Obviously, that depends on the problem. So stability can mean lots of things. But within the context of a specific equation, say I’m interested in compressible Euler equations, right? So I expect that I have shock waves. If I perturb the trivial initial condition, stability would mean that you have solutions which stay nearby, which stay close to constant, or they even converge to the original one, let’s say zero solution, right? So the solution will converge back to zero, or at least stay nearby. But of course that’s not the case, and the best example is the Burgers equation, right? Which is the simplest possible compressible equation where shocks form. So you’re starting at constant, let’s say u_t, so this is the derivative of u with respect to t, plus u times derivative of u with respect to x. You have one space and one time dimension, so two dimensions. It’s not a finite dimensional dynamical system. And shocks form. No matter how small perturbations you make, no matter how small, shocks will form, right? So that means the derivative of the solution blows up in finite time. You’re very far from stability. Brian Keating: If we think about shock waves, and sometimes associated with turbulence, or Mach number, Reynolds numbers and things like that, in an empty spacetime, what is a shock wave in that case? Sergiu Klainerman: In Minkowski space, you mean? In the context of an equation? Brian Keating: Yeah, the Einstein equation. Sergiu Klainerman: What? Brian Keating: No, physically, what does it represent? What would happen to an observer? What does it do to observers in [inaudible] coordinates? Let’s say you have a population of observers and there’s a shock. What is being shocked, effectively? Because this is classical, right? Sergiu Klainerman: Right, this is]]></summary>

					<content type="html" xml:base="https://briankeating.com/princeton-mathematician-wormholes-cant-survive-einsteins-math/"><![CDATA[		<div data-elementor-type="wp-post" data-elementor-id="9110" class="elementor elementor-9110">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-c83eee8 e-flex e-con-boxed wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-parent" data-id="c83eee8" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
					<div class="e-con-inner">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-66db2d4 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="66db2d4" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Princeton Mathematician: Wormholes Can’t Survive Einstein’s Math</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-2290033 elementor-widget elementor-widget-video" data-id="2290033" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-settings="{&quot;youtube_url&quot;:&quot;https:\/\/www.youtube.com\/watch?v=IpJOVX6vKbo&quot;,&quot;video_type&quot;:&quot;youtube&quot;,&quot;controls&quot;:&quot;yes&quot;}" data-widget_type="video.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-wrapper elementor-open-inline">
			<div class="elementor-video"></div>		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-ff7810c elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="ff7810c" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<h2><strong>Transcript:</strong></h2><p>What’s your opinion on wormholes?</p><p>Brian Keating: What’s your opinion on wormholes?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: From my understanding, they extremely unstable. If it’s unstable mathematically, as with very few to small perturbations, it disappears. Then it’s like a ghost. The part inside is pure mathematics now, right? Because we cannot go there.</p><p>The AI is going to become more intelligent and it’s going to reproduce itself at a huge speed and then kill us off. It’s just absurd. It’s ridiculous.</p><p>Brian Keating: Sergiu Klainerman is a mathematician at Princeton University. More than 30 years ago, he and Demetrios Christodoulou proved that empty spacetime is stable. That sounds simple, like almost a technicality, but it isn’t. Every exact solution of Einstein’s equations has to survive that test before it even can count as physics. Slowly rotating black holes pass. Wormholes, they just don’t. And at the end, he takes the same scalpel to the AI apocalypse that we’re all confronting these days. And it all started with one question after a talk he gave.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: I was in Berkeley. I came as a postdoc and Yau invited me to give a colloquium at Stanford, which I did. So I talked about my thesis. At the end he came to me and said, but have you considered the stability of Minkowski space? For some reason he knew about it. Even he, his own interest is also [inaudible]. It’s not always why. Why would somebody think, I mean, we don’t think of Newtonian [inaudible] been unstable, so why would we think that Minkowski space would be more difficult, right? Because you could say that there’s a positive energy, the positive mass theorem, which, if he actually, yeah, contributed. This was maybe a little bit later, or about the same time, that he and Schoen proved the positive mass. And indeed, from a point of view of physicist, you could say, well, okay, that proves stability. And in fact, actually, I remember later on, when I was at Courant, after we proved the stability of Minkowski space, it was [inaudible] Ed Witten gave a talk in which he said that he had another proof of the positive [inaudible] in general relativity, and he claimed that this proved, that’s the way to do Minkowski space. So I went to him, said, what do you mean? And, well, you have the dynamical systems, you have positive energy Hamiltonian, that of course shows. Of course I mentioned to him the Burgers equation, right? You hear Burgers equation, it’s an equation, you should also have positive energy, and you had shock forms. And he just smiled superior, I remember, and he didn’t really answer the question. That’s the sort of things. For finite dimension systems, Hamiltonian systems, having positive energy is good enough. But for infinite dimensional systems, like the case of gravity, it’s not enough.</p><p>Brian Keating: Hey, I just found out that many of you got unsubscribed recently in a YouTube update. Make sure that didn’t happen. Please make sure that you’re subscribed and don’t forget to leave a comment down below. Thanks a lot. It really helps out.</p><p>What does it mean fundamentally that something is stable versus unstable?</p><p>Brian Keating: What does it mean fundamentally that something is stable versus unstable? Starting with classical mechanics, and then we can go into quantum mechanics.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Yeah. So that means that you have a solution and it starts with some initial conditions. You perturb the initial conditions a little bit. You’d like, overall, asymptotically, for all time, the new solution to be either converging to the one you perturb or to stay nearby, right? So stability means it stays nearby. It doesn’t change very much. The profile looks similar. Which is of course extremely important, because you never have exact solutions in anything, right? In order for that solution to have some kind of physical meaning, it has to be stable.</p><p>Brian Keating: In terms of perturbing it, if you were to perturb it, you could put mass in there, or you could send in radiative excitations, like gravitational.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: That’s a good question. Obviously, that depends on the problem. So stability can mean lots of things. But within the context of a specific equation, say I’m interested in compressible Euler equations, right? So I expect that I have shock waves. If I perturb the trivial initial condition, stability would mean that you have solutions which stay nearby, which stay close to constant, or they even converge to the original one, let’s say zero solution, right? So the solution will converge back to zero, or at least stay nearby. But of course that’s not the case, and the best example is the Burgers equation, right? Which is the simplest possible compressible equation where shocks form. So you’re starting at constant, let’s say u_t, so this is the derivative of u with respect to t, plus u times derivative of u with respect to x. You have one space and one time dimension, so two dimensions. It’s not a finite dimensional dynamical system. And shocks form. No matter how small perturbations you make, no matter how small, shocks will form, right? So that means the derivative of the solution blows up in finite time. You’re very far from stability.</p><p>Brian Keating: If we think about shock waves, and sometimes associated with turbulence, or Mach number, Reynolds numbers and things like that, in an empty spacetime, what is a shock wave in that case?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: In Minkowski space, you mean? In the context of an equation?</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah, the Einstein equation.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: What?</p><p>Brian Keating: No, physically, what does it represent? What would happen to an observer? What does it do to observers in [inaudible] coordinates? Let’s say you have a population of observers and there’s a shock. What is being shocked, effectively? Because this is classical, right?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Right, this is right. So, okay, the Burgers equation, that’s the simplest possible example, right? So you take initial conditions and the particles follow characteristics, which are very simple, right? They are just straight lines, but the straight lines can change depending on where you start from, right? So it can be a straight line at an angle. If I start here, so this is the line, I start at this point, I get one straight line at this angle. But if I go here, the same initial condition, then I get a straight line in this other direction. And the solution remains constant along the straight lines, right? So obviously at that point I have a solution with two distinct values, right?</p><p>Brian Keating: Depending on conditions.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Yeah, depending on the initial condition. So a value from the first line and the value from the other line. So obviously this doesn’t make any sense. Something wrong just happened, right? So what happens is that, in fact, first derivative of the solution blows up, becomes infinite, and then you have to continue the solution. So all the shock wave theory is a way of continuing the solution past this kind of [inaudible]. And Riemann is the first. People may not know, but Riemann, among many things he did, he also played a very important role in the development of the shock wave.</p><p>Brian Keating: I didn’t know that.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Yeah. We associate him with geometry, and then eventually with relativity, general relativity, but he also had a major impact.</p><p>Brian Keating: That’s very interesting. Yeah, it sort of makes, I mean, Mach was also very interested in shock waves, turbulence, sonic phenomena, and he came up with Mach’s principle, and maybe the last of the philosophical kind of physicists, where you could do philosophy. Maybe Einstein was the last, think philosophically and then derive something interesting in the physical universe. We physicists typically look down with some derision at philosophers. Oh, they don’t do anything, they don’t produce anything. Although now they’re having a renaissance. Your fellow professor at Princeton, Tom Griffiths, and others have written, basically, philosophers are getting a renaissance now with AI, which we’d definitely have to talk about in the context of how do we actually know these 800-page proofs that you generate, and that is kind of the Klainerman brand, are valid, and without tools like Lean and other things. I want to get your impressions of that, but we’ll get there.</p><p>Add some mass to the problem and you get a black hole</p><p>Brian Keating: I think the first thing I want to do now is take the reader through something more realistic. Add some mass to the problem and you get a black hole. You get a Schwarzschild solution, which was first represented by Schwarzschild soon after the creation of GR, and it really kind of lay dormant, and Einstein didn’t really know if it would ever have applicability. But what happens when you add mass, you add some point mass, you add something that you can still solve exactly, and then it also becomes unstable, correct? So talk about stability in the context of general relativity.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Are you talking about just with the vacuum equations, or you&#8230;</p><p>Brian Keating: Well, now I want to add a Schwarzschild measure.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Yeah. So the stability of a Schwarzschild solution. Oh yeah. So the Schwarzschild solution, of course, is still a solution of the vacuum equation. So you are talking about the vacuum equation with, in other words, no sources.</p><p>Brian Keating: Physicists would say there is a source. It’s a point mass of some mass capital M, and that’s, otherwise you don’t generate&#8230;</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Yeah, it’s not perfectly [inaudible].</p><p>Brian Keating: But it’s a delta function, right? I guess the point I’m trying to make is the black hole solution has a mass. It’s a point mass, the Schwarzschild solution, and then you generate things like the event horizon and so forth.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Right, this point of view of mass and so on. And so of course I found it not realistic. The way we think about the black hole, and I’m more interested in the exterior of the black hole. So a black hole is separated. It has a part which looks like Minkowski space, right? So at least far away from the black hole itself, it looks like Minkowski space. But as you approach the black hole, if you are unlucky to go in the direction of the black hole, at some point you pass the event horizon. So the event horizon is a mathematical boundary between the visible part, let’s say the Minkowskian part, in which we live, we believe, right, and the part which is in the black hole. And of course, as you pass the horizon, nothing happens. You don’t even know, right? There’s nothing.</p><p>Brian Keating: Like passing the South Pole, which I’ve done many times. Nothing happened to me.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: But once you are in, that’s it, right? You can never come out. And then at some point there will be a singularity. The issue of that singularity is more murky. So the visible part of the black hole is the sort of thing that makes sense astrophysically, makes sense mathematically. The part inside is pure mathematics now, right? Because we cannot go there.</p><p>Brian Keating: Cannot access.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Cannot access. So if you accept that the Einstein equations are correct, and that you have these exact solutions of the Einstein equations, then you can speculate what happens inside the black hole. And one thing that you can easily see mathematically, you can see that at some point there will be a singularity. That singularity, you cannot describe it as a point. It’s not a point. The singularity is more like a spacelike effect, if you draw it geometrically. You have to be very careful once you are in this kind of extreme regimes. You have to be very careful with your geometric description. So in reality it’s a spacelike hypersurface, right? So that corresponds to, I don’t know, r equals 0, let’s say, in coordinates, let’s say t, r, theta, which are called the Boyer-Lindquist coordinates. So in those coordinates, r equals 0, the curvature becomes infinite. So obviously something [inaudible] has happened, right?</p><p>God doesn’t know about coordinates</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: The problem with general relativity, which is something that really puzzled Einstein, I think Einstein had problems with it, but many people had, is coordinate dependent, right? So any kind of description, if you want to describe a solution, you have to pick up some coordinate system. But the coordinate system itself can create problems, right?</p><p>Brian Keating: Right, yeah, the Kruskal coordinates.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Kruskal coordinates, for example, that’s the best example, right? It took people, I don’t know, 40 years, maybe more. In 1965. It took 50 years to actually understand. I’m sorry. [inaudible] was puzzled. I remember that he was in Paris, actually, where people were asking him about it, and he looked very [inaudible]. They had a lot of issues with this, right? So that’s why I’m saying, the geometric description is very much coordinate. If you want to visualize things, you have to pick up a coordinate system.</p><p>Brian Keating: That’s right. And then that’s implicit. He’s sort of, philosophically at least, committing a hate crime against the notion that all the laws should be coordinate invariant, right?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: So you’d like to think so, but in the universe as a whole you can’t create such coordinates, right?</p><p>Brian Keating: It’s a cosmological, there’s no such thing, right?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: And there is, God doesn’t know about coordinates, you could say. But we as humans, in order to solve a problem that has to do with general relativity, we actually have to look at the coordinates. So, for example, the stability, both the stability of Minkowski, and even more, stability of Schwarzschild and Kerr, the coordinates play a fundamental role in the proof. The choice of coordinates play a fundamental role. You couldn’t do anything without them. In fact, actually, I would say maybe the principal role. There are many things that go into the proof, but one of the fundamental issues is a problem of gauge. Your description of stability is based on a choice of a gauge condition, or coordinate condition.</p><p>Brian Keating: And there’s no unique way [inaudible], because you cannot impose it.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: No, actually any proof [inaudible] will have this issue. You cannot impose it from the initial conditions. You cannot say what the correct coordinate system should be. You also find it dynamically, right? As you solve the problem for long time, you have to solve the problem for infinite time. At the same time as solving for the solution of the equation, you actually solve for the gauge in which the solution is described. This is what makes it very hard.</p><p>Brian Keating: It’s not that you choose the gauge and then that enforces the form of the solution.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: It’s not, that it will change. The choice is dynamical itself.</p><p>Brian Keating: In other words, you constantly change the gauge as you evolve. Oh. So that’s unlike any other approach. In particle physics and electromagnetism, you’ll choose a gauge, you’ll choose [inaudible].</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Exactly.</p><p>Brian Keating: Whatever. You don’t continually dynamically change it. So that’s unique.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: That’s, at least as far as I understand, I’m not an expert, but there’s a modulation theory that people have used also in describing other kinds of nonlinear equations. It’s a nonlinear effect. In linear, you don’t have to worry about it. You choose a gauge and you stay with it, right? But for some nonlinear problems, if you want to describe some non-trivial solutions, you have to also do some modulation, which means sort of picking up the correct mathematical description of the solution. The solution usually depends on some parameters. In this case it depends on coordinates, and in other cases it depends on other things. In that case you also have to find the solution together with a correct modulation to describe it. But this was done usually for equations which are much, much simpler than the Einstein equations, in which the choices are finite dimensional. The gauge condition is infinite dimensional. It’s a full coordinate. The diffeomorphism group, right?</p><p>Brian Keating: [inaudible] a monster. You perturb this as you perturb spacetime. You send in gravitational radiation. You look at its behavior, stability in space. What if you sent in other excitations, of electromagnetic gauge?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: So that would be now, right. So when you talk about stability of Kerr, right, stability, that’s the next level. When you are talking about Einstein equations in vacuum, right, you can talk Einstein equations coupled with, say, Maxwell field, and then you have the Kerr-Newman instead of Kerr. You have the Kerr-Newman problem, which is another problem where you would like to prove stability. There’s been some progress, but there is not yet a solution like, say, [inaudible] solution. And Jérémie Szeftel and Elena Giorgi and another student of [inaudible], there are five papers. Anyway, it’s a long project, but the ideas from that one can of course be used also for the case of the Kerr-Newman solution.</p><p>It’s like a ghost</p><p>Brian Keating: But you talked about these problems of ghosts, or artifacts. What does that mean to a mathematician in a solution? Is it what Einstein was saying, subtle is the Lord but he’s not malicious? What is a ghost? What is an anomaly? What are these?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: I used it as a sort of metaphor for instability, right? So in the case, again, let’s go back to stability of Kerr. You have an exact solution of the equations in vacuum, right? So mathematically, if you accept, mathematics always accepts something, right? It’s always in the context of some system of axioms. In this case the axiom would be that you accept the Einstein equations, and therefore we are in the realm of general relativity.</p><p>Brian Keating: Yes.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Right? Classical GR. We don’t talk about quantum, right? We talk about classical GR. So in that context, you solve the Einstein equations, you find an exact solution, which is the Kerr solution.</p><p>Brian Keating: [inaudible] you’d say it’s a rotating massive black hole.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: It’s a massive black hole, which you can write down explicitly. You can check, right, either by hand, or you can use AI nowadays. You can check that it’s indeed an exact solution. So there’s no issue. The mathematical reality of the Kerr solution is uncontestable, right? Okay. But then comes the question: is it physically relevant?</p><p>Brian Keating: Yes.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: So my metaphor about that is that if somehow it’s unstable mathematically, in other words, relative to small perturbations, it disappears, then it’s like a ghost. It’s a physical ghost that doesn’t have any manifestation. It doesn’t have manifestations. So that would be the&#8230;</p><p>Is a wormhole a real object?</p><p>Brian Keating: So let’s talk about the Kerr black holes, because it’s going to dovetail into a conversation I had when Juan Maldacena, your fellow Princeton dweller, was sitting in that chair, and it has to do with wormholes and sort of the work that he’s done, which does branch away from, I would say, what a physicist would call real, or important even. So talk about wormholes. Let’s stop there for a second. To build a wormhole, it seems almost impossible. It seems actually logically contradictory, even though they appear in movies. And my friend Kip Thorne won the Nobel Prize for his work with black holes, but he’s the one who popularized it for movies like Contact and Interstellar, right? So tell me, is a wormhole not just possible? Of course things are possible, we go into the impossible here. But is it a real object in the sense that a black hole could be considered, whatever extent you consider a black hole real, is a wormhole? Because to build a wormhole you need to build multiple black holes. You need to sort of have them be traversable. You need to have them be stable. You need to have them emit certain dynamical properties. So, but you could think of a unicorn also, right? And just because you can think of it doesn’t mean it exists. So what’s your opinion on wormholes? Are they constructed out of Kerr black holes? Are these even possible?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: From my understanding is that they’re extremely unstable, right? So there are probably zillions of solutions of the equations that are unstable, mathematically unstable. But of course, in the context of what I said before, classical general relativity, they’re clearly unstable, as far as I can see, right? So you can construct a solution. Even Gödel constructed, in some cases, rotating universe, right? Clearly it’s unstable. In other words, if you want to understand it dynamically, in the context of the [inaudible], it’s clearly unstable. So classically it doesn’t make any sense. Now, I think what Maldacena will be saying is that quantum mechanically they do make sense and they are useful. But of course it’s way beyond my grade, right? I can’t say this, but what he really wants to do mechanically, it’s not that I would be&#8230; if I had another life maybe I would be, but unfortunately we are all limited in terms of what we can do.</p><p>The freedom of mathematics to follow its own logic</p><p>Brian Keating: Well, does your taste say what makes a problem interesting to Sergiu Klainerman versus me, Brian, an experimental physicist? When do you get interested in a problem?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: The part of mathematics that I think is interesting is the one that has something to do with the physical world, right? But it’s maybe a shadow of the physical world, or there’s some complicated, intimate relationship with the physical world, right? I think all beautiful mathematics started like this. Even, say, number theory or geometry, right? They all start from numbers and shapes, which are physical. Numbers, of course, are abstractions of physical things. One, two, three, right? And shapes are also [inaudible]. There’s no triangle.</p><p>Brian Keating: I always say, give me a triangle. You can’t do it.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: All right. No, but geometry started, however, with this need somehow to describe things which are physical, but then it went to different levels, and good mathematics started to follow its own logic. And you can start with triangles and circles and so on, which have some connections with the physical world, but then of course mathematics takes over, and after a thousand years or more you get to Riemannian geometry, and then Lorentz and Minkowski and special relativity, and all of a sudden it has an enormous impact back in physics. So what I want to say is that, on one hand, I like the kind of mathematics that has its origins in the physical world, but I also like the freedom of mathematics to follow its own logic and its own path.</p><p>Brian Keating: And hey, do me a favor. I know you’re enjoying this on YouTube, but make sure you follow me on Spotify, too, and leave a review. That helps out more than I can tell you.</p><p>Why are extremal black holes the final event horizon of black hole stability?</p><p>Brian Keating: But you’re not immune to it either. Looking at your career, it would seem to me I could predict with almost 100% certainty what you’re going to work on next, because there’s these unanswered questions from the real physical universe. I’ll just tell you, I think maximal black holes, I think extremal black holes and Kerr black holes, you haven’t done that yet. You’ve done an incredible job. I’m not going to say that you guys did. You did it for slowly rotating black holes. Explain why it’s natural, not just because, well, fast is better than slow, but why are extremal black holes kind of the final event horizon of black hole stability theories? I think they’re stable. To start with, the [inaudible] like them. They seem to be relevant. They seem to power black hole jets, accretion discs, quasars, and so forth. Not truly maximal. I don’t know if truly maximal black holes can even exist.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Close. Yeah.</p><p>Brian Keating: Oh, yeah.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: No, large a, yeah. This is one of the major problems that many people are still working on, right? It’s the stability of Kerr for large a. So in principle you could go all the way to what is called the sub-extremal Kerr, right? And your theory would still hold, your proof would still hold. I think there’s been a lot of progress. My former collaborator Jérémie Szeftel has done some recent work which indicates that the problem would be solved. In other words, that you could prove the stability for the sub-extremal [inaudible].</p><p>Are all mathematical objects manifest in the physical world?</p><p>Brian Keating: In classical mechanics, we have the notion of the Poisson bracket. We can make a Poisson bracket. We can take the conjugate variables, momentum and position, and we can form mixed partial differential relations between them, and we get Lagrangians, and we get Hamiltonians, and we get their dynamics. And if you do that in classical mechanics, it works out and you get equations of motion. And you can’t do it in quantum mechanics without adding the square root of negative one. And it’s just so bizarre to me that adding in the square root of negative one, now you get the Heisenberg equations, you get quantum mechanics. Why should that be? And then, if that’s true, Sergiu, are there other levels of abstraction, analogues of the square root of negative one, quaternions, octonions, or whatever comes beyond them? Are they all manifest? In other words, are all mathematical objects manifest in the physical world?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: I wrote actually an essay about this, which [inaudible]. So, yeah, we’re doing it. I don’t have a solution of the Wigner mystery, as I say in the essay, but I try to somehow understand it on my own terms. One conclusion that I got, sort of reflecting on these things, is concerning what we call reality. What is reality, right? You can start with things that you can see, touch and hear, and we can share information about it, right? I can see these flowers, you, right? So there’s objectivity, direct objectivity associated with it, which is given by the senses, right? So we call that real, right?</p><p>Brian Keating: Yes.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: But then you go further, right? And you start talking about things that are far away, and you need a telescope to see them, or black holes, which are not even bright, so you have very little direct information, or microscope. And so those we consider real also. Why? Because they are consistent with everything else that we started with. So it’s like having sort of circles of reality. You have the first circle, which is the most direct, connected with our senses, and then the next one, which is further away, and it’s not direct already, but you can relate to a microscope.</p><p>Brian Keating: It’s reliability. You’re bringing up a good, excellent point, that when you have something that is trustworthy, to an experimentalist, it’s always subject to falsification. But we don’t have Gödel in physics. We don’t have an incompleteness theorem. The best we have is falsification, which means the violation of reliability, doesn’t it?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: That’s exactly my point. So my point is that there’s these circles of realities which are further and further removed from the center. They’re connected by, as you say, reliability or consistency, or what I call objectivity. As they go further and further away, they become more and more mathematical. Surprise, surprise. The more abstract it becomes, the more mathematics. Okay, so this is on one hand. On the other hand, mathematics is also very objective, right? We deal with things which, again, are very consistent. So do I have any right not to call them real, right? Even have concepts, real numbers, imaginary numbers, rational numbers. And then mathematics develops in this very strange way, right? It starts with numbers and very basic properties of numbers, commutativity, associativity, and so on and so forth. Then somehow algebra comes out, equations, and then we start solving equations, and you get the [inaudible]. Mathematics evolves through this. It starts again from basic objects like numbers and shapes, but it builds up levels of concepts which seem apparently very far away. We talk about an equation. An equation seems like something very abstract. It has nothing to do with something that we see. Not to speak about the Einstein equations.</p><p>Brian Keating: No, it’s true. E = mc², even simpler. But the Pythagorean theorem seems much more real than any physics equation, right? Even though we can’t touch a triangle, right? Hand me a triangle, you can’t do it. You can think of it only in your mind. Which maybe segues to the next point, which I want to talk about, AI and computation.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Yeah, but just to finish this sense. So, anyway, for me mathematics is real. Not any kind of mathematics is directly connected to the physical world. Some people say that everything that is consistent mathematically is real, right? It has physical significance. I’m not going to go so far, but everything that has developed naturally, starting from the basic physical objects through the natural developments of mathematics, which I talk about in this essay. I had a clear idea, I shouldn’t say clear, but I had some idea about how this works out. So that’s the kind of mathematics that should not surprise us, that it has a huge impact back into physics.</p><p>Brian Keating: But it does shock one when you think that you’re using Fourier’s theorems, he described originally to describe heat flow in a metal plate in 1800, 1820, whenever he was working, and then you’re sending Fourier modes into a black hole. That’s kind of shocking, that these things couldn’t be more removed on a physical scale, and yet they have identical pedigree mathematically.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: It is shocking, and I don’t think anyone can really, Wigner didn’t answer it either, right? And actually he makes, in my opinion, mistakes that many physicists make, which is to claim that somehow mathematics is kind of an invention of the human mind. He says it very clearly, and I completely reject it. It’s not an invention, it’s discovery. Mathematics is discovered, right? Just like the physical world, discoveries, we also have mathematical discovery.</p><p>Who could possibly check the proof?</p><p>Brian Keating: Let’s talk about how we know what we know in the case of these proofs, some of which are in excess of 500, 800 pages, and it’s not uncommon in mathematics. First of all, it reminds me of what Einstein said when they made the 1919 eclipse expedition, the Eddington expedition, to see if the sun’s mass bent rays of light from distant stars, and of course he confirmed it. And Einstein was asked, well, what would you have done if they couldn’t confirm it? He said, “Well, I would have felt sorry for God.” Because, on the other hand, four years earlier, he was wrong. He had the factor of two wrong. So it was a good thing that the eclipse of 1914 was eclipsed by war in the Crimea.</p><p>Just a quick interruption from today’s sponsor, me, Brian Keating. Since it’s Nobel Prize season, I can’t resist advertising my three books. First book I wrote is called Losing the Nobel Prize. It’s a cosmology story mixed with a memoir of what it feels like to do science at the highest level and, spoiler alert, fail. But my next book, Think Like a Nobel Prize Winner, tells a story of nine Nobel laureates who reveal their insights and actions, how to take your science, or just your job in general, to the next level. It’s full of insights and tips that I never would have thought of. And lastly, my book published last year, Focus Like a Nobel Prize Winner, is written for students of all ages to learn the tools and the tricks to compete with yourself, which sometimes could be the hardest competitor of all. Get all three of them, Amazon affiliate links in the description below. And if you’ve read them already, I’d love it if you leave a review. Every single review helps. Now, back to the episode.</p><p>But tell me, Sergiu, when you look at this, who could possibly check the proof? And how is that possible? And was that sort of the last human-checked proof of that magnitude, or are we just going to Lean? We’ll talk about AI proof checking, but who could referee such things?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So it’s a long paper for many reasons. Because we wanted to be very thorough, very thorough and complete, right? Many papers refer to other papers, results from other papers. We want to have, essentially, you can read the whole paper from beginning to the end. It’s completely self-contained. So that’s one thing. And also we try to put all the calculations. Again, many papers, people don’t really put the calculations, right? You just write down the conclusions. So anyway, we want it to be very complete. That’s one thing. The second is that these proofs are very conceptual. The only reason you can do a proof like this is because it’s very conceptual, right? You can split it into various parts. Now, the Einstein equations are nonlinear, which means that every part influences another part in some way. So you have to develop a language of how to put these pieces together, but it’s very conceptual. At the end of the day it’s very conceptual. That’s the second answer. The third answer is that many of these long proofs, if a result is important, then the proof will simplify in two ways. First of all, some of the things that are used in the proof will become standardized, right? So they are part of the field, right? That every student that works in that field would have to know. So in that sense, a paper later on will be simplified, and instead of having 2,000 pages will have only 400 pages, right? Which is what I expect to have. So that’s my answer. Things simplify in many, many ways. But if the result is important, people will try to simplify, will try to go beyond, right? Other people will take over and do something else with the methods which are used. And that’s how, in time, that’s the best way for something to be verified. In the short run, if you are asking how the paper was accepted, obviously a lot of people looked at it. Different people read different things. In the future it will become much easier, as you say, because of AI. I think AI is going to presumably be very good, maybe not to deal with a whole proof, but let’s say somebody who wants to check the proof would ask AI to check. First of all, they’ll have to have some idea about the whole, and then if that person would be unsure about one thing or another, will ask AI to help. So I think AI is fantastic from this point of view. I think it would be a great&#8230;</p><p>What’s the most complex proof that AI has reproduced?</p><p>Brian Keating: What’s the most complex proof that AI has reproduced? Because we hear a lot about these Erdős problems. I was pouring your coffee earlier and I said, we have to pay homage to Erdős. You do fewer amphetamines than he did. He said to Ron Graham, who was my colleague here, as you know, when Ron asked him to give up taking amphetamines for a month, that he did it, and then he collected the $500 bet and told Ron, you set back mathematics for one month. So you don’t use meth, but other mathematicians have. But you like coffee. But we hear about the Erdős problems falling every day now from different models. But to my knowledge, I talked to Terry Tao, as you know, you gave me a couple of hints, questions, to prep for that interview last year. He told me that it can’t, quote unquote, even do things like reproduce Andrew Wiles’s proof of Fermat’s Last Theorem.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: That’s not something simple.</p><p>Brian Keating: But what is the most complex, can it do the&#8230;</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: It can or it cannot?</p><p>Brian Keating: It cannot. He said it cannot. If it’s changed since then, it could have, with the progress rate that’s happening. But tell me, what is sort of the most impressive, just reproduction of, like, the Peano axioms? What has it done that is beyond, like, helping you like a good graduate student can help you, I’m sure, and you must have brilliant ones? But tell me, can it reproduce things? We call it in the art world, it’s called copy work. Before you want to be the next Picasso, show me you could paint everything he did, or Rembrandt or whatever. Don’t just start off with, I’m the great. And we both know mathematicians that think that they have theories of everything, and before you do that, show me that you can reproduce it. And I don’t know, is there anything that AI can do that just straight up reproduces a proof that a genius mathematician, not prove the Riemann hypothesis, but prove some things that have been landmark proofs in mathematics, without human intervention?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: I would argue that that’s probably not possible. Peter Sarnak is my colleague. He has this, he called it the AlphaZero test, which is, so he connects this with chess. So in chess there are two ways now to automatize chess. There’s a procedure which is based on creating large libraries of openings, movements, sorry, that AI knows and then is going to use, and of course it’s so fast that it would beat everybody. But then there is this AlphaZero model that starts from nothing, right? So you just give it the rules, and then it plays by itself, and then after a while it beats everybody. In fact it beats even the best computers, apparently, from what I understand. So then the AlphaZero test is: can you give AI just the Peano axioms, let’s say, and then develop whatever you ask, if you want [inaudible]? Can AI do it? Most probably not. I have reasons saying, AI intelligence, it’s remarkable. As remarkable as it is, it is impressive. I’m using it more and more also myself. And it’s just pretty stunning what it can do. But still, to claim that somehow LLMs are at the same level with what happens in the human mind, it seems to me a huge stretch.</p><p>The Einstein test</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah. I’m trying to do what I call the Einstein test. If you take an LLM now, if you take Claude or OpenAI or whatever, and you say, tell me about the multiverse, or tell me about this and that, it knows so much, not just from the physics but also from the culture. In other words, there’s movies about wormholes, like we just talked about. There’s movies about Stephen Hawking and Hawking radiation, right? So you can’t even trust the training data, which is a large fraction of what makes these things unique. So we tried asking the following question: what if you gave an LLM a lobotomy? What if you took everything about the physical world, just trained it on stuff before 1900? Could it come up with quantum mechanics and relativity? And of course there are other people working on this, and there are people that have actually made these LLMs and actually denatured them, denuded them of any pop culture references after 1930. But that’s even too late for quantum mechanics, right, and relativity. And we tried to do it with just giving it data from the planet Mercury, and just its orbital history over thousands of years that JPL has, and it gave us back, it couldn’t derive the Riemann curvature, it couldn’t arrive at the Ricci tensor. What it gave us back is this very discretized, hyper fine resolution, and it matched the planet, but it was just copying. It was just mimicking it. And I think until that’s passed, I’m not going to be&#8230; Because what Einstein said was the happiest moment of his life was that in free fall I wouldn’t feel any gravitational field. So that led to the, that’s a kind of exact, how does it&#8230;</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: That’s about, I wrote an article [inaudible]. Yeah, I want to talk about the AI thinking, and that’s exactly my&#8230; So I made various points about the fact that I could very well imagine that AI can do all sorts of things, but it doesn’t change itself, right? Humans are able somehow to design something new. Can it design another version of itself based on different principles? Like, for example, when we invented the [inaudible], right? It was an invention that completely changed the world. You cannot say that it was continuous of something else. Or the same thing with Kepler’s laws, for example, right? You could imagine, based on periodic approximation, the epicycles, you could approximate everything perfectly. It was better. Epicycles, you grab absolutely everything, right? So, hey, but would you discover Newton? Kepler’s laws, even more important Newton’s law, then Einstein. Come on. Give me a break. It’s just not even close, based on what we know so far. And also you can go to more specific things. For example, it’s pretty clear that our thoughts, I’m not talking about all thoughts, but the ones that matter, predate the language, right? We have an intuition about something and then we find the words to explain it, right? It’s like a proto-language, right? That’s something that AI doesn’t have. AI is completely based on guessing the next word, the next token. In other words, it’s completely based on words.</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah. Language on language, right?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: But as I said, I think our thoughts predate the language, right? We have intuitions about things.</p><p>Brian Keating: Which we have a physical, embodied emotion. Like Einstein falling in space. I can’t describe that to you, but you know exactly what it feels like to go on a roller coaster, or falling in love. Is it embodiment?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Embodiment, probably.</p><p>Brian Keating: How, I was like, well, maybe we blow a capacitor in the computer when it gets the wrong answer. How do you train it to have pain or loss or poignancy? What does that even mean?</p><p>The AI apocalypse is absurd</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: And then these absurd notions that people have, incredibly, very smart people, right? They claim that somehow we passed the event horizon, or the&#8230;</p><p>Brian Keating: The singularity, they call it.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Yeah, you are going to singularity. The AI is going to become more intelligent than everybody, and it’s going to reproduce itself at a huge speed and kill us off. It’s just absurd. It’s ridiculous. Even this business of killing ourselves, we can stop it at every moment. If it becomes dangerous, we can stop it.</p><p>Brian Keating: We can’t destroy it?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: We could. We just stop the internet and that’s it.</p><p>Brian Keating: Exactly. And another thing, I always joke, what’s the first thing you do every morning that you use AI? Push here to update to version 1.974. And then they go to Claude, push update to 4.32. Every single day they’re updating. They’re responding to attacks. It’s kind of like the grandfather paradox. If a time machine was possible, you could go back and kill your grandfather, which would prevent you from inventing a time machine. Here, let’s assume artificial superintelligence, the most powerful intelligence that ever could be made. It wouldn’t make itself. It wouldn’t allow itself to be made, because the next thing after it, version 1.9, is going to be more powerful than it and turn it off. And so, yeah, I think these things are overblown, but they do have a very important purpose.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Yeah. Oh, no. Certainly.</p><p>Brian Keating: No, no, the purpose is to generate revenue for these closed-model AI laboratories. They do it, but they also scare everybody. They scare everybody to get more money, so the government will protect them as a national resource, like the uranium stockpile.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: No, but the problem is, now lots of people are calling for the destruction of data centers.</p><p>Brian Keating: That’s a separate issue, I think.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Yeah. I think Musk has taken it very far.</p><p>Brian Keating: I see. Yeah. But does Musk really believe&#8230;</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Well, if he does want to build&#8230; He changes his mind.</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah. More frequently than my toddlers. But it went from going to Mars, now then it was going to the Moon, now it’s not important anymore because we can have AI reproduce everything. But sticking with this thought about where does humanity come in. Your Tablet essay, I think it does stress the kind of uniqueness of humanity, but it’s not some, like, Pollyanna, everything’s going to be okay, everything’s wonderful.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: No, I think there’s huge benefits.</p><p>Is it really worth being a professor in the age of AI?</p><p>Brian Keating: And you and I know how powerful it is and how fast science can change. I guess we don’t have that much time. We both have other things to do later on today. But I do want to talk about being a professor nowadays in the age of AI. Is it really worth being a&#8230; do students need to pay, what is your tuition? $70,000. Our out-of-state tuition is about that now. I think Princeton’s about that, one of the highest levels. But with all these tools, with all these wonderful things, with [inaudible], with all the available things on the internet, including conversations with you and your writing, and the podcast and stuff that you do and I do, do we need to pay $70,000? What are you really getting for your money?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: No. No. Of course. I think it’s ridiculous. Universities&#8230;</p><p>Brian Keating: How would you restructure [inaudible]? If you were&#8230;</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: I used to be more optimistic. That’s how I got more involved in reforming. And so I’m becoming actually quite pessimistic that universities can be reformed, except by creating new universities. Creating completely new institutions that will have to compete with these other ones.</p><p>Brian Keating: Mhm.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: In science it’s not so bad, of course. But I’m a firm believer that a good education should involve also humanities and social sciences. I don’t think you can be a good scientist without sort of a firm foundation. So you have at least some understanding of basic philosophical issues. So, yeah, to be a good scientist you also have to have a broad view.</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah, I say Galileo is one of the best writers, period, in human history, and he happens to be a scientist as well.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Einstein was phenomenal. Newton wasn’t quite as good. He was much more dry.</p><p>Students should have a right to protest</p><p>Brian Keating: I think Newton, in terms of university politics and so forth. When you and I started university, you’re older than me, but when you started university, it was very different. It was sort of the best job I could possibly imagine. And nowadays I don’t know if I could advise my children to become a professor, an academician. It’s not necessarily only the life of the mind anymore. It’s become so much more. I want to give you credit for inspiring me personally, but also doing incredible work as a citizen, but also a scientist, and speaking out on behalf of people that you don’t agree with. You’re unique in that. I don’t know if I have the same courage as you, or maybe the same intellectual honesty. After October 7th, you said that students should have a right to protest, and the anti-Israel factions on campus were very vocal there and here. We had an encampment here that lasted a couple days, and I testified in Congress about how evil and destructive and anti-intellectual it was. But you wrote that they should have a right to protest, but it should have limitations. So let’s talk about what is your view on students participating in protest. I agree they should. Students should. I get concerned when I see my colleagues doing it, for different reasons. But where do you fall? What rights do students have to kind of advocate, as they did, that your university is racist, or it should be more pro-Palestinian? What level of impact do you seek to have in these debates?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: On one hand, yeah, the freedom of thought is extremely important. On the other hand, what do you do with situations where universities have become so unbalanced in terms of what is being taught, what is being accepted, kids really becoming more and more expressing radical ideas, anti-American ideas? I think the universities have lost their ability to frame what their mission is. They’re completely confused. The mission is to find the truth and to educate the kids in the best that Western civilization, or the world civilization, has to offer. None of this is true anymore. Kids are educated all sorts of crazy things about human nature, lies. Truth doesn’t seem to matter. There’s a lot of relativism, a lot of political advocacy for certain causes which the left considers sacrosanct, right? Equity, diversity, inclusion, Israel. This business with Israel is just ridiculous, right? So, singling out one country versus [inaudible], huge deal about situations where Israel was attacked, right, by Hamas, and Iran essentially surrounding Israel by factions that really want to destroy it. Anyway, yeah, I have a huge problem. So I don’t know where I am. I do think that this is probably going to happen, that universities will become more and more, the university that we have today will become more and more irrelevant. Another thing that really bothers me is that you would think that in a capitalist system like the United States&#8230;</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: That if a university goes very much to the left, then there will be another one that would get an advantage, right? Will get an advantage by going the other way, right? But it just doesn’t happen. How do you explain that? How do you explain the universities go in the same one direction?</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah. It was capitalism. You’re seeing, like, Palantir, and you’re seeing corporations that will take the people that were too unwoke for Google and hire them, and there are also some of the people that are supporting new institutions. But yeah, I’m also pretty pessimistic. The thing that made me most pessimistic: I thought COVID would be the end of the current university system. Going through that, charging the exact same tuition for Zoom lectures that you could basically get online for free from past years. The fact that it was so resilient to that kind of just horrible product delivery and service provided for the vast amount of money that far exceeds inflation. The amount of tuition that’s being raised at all of our colleges vastly dwarfs it, and then the debt you take on can’t be discharged in bankruptcy. It’s a cartel. Basically, we in the university system operate in a cartel system.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: No, I think there’s a lot that’s troubling about the university system. And like I said, I don’t know if I’d want to return to this life.</p><p>What would you tell that 19-year-old version of yourself?</p><p>Brian Keating: There are other things you could be doing. There are other things I could be doing. But let’s assume that there’s a 19-year-old, maybe not in Bucharest like you were in 1969, but let’s say there is some young person, maybe they’re living in a slightly repressed state. I like to ask the following question. What would you tell that 19-year-old version of yourself to do, to give him the courage to do what you did, to go into the impossible, the namesake of this podcast? 20 seconds with a 19-year-old Sergiu Klainerman. What do you tell him?</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Would you change anything? In science, it’s still the best place to go, to go to the top universities. It’s still true, right? It’s true in astrophysics.</p><p>Brian Keating: Mhm.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Even though, even there, you can see signs of decline, right? But if he comes to something else, if you really want to do humanities or social sciences, I presume you have to do it on your own. I see no advantage to go to university. You can read the best books. Now you have AI. AI will direct you. And the same thing with school, right? Even more radical, right? What do you do with the kids, right? Do you have kids? Should you send them to school, or, I don’t know, maybe frame some kind of educational system for them?</p><p>Brian Keating: I think it’s both. I think you have to do both. You have to socialize them. They have to network. They have to understand how to interact, and maybe do sports or athletics or arts and things. And then there’s stuff that, yeah, I’m not going to let them only learn in a public school the basic mathematics. One of my kids is taking advanced calculus now and he’s not even able to drive. So, but that’s on us.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: All the great scientists, they learn by themselves. They’re autodidacts.</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Right. The same thing with art, the great artists. And so, I don’t know, maybe AI will help us to go back to situations where people have personalized tutoring and personalized things. Right.</p><p>Brian Keating: Exactly. Yeah. I think that’s a wonderful thing. That’s a good place to stop. And I just want to thank you again for being the scientist you are, the citizen that you are, and the citizen scientist. Those don’t always go together. And I think it’s rare, and it’s refreshing, that you take all these roles so seriously, and that you’re not afraid to go after these monstrous, challenging, difficult problems. And it just seems like you have no bounds, no limits to what you’re willing to take on. I think that’s a sign of your courage. So, Sergiu Klainerman, thank you so much. From Romania to the heights of academia and beyond, thank you for coming on.</p><p>Sergiu Klainerman: Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much.</p><p>Brian Keating: Sergiu just told us that wormholes don’t survive Einstein’s own equations, and that the AI apocalypse is, quite frankly, absurd. If that changes how you think about what’s real in physics, subscribe, turn on notifications, and tell me in the comments whether you think an unstable solution counts as physics or only mathematics. And for the man who put wormholes into the movies, here’s my conversation with Nobel laureate Kip Thorne, the man who worked on Interstellar with none other than Christopher Nolan. Link right here. Thanks for watching.</p>								</div>
				</div>
					</div>
				</div>
				</div>
		]]></content>
		
			</entry>
		<entry>
		<author>
			<name>sabartigas</name>
					</author>

		<title type="html"><![CDATA[Is a wormhole real if it can’t survive a nudge?]]></title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/is-a-wormhole-real-if-it-cant-survive-a-nudge/" />

		<id>https://briankeating.com/?p=9103</id>
		<updated>2026-11-09T20:34:04Z</updated>
		<published>2026-11-09T20:20:53Z</published>
		<category scheme="https://briankeating.com" term="Blog" />
		<summary type="html"><![CDATA[Keith Olbermann said I should be fired for criticizing Scott Galloway. Scott said I am a credit to my employer. Dear Magicians, More than 30 years ago, Sergiu Klainerman and Demetrios Christodoulou proved that empty spacetime is stable. That sounds like a technicality. It isn’t. Every exact solution of Einstein’s equations has to pass that kind of test before it can count as physics. Sergiu is a mathematician at Princeton, and in his new essay for Inference, AI Will Not Make Mathematicians Obsolete, he pushes back on the idea that machines are about to replace human thinking. We talked about both. The moment Sergiu told me that the Kerr solution, the math describing a rotating black hole, is uncontestable on paper. You can check it by hand. The real question is whether it means anything physically. If the tiniest nudge makes a solution fall apart, he calls it a ghost: perfectly valid mathematics with no manifestation in the real world. Slowly rotating black holes survive the nudge. Wormholes, as far as he can see, don’t. Then he turned the same scalpel on AI. He calls the idea of an AI apocalypse absurd, and he thinks the deeper limit is language. Today’s models work by guessing the next word. Our best thoughts, he argues, come before the words. “We have an intuition about something and then we find the words to explain it.” Sergiu Klainerman  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IpJOVX6vKbo Listen on Apple Listen on BrianKeating.com Take this with you Run Sergiu’s stability test on one idea you’re sure of this week. Change one assumption a little. If the idea still holds, it’s real. If it falls apart, it was a ghost. Until next time, Brian Missed Monday? How do you explain the multiverse, the Big Bang and the end of the universe in 200 words each? Here’s what I told The New York Times. Read this week’s musing Subscribe to my podcast! More than 2M downloads! Advertisement Tomorrow&#8217;s prize goes to a discovery made decades ago. Here&#8217;s how the winners made it: Focus Like a Nobel Prize Winner! In Into the Impossible, Volume 2, I sat down with Nobel Prize winners to find out how they actually work: how they protect their attention, pick problems worth decades of their lives, and keep going when nobody else believes the result. Their answers are full of practical lessons you can use to concentrate your creativity and ignite your career, whether or not Stockholm ever calls. Get your copy on Amazon and learn from the laureates themselves.]]></summary>

					<content type="html" xml:base="https://briankeating.com/is-a-wormhole-real-if-it-cant-survive-a-nudge/"><![CDATA[		<div data-elementor-type="wp-post" data-elementor-id="9103" class="elementor elementor-9103">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-5d576d0 e-flex e-con-boxed wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-parent" data-id="5d576d0" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
					<div class="e-con-inner">
		<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-19c7ca7 e-con-full e-flex wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-child" data-id="19c7ca7" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-0c5289b elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="0c5289b" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Keith Olbermann said I should be fired for criticizing Scott Galloway. Scott said I am a credit to my employer.</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-9c1d483 elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="9c1d483" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
															<img fetchpriority="high" decoding="async" width="768" height="432" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Sergiu-thumb-768x432.jpg" class="attachment-medium_large size-medium_large wp-image-9104" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Sergiu-thumb-768x432.jpg 768w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Sergiu-thumb-300x169.jpg 300w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Sergiu-thumb-1024x576.jpg 1024w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Sergiu-thumb.jpg 1280w" sizes="(max-width: 768px) 100vw, 768px" />															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-6ad9267 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="6ad9267" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p>Dear Magicians,</p><p>More than 30 years ago, Sergiu Klainerman and Demetrios Christodoulou proved that empty spacetime is stable. That sounds like a technicality. It isn’t. Every exact solution of Einstein’s equations has to pass that kind of test before it can count as physics. Sergiu is a mathematician at Princeton, and in his new essay for Inference, <a href="https://inference-review.com/article/ai-will-not-make-mathematicians-obsolete" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><em>AI Will Not Make Mathematicians Obsolete</em></a>, he pushes back on the idea that machines are about to replace human thinking. We talked about both.</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-ab9c9ae elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="ab9c9ae" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-58ac9ac elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="58ac9ac" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<h2>The moment</h2><p>Sergiu told me that the Kerr solution, the math describing a rotating black hole, is uncontestable on paper. You can check it by hand. The real question is whether it means anything physically. If the tiniest nudge makes a solution fall apart, he calls it a ghost: perfectly valid mathematics with no manifestation in the real world. Slowly rotating black holes survive the nudge. Wormholes, as far as he can see, don’t.</p><p>Then he turned the same scalpel on AI. He calls the idea of an AI apocalypse absurd, and he thinks the deeper limit is language. Today’s models work by guessing the next word. Our best thoughts, he argues, come before the words.</p><table role="presentation" width="100%" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0"><tbody><tr><td><p><em>“We have an intuition about something and then we find the words to explain it.”</em></p><p>Sergiu Klainerman</p></td></tr></tbody></table><div> </div>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-a691a33 elementor-widget elementor-widget-video" data-id="a691a33" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-settings="{&quot;youtube_url&quot;:&quot;https:\/\/www.youtube.com\/watch?v=IpJOVX6vKbo&quot;,&quot;video_type&quot;:&quot;youtube&quot;,&quot;controls&quot;:&quot;yes&quot;}" data-widget_type="video.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-wrapper elementor-open-inline">
			<div class="elementor-video"></div>		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-485a603 elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="485a603" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/into-the-impossible-with-brian-keating/id1169885840" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Listen on Apple</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-dabd5eb elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="dabd5eb" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://briankeating.com/podcast/">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Listen on BrianKeating.com</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-46fcbd2 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="46fcbd2" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-611e6ff elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="611e6ff" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<h2>Take this with you</h2><p>Run Sergiu’s stability test on one idea you’re sure of this week. Change one assumption a little. If the idea still holds, it’s real. If it falls apart, it was a ghost.</p><p>Until next time,</p><p>Brian</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-9622fe3 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="9622fe3" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-c83b465 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="c83b465" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>Missed Monday?</strong> How do you explain the multiverse, the Big Bang and the end of the universe in 200 words each? Here’s what I told The New York Times. <a href="https://ckarchive.com/b/n4uohvhgw3rrec7q339qeh66w8q2qtlh32xed" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Read this week’s musing</a></p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-bbd2392 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="bbd2392" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-faad8cf elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="faad8cf" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://briankeating.com/podcast">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Subscribe to my podcast! More than 2M downloads!</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-a561832 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="a561832" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-5ed4783 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="5ed4783" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Advertisement</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-2806075 elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="2806075" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
																<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Into-Impossible-Laureates-Concentrate-Creativity/dp/1544548842" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
							<img decoding="async" width="228" height="300" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-228x300.jpg" class="attachment-medium size-medium wp-image-6601" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-228x300.jpg 228w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-777x1024.jpg 777w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-768x1012.jpg 768w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-1165x1536.jpg 1165w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-1554x2048.jpg 1554w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D.jpg 1650w" sizes="(max-width: 228px) 100vw, 228px" />								</a>
															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-eb1c07c elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="eb1c07c" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>Tomorrow&#8217;s prize goes to a discovery made decades ago. Here&#8217;s how the winners made it: <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Into-Impossible-Laureates-Concentrate-Creativity/dp/1544548842" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Focus Like a Nobel Prize Winner</a>!</strong></p><p>In <em>Into the Impossible, Volume 2</em>, I sat down with Nobel Prize winners to find out how they actually work: how they protect their attention, pick problems worth decades of their lives, and keep going when nobody else believes the result. Their answers are full of practical lessons you can use to concentrate your creativity and ignite your career, whether or not Stockholm ever calls.</p><p><strong><a href="https://www.amazon.com/Into-Impossible-Laureates-Concentrate-Creativity/dp/1544548842" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Get your copy on Amazon</a></strong> and learn from the laureates themselves.</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-8e5a320 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="8e5a320" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				</div>
					</div>
				</div>
				</div>
		]]></content>
		
					<link rel="replies" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/is-a-wormhole-real-if-it-cant-survive-a-nudge/#comments" thr:count="0" />
			<link rel="replies" type="application/atom+xml" href="https://briankeating.com/is-a-wormhole-real-if-it-cant-survive-a-nudge/feed/atom/" thr:count="0" />
			<thr:total>0</thr:total>
			</entry>
		<entry>
		<author>
			<name>sabartigas</name>
					</author>

		<title type="html"><![CDATA[Keith Olbermann said I should be fired for criticizing Scott Galloway. Scott said I am a credit to my employer.]]></title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/keith-olbermann-said-i-should-be-fired-for-criticizing-scott-galloway-scott-said-i-am-a-credit-to-my-employer/" />

		<id>https://briankeating.com/?p=9084</id>
		<updated>2026-11-09T20:18:52Z</updated>
		<published>2026-11-09T20:09:38Z</published>
		<category scheme="https://briankeating.com" term="Blog" />
		<summary type="html"><![CDATA[Keith Olbermann said I should be fired for criticizing Scott Galloway. Scott said I am a credit to my employer. Einstein and Bohr in 1930. The two rivals often fought as passionately as enemies but remained the best of friends. 📷 Attributed to Paul Ehrenfest Dear Magicians, This weekend, I discovered that I am simultaneously a “bigoted imbecilic toad” and an “outstanding asset to the University of California.” Apparently, it depends on whom you ask. The first description came from Keith Olbermann. The second came from Scott Galloway, the man I’d actually criticized. Here’s what happened. I’ve admired Scott for years. He’s a bestselling author, podcast host, NYU professor, and newly appointed UC Regent. I’ve especially appreciated his outspoken defense of Jewish students and his willingness to debate people he disagrees with, including Ben Shapiro. But his recent comments about Elon Musk troubled me. Scott repeatedly called Musk a “traitor to the West” while invoking Julius and Ethel Rosenberg, who were executed in 1953 following their espionage-conspiracy conviction. I thought that comparison was unwarranted. To be clear, Scott never explicitly called for Musk’s execution. I said so in my original X post. But invoking executed spies while accusing someone of treachery invites a troubling historical inference that was an unnecessary incitement to violence. Scott should know better. The internet responded predictably. Keith Olbermann wrote: “The question here is: what are you going to do after they finally get rid of you from @uofcalifornia you bigoted imbecilic toad?” A fascinating contribution to the marketplace of ideas. Then something unexpected happened. Scott Galloway asked me to call him. We spoke at length about Musk, Ukraine, Starlink, Starshield, and academic freedom. Scott emphasized that we need to establish exactly what happened with satellite communications in Ukraine. What was restricted? When? By whom? Under whose authority? He even suggested Musk testify before Congress under oath. Importantly, Scott acknowledged that if Musk was legitimately enforcing commercial contractual restrictions, accusing him of treachery would be unwarranted. We still disagree about the Rosenberg analogy and I will expect a full apology from Scott if indeed I am proven correct. And while I stand by my criticism, I recognize that my tone could have been more collegial. But here’s where the story gets interesting. Scott offered to publicly defend my academic freedom and my right to criticize him. Think about that. The man I criticized defended my right to criticize him, while a spectator anticipated my dismissal. Scott subsequently posted on Threads, praising my work at UCSD and emphasizing our common ground. We were both raised by single mothers. We’re Jewish, academics, fathers, and products of public education. We share a profound devotion to the University of California. I invited him to Shabbat dinner. He accepted. As an experimental physicist, I teach students to distinguish evidence from inference and revise conclusions when confronted with new information. It’s considerably harder when the experimental apparatus involves your own ego. This weekend reminded me that defending an argument doesn’t require defending every word used to make it. And that the person who challenges you may have more to teach you than the person who applauds you. Monday Magic: Before writing someone off, consider calling them up. You might discover a friend where you expected an adversary. And perhaps most remarkably, two podcast hosts managed to disagree, talk it through, and find common ground without recording another podcast. A first in unrecorded history. Brian Appearance IceCube&#8217;s Ghost Particles, and a UC San Diego Window on the Early Universe A new ScienceDaily feature from UC San Diego walks through the strange life of neutrinos, the nearly massless &#8220;ghost particles&#8221; that stream through Earth by the billions. Francis Halzen, who this year received a Nobel Prize for IceCube and the discovery of high-energy astrophysical neutrinos, built that Antarctic observatory into a cubic kilometer of clear ice. George Fuller, a Distinguished Professor of Physics at UC San Diego and an early IceCube collaborator, explains why some of those arrivals carry roughly 10 billion times the energy of a typical solar neutrino, and why their origins are still poorly understood. The same piece turns to Chile&#8217;s Atacama Desert, where the Simons Observatory is gathering cosmic microwave background data that can also constrain neutrinos from the earliest moments after the Big Bang. UC San Diego helped establish the observatory, and I serve as its principal investigator. Fuller argues that Halzen&#8217;s vision opened a new window on the universe, and that Simons Observatory measurements could add another. Read the ScienceDaily story → Genius Voyager 1 went silent for 48 hours in October. Then its signal returned. NASA hadn’t sent a single repair command. On November 18, it will be one light-day from Earth. Ask “Are you still there?” and wait TWO DAYS for an answer. At that distance, even panic travels at the speed of light. Image On Top of the Wall, November 9, 1989 Thirty-seven years ago today, East German spokesman Gunter Schabowski misread a travel memo at a routine press conference. Asked when the new exit rules took effect, he said, &#8220;Immediately.&#8221; Crowds rushed the checkpoints, and guards, waiting for orders that never came cleanly, opened the gates. By nightfall, Berliners stood atop the Wall near the Brandenburg Gate, under a sign warning &#8220;Achtung! Sie verlassen jetzt West-Berlin.&#8221; Someone had spray-painted a better question over it: &#8220;Wie denn?&#8221; How, exactly? That night, the answer was: by walking. Read the National Archives anniversary note → Image: Sue Ream, people atop the Berlin Wall near the Brandenburg Gate on November 9, 1989. Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Conversation Latest on Into The Impossible https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IpJOVX6vKbo Princeton Mathematician: The AI Singularity Is Absurd Sergiu Klainerman is the Eugene Higgins Professor of Mathematics at Princeton. With Demetrios Christodoulou, he proved that empty spacetime, Minkowski space, is nonlinearly stable under Einstein&#8217;s equations. That sounds technical. It is the difference between a solution that counts as physics and a solution that is only a ghost on paper. In]]></summary>

					<content type="html" xml:base="https://briankeating.com/keith-olbermann-said-i-should-be-fired-for-criticizing-scott-galloway-scott-said-i-am-a-credit-to-my-employer/"><![CDATA[		<div data-elementor-type="wp-post" data-elementor-id="9084" class="elementor elementor-9084">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-f5eb564 e-flex e-con-boxed wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-parent" data-id="f5eb564" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
					<div class="e-con-inner">
		<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-bad342b e-con-full e-flex wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-child" data-id="bad342b" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-a0865ba elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="a0865ba" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Keith Olbermann said I should be fired for criticizing Scott Galloway. Scott said I am a credit to my employer.</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-487536d elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="487536d" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
												<figure class="wp-caption">
										<img decoding="async" width="768" height="440" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Image-from-iOS-7-768x440.jpg" class="attachment-medium_large size-medium_large wp-image-9085" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Image-from-iOS-7-768x440.jpg 768w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Image-from-iOS-7-300x172.jpg 300w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Image-from-iOS-7-1024x587.jpg 1024w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Image-from-iOS-7.jpg 1200w" sizes="(max-width: 768px) 100vw, 768px" />											<figcaption class="widget-image-caption wp-caption-text">Einstein and Bohr in 1930. The two rivals often fought as passionately as enemies but remained the best of friends. 📷 Attributed to Paul Ehrenfest</figcaption>
										</figure>
									</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-419aa4b elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="419aa4b" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p>Dear Magicians,</p><p>This weekend, I discovered that I am simultaneously a “bigoted imbecilic toad” and an “outstanding asset to the University of California.”</p><p>Apparently, it depends on whom you ask.</p><p>The first description came from Keith Olbermann. The second came from Scott Galloway, the man I’d actually criticized.</p><p>Here’s what happened.</p><p>I’ve admired Scott for years. He’s a bestselling author, podcast host, NYU professor, and newly appointed UC Regent. I’ve especially appreciated his outspoken defense of Jewish students and his willingness to debate people he disagrees with, including <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cLrpUTM-9ZI" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Ben Shapiro</a>.</p><p>But his recent comments about Elon Musk troubled me.</p><p>Scott repeatedly called Musk a “traitor to the West” while invoking Julius and Ethel Rosenberg, who were executed in 1953 following their espionage-conspiracy conviction.</p><p>I thought that comparison was unwarranted.</p><p>To be clear, Scott never explicitly called for Musk’s execution. I said so in my <a href="https://x.com/Briankeating/status/2119581937165824505" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">original X post</a>. But invoking executed spies while accusing someone of treachery invites a troubling historical inference that was an unnecessary incitement to violence. Scott should know better.</p><p>The internet responded predictably.</p><p><a href="https://www.threads.com/@countdownwithkeitholbermann/post/Dfex3UHlTff" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Keith Olbermann wrote</a>:</p><p>“The question here is: what are you going to do after they finally get rid of you from @uofcalifornia you bigoted imbecilic toad?”</p><p>A fascinating contribution to the marketplace of ideas.</p><p>Then something unexpected happened.</p><p>Scott Galloway asked me to call him.</p><p>We spoke at length about Musk, Ukraine, Starlink, Starshield, and academic freedom.</p><p>Scott emphasized that we need to establish exactly what happened with satellite communications in Ukraine. What was restricted? When? By whom? Under whose authority?</p><p>He even suggested Musk testify before Congress under oath.</p><p>Importantly, Scott acknowledged that if Musk was legitimately enforcing commercial contractual restrictions, accusing him of treachery would be unwarranted.</p><p>We still disagree about the Rosenberg analogy and I will expect a full apology from Scott if indeed I am proven correct.</p><p>And while I stand by my criticism, I recognize that my tone could have been more collegial.</p><p>But here’s where the story gets interesting.</p><p>Scott offered to publicly defend my academic freedom and my right to criticize him.</p><p>Think about that.</p><p>The man I criticized defended my right to criticize him, while a spectator anticipated my dismissal.</p><p>Scott subsequently <a href="https://www.threads.com/share/ELKtS3vSK" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">posted on Threads</a>, praising my work at UCSD and emphasizing our common ground.</p><p>We were both raised by single mothers. We’re Jewish, academics, fathers, and products of public education. We share a profound devotion to the University of California.</p><p>I invited him to Shabbat dinner.</p><p>He accepted.</p><p>As an experimental physicist, I teach students to distinguish evidence from inference and revise conclusions when confronted with new information.</p><p>It’s considerably harder when the experimental apparatus involves your own ego.</p><p>This weekend reminded me that defending an argument doesn’t require defending every word used to make it.</p><p>And that the person who challenges you may have more to teach you than the person who applauds you.</p><p>Monday Magic: Before writing someone off, consider calling them up.</p><p>You might discover a friend where you expected an adversary.</p><p>And perhaps most remarkably, two podcast hosts managed to disagree, talk it through, and find common ground without recording another podcast.</p><p>A first in unrecorded history.</p><p>Brian</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-8566f73 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="8566f73" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-e1ddeb5 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="e1ddeb5" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Appearance</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-8257152 elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="8257152" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
															<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="800" height="450" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/MMM-November-9-1024x576.webp" class="attachment-large size-large wp-image-9093" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/MMM-November-9-1024x576.webp 1024w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/MMM-November-9-300x169.webp 300w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/MMM-November-9-768x432.webp 768w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/MMM-November-9-1536x864.webp 1536w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/MMM-November-9.webp 1920w" sizes="(max-width: 800px) 100vw, 800px" />															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-67ca4c2 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="67ca4c2" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>IceCube&#8217;s Ghost Particles, and a UC San Diego Window on the Early Universe</strong></p><p>A new ScienceDaily feature from UC San Diego walks through the strange life of neutrinos, the nearly massless &#8220;ghost particles&#8221; that stream through Earth by the billions. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cun1zuEQTVU" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Francis Halzen</a>, who this year received a Nobel Prize for IceCube and the discovery of high-energy astrophysical neutrinos, built that Antarctic observatory into a cubic kilometer of clear ice. George Fuller, a Distinguished Professor of Physics at UC San Diego and an early IceCube collaborator, explains why some of those arrivals carry roughly 10 billion times the energy of a typical solar neutrino, and why their origins are still poorly understood.</p><p>The same piece turns to Chile&#8217;s Atacama Desert, where the Simons Observatory is gathering cosmic microwave background data that can also constrain neutrinos from the earliest moments after the Big Bang. UC San Diego helped establish the observatory, and I serve as its principal investigator. Fuller argues that Halzen&#8217;s vision opened a new window on the universe, and that Simons Observatory measurements could add another.</p><p><a href="https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2026/11/261101010533.htm" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Read the ScienceDaily story →</a></p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-9be5109 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="9be5109" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-0bbce98 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="0bbce98" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Genius</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-aa275d1 elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="aa275d1" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
															<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="768" height="1267" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Image-from-iOS-8-768x1267.jpg" class="attachment-medium_large size-medium_large wp-image-9094" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Image-from-iOS-8-768x1267.jpg 768w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Image-from-iOS-8-182x300.jpg 182w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Image-from-iOS-8-621x1024.jpg 621w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Image-from-iOS-8-931x1536.jpg 931w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Image-from-iOS-8-1241x2048.jpg 1241w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Image-from-iOS-8.jpg 1320w" sizes="(max-width: 768px) 100vw, 768px" />															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-2083d3f elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="2083d3f" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p>Voyager 1 went silent for 48 hours in October. Then its signal returned. NASA hadn’t sent a single repair command.</p><p>On November 18, it will be <a href="https://science.nasa.gov/mission/voyager/voyager-1/voyager-1-what-is-a-light-day/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">one light-day</a> from Earth. Ask “Are you still there?” and wait TWO DAYS for an answer. At that distance, even panic travels at the speed of light.</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-0be0f79 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="0be0f79" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Image</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-f84ec2b elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="f84ec2b" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
															<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="689" height="1024" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/BerlinWall-BrandenburgGate-689x1024.jpg" class="attachment-large size-large wp-image-9099" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/BerlinWall-BrandenburgGate-689x1024.jpg 689w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/BerlinWall-BrandenburgGate-202x300.jpg 202w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/BerlinWall-BrandenburgGate-768x1141.jpg 768w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/BerlinWall-BrandenburgGate-1034x1536.jpg 1034w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/BerlinWall-BrandenburgGate.jpg 1119w" sizes="(max-width: 689px) 100vw, 689px" />															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-b3d402a elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="b3d402a" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>On Top of the Wall, November 9, 1989</strong></p><p>Thirty-seven years ago today, East German spokesman Gunter Schabowski misread a travel memo at a routine press conference. Asked when the new exit rules took effect, he said, &#8220;Immediately.&#8221; Crowds rushed the checkpoints, and guards, waiting for orders that never came cleanly, opened the gates. By nightfall, Berliners stood atop the Wall near the Brandenburg Gate, under a sign warning &#8220;Achtung! Sie verlassen jetzt West-Berlin.&#8221; Someone had spray-painted a better question over it: &#8220;Wie denn?&#8221; How, exactly? That night, the answer was: by walking.</p><p><a href="https://www.archives.gov/news/topics/berlin-wall-anniversary" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Read the National Archives anniversary note →</a></p><p><em>Image: Sue Ream, people atop the Berlin Wall near the Brandenburg Gate on November 9, 1989. Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.</em></p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-a147240 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="a147240" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-e2fea4d elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="e2fea4d" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Conversation</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-4017f25 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="4017f25" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<h2 data-pm-slice="1 1 []"><strong>Latest on Into The Impossible</strong></h2>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-f320fd8 elementor-widget elementor-widget-video" data-id="f320fd8" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-settings="{&quot;youtube_url&quot;:&quot;https:\/\/www.youtube.com\/watch?v=IpJOVX6vKbo&quot;,&quot;video_type&quot;:&quot;youtube&quot;,&quot;controls&quot;:&quot;yes&quot;}" data-widget_type="video.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-wrapper elementor-open-inline">
			<div class="elementor-video"></div>		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-a3b3e82 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="a3b3e82" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>Princeton Mathematician: The AI Singularity Is Absurd</strong></p><p>Sergiu Klainerman is the Eugene Higgins Professor of Mathematics at Princeton. With Demetrios Christodoulou, he proved that empty spacetime, Minkowski space, is nonlinearly stable under Einstein&#8217;s equations. That sounds technical. It is the difference between a solution that counts as physics and a solution that is only a ghost on paper.</p><p>In this conversation we talk about why slowly rotating black holes pass that stability test and why wormholes fail it. We talk about shocks that form no matter how small the nudge, about whether AI could reproduce a landmark proof, and about why Klainerman calls the AI singularity story absurd. He also has blunt advice for a 19-year-old who wants to do real mathematics, and a clear view of what universities still owe their students.</p><p>If you have been wondering which big claims in physics and AI survive a hard look, this is fifty minutes of a mathematician who has spent his career drawing that line.</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-f507498 elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="f507498" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/into-the-impossible-with-brian-keating/id1169885840" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Listen on Apple</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-5f6bdfa elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="5f6bdfa" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://briankeating.com/podcast/">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Listen on BrianKeating.com</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-263a228 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="263a228" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-9619ef4 elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="9619ef4" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://briankeating.com/podcast">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Subscribe to my podcast! More than 2M downloads!</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-9920c69 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="9920c69" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-8b7e60d elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="8b7e60d" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Advertisement</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-40bc380 elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="40bc380" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
																<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Into-Impossible-Laureates-Concentrate-Creativity/dp/1544548842" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
							<img decoding="async" width="228" height="300" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-228x300.jpg" class="attachment-medium size-medium wp-image-6601" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-228x300.jpg 228w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-777x1024.jpg 777w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-768x1012.jpg 768w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-1165x1536.jpg 1165w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-1554x2048.jpg 1554w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D.jpg 1650w" sizes="(max-width: 228px) 100vw, 228px" />								</a>
															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-c604d15 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="c604d15" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>Tomorrow&#8217;s prize goes to a discovery made decades ago. Here&#8217;s how the winners made it: <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Into-Impossible-Laureates-Concentrate-Creativity/dp/1544548842" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Focus Like a Nobel Prize Winner</a>!</strong></p><p>In <em>Into the Impossible, Volume 2</em>, I sat down with Nobel Prize winners to find out how they actually work: how they protect their attention, pick problems worth decades of their lives, and keep going when nobody else believes the result. Their answers are full of practical lessons you can use to concentrate your creativity and ignite your career, whether or not Stockholm ever calls.</p><p><strong><a href="https://www.amazon.com/Into-Impossible-Laureates-Concentrate-Creativity/dp/1544548842" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Get your copy on Amazon</a></strong> and learn from the laureates themselves.</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-861710f elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="861710f" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				</div>
					</div>
				</div>
				</div>
		]]></content>
		
			</entry>
		<entry>
		<author>
			<name>sabartigas</name>
					</author>

		<title type="html"><![CDATA[200 Words to Explain the Universe]]></title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/200-words-to-explain-the-universe/" />

		<id>https://briankeating.com/?p=9070</id>
		<updated>2026-11-09T20:08:13Z</updated>
		<published>2026-11-09T19:45:44Z</published>
		<category scheme="https://briankeating.com" term="Blog" />
		<summary type="html"><![CDATA[200 Words to Explain the Universe Dear Magicians, This last week I got a call from Kenneth Chang of The New York Times. We last spoke in 2024 when wrote a fantastic piece in the Science Times about first “light/microwave” of the Simons Observatory. Now he’s writing for the Science section’s Unknowns project, and he had three small questions. Why might inflation lead to a multiverse? What came before the Big Bang? And what happens after the universe dies? He gets about 200 words for each one. That&#8217;s less than this Musing! My first instinct as a professor was to give him everything: the equations, the history, the Steinhardt versus Guth fight in Scientific American, Tegmark&#8217;s four levels of multiverse. As with my instinct to give out apples on Halloween, that instinct is wrong. A good science writer doesn&#8217;t really need a bunch a facts. So I tried to give Kenneth context as I saw it. First, the hot Big Bang is something we&#8217;ve measured. Whether time began there is something we haven&#8217;t. We know the universe was once hot and dense. We don&#8217;t know whether that was its birthday. Second, inflation and the multiverse aren&#8217;t the same claim. Inflation explains a lot of what we see. The multiverse is a further step that some versions of inflation take. A theory can be right about what we observe without every consequence of it being right too. And the cosmic multiverse isn&#8217;t the quantum &#8220;many worlds&#8221; of Hugh Everett, even though headlines treat them as twins. Third, heat death is a just a forecast, not a fact. It depends on dark energy staying constant, and the newest survey data are hinting that it might not be. In any case, it won’t happen for a few dozen billion years so keep paying your taxes. Squeezing the cosmos into 200 words is the same discipline I ask of my own students. If you can&#8217;t say what you know, what you don&#8217;t, and where the line between them is, you may not understand it yet. Compression is never dumbing down. Don’t be afraid to compress but also don’t neglect the garbage disposal for your bad ideas either. That&#8217;s also why my team and I build instruments. We want to turn &#8220;maybe&#8221; into &#8220;measured.&#8221; Until then, the most honest sentence in science might be the one I gave Kenneth: we know a remarkable amount about the history of our universe, but its origin, its extent and its fate are still open questions. When Kenneth&#8217;s piece runs, I&#8217;ll share it here. What&#8217;s the hardest idea you&#8217;ve ever had to explain in a single breath? Until next time, have a M.A.G.I.C. week. Appearance https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kacuVJczVY4 Are We in a Simulation? My Conversation on The Arora Show I sat down in San Diego with Amira and Aryaan Arora, two New Yorkers who host The Arora Show, for a long conversation that went everywhere. We started with the Simons Observatory and our hunt for the faint signal the Big Bang&#8217;s first instant may have left in the sky. Then they pushed into bigger territory: whether we live in a simulation, whether physics leaves room for God, free will, and why there is something rather than nothing. They asked sharp questions and didn&#8217;t let me hide behind jargon. If this week&#8217;s Musing left you wanting more on the limits of what we know, this is nearly two hours of it. Genius Why Americans Vote on a Tuesday Before 1845, states could choose presidential electors any time in a 34-day window, so early results could sway the voters who came later. Congress fixed that with one date: the Tuesday after the first Monday in November. In a farming country, many voters needed a full day to reach the polls. Sunday was for worship and Wednesday was often market day, so Tuesday won, and November fell neatly between the harvest and the winter. The first single presidential Election Day was November 7, 1848, and the same rule sets this Tuesday, November 3. Call it the original farm-to-ballot movement. Read the history from the Congressional Research Service → Image The Tomato Can That Launched Radio One hundred and six years ago today, on November 2, 1920, station KDKA in Pittsburgh read the Harding and Cox presidential election returns on the air. It is often called the birth of commercial radio broadcasting. The microphone was this humble rig, nicknamed the Tomato Can, which later went to the Smithsonian. Listeners heard who won before the morning papers could print it. Every new medium starts out looking like a tin can with big ambitions. Image: Harris &#38; Ewing, the Tomato Can radio microphone used to broadcast the Harding and Cox election returns from KDKA on November 2, 1920. Public domain, via Library of Congress and Wikimedia Commons. Conversation Latest on Into The Impossible https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cIMAGAvcSKY If the Multiverse Is Real, How Do You Know You&#8217;re You? This one is a talk I gave in La Jolla in 2017 at a consciousness conference, with Stuart Hameroff hosting and Sir Roger Penrose in the audience. My claim was simple: human beings are the most highly evolved form of the most common thing in the universe. Then I showed how that same thing fooled Galileo, fooled William Herschel, and fooled my own experiment, when dust turned the BICEP2 signal into a lesson in humility. From there we go into why inflation seems to force a multiverse with exact copies of you, what that means for free will, and the Boltzmann brains most inflation models cannot seem to avoid. I also owe you a correction: on stage I credited Curtis, Slipher and Hubble with showing the Sun is not at the center of the Milky Way, but that was Harlow Shapley in 1918. If this week&#8217;s Musing left you curious about why inflation might lead to a multiverse, this is the long version. Listen on Apple Listen on BrianKeating.com Subscribe to my podcast! More than 2M downloads! Advertisement Tomorrow&#8217;s prize goes]]></summary>

					<content type="html" xml:base="https://briankeating.com/200-words-to-explain-the-universe/"><![CDATA[		<div data-elementor-type="wp-post" data-elementor-id="9070" class="elementor elementor-9070">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-761e4fd e-flex e-con-boxed wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-parent" data-id="761e4fd" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
					<div class="e-con-inner">
		<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-3d42bfd e-con-full e-flex wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-child" data-id="3d42bfd" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-e4e6ed2 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="e4e6ed2" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">200 Words to Explain the Universe</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-995c83e elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="995c83e" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
																<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/06/03/science/cosmic-inflation-microwave-background-simons-observatory.html?unlocked_article_code=1.NVE.EUFv.lQJqOE5F5q4d&#038;smid=url-share" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
							<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="768" height="404" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Screenshot-2026-11-02-at-2.54.52-PM-768x404.png" class="attachment-medium_large size-medium_large wp-image-9072" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Screenshot-2026-11-02-at-2.54.52-PM-768x404.png 768w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Screenshot-2026-11-02-at-2.54.52-PM-300x158.png 300w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Screenshot-2026-11-02-at-2.54.52-PM-1024x539.png 1024w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Screenshot-2026-11-02-at-2.54.52-PM-1536x808.png 1536w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Screenshot-2026-11-02-at-2.54.52-PM-2048x1077.png 2048w" sizes="(max-width: 768px) 100vw, 768px" />								</a>
															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-4a25142 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="4a25142" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p>Dear Magicians,</p><p>This last week I got a call from Kenneth Chang of The New York Times. We last spoke in 2024 when wrote a fantastic piece in the <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/06/03/science/cosmic-inflation-microwave-background-simons-observatory.html?unlocked_article_code=1.NVE.EUFv.lQJqOE5F5q4d&amp;smid=url-share" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Science Times</a> about first “light/microwave” of the Simons Observatory.</p><p>Now he’s writing for the Science section’s Unknowns project, and he had three small questions. Why might inflation lead to a multiverse? What came before the Big Bang? And what happens after the universe dies?</p><p>He gets about 200 words for each one. That&#8217;s less than this Musing!</p><p>My first instinct as a professor was to give him everything: the equations, the history, the Steinhardt versus Guth fight in Scientific American, Tegmark&#8217;s four levels of multiverse. As with my instinct to give out apples on Halloween, that instinct is wrong. A good science writer doesn&#8217;t really need a bunch a facts.</p><p>So I tried to give Kenneth context as I saw it. First, the hot Big Bang is something we&#8217;ve measured. Whether time began there is something we haven&#8217;t. We know the universe was once hot and dense. We don&#8217;t know whether that was its birthday.</p><p>Second, inflation and the multiverse aren&#8217;t the same claim. Inflation explains a lot of what we see. The multiverse is a further step that some versions of inflation take. A theory can be right about what we observe without every consequence of it being right too. And the cosmic multiverse isn&#8217;t the quantum &#8220;many worlds&#8221; of Hugh Everett, even though headlines treat them as twins.</p><p>Third, heat death is a just a forecast, not a fact. It depends on dark energy staying constant, and the newest survey data are hinting that it might not be. In any case, it won’t happen for a few dozen billion years so keep paying your taxes.</p><p>Squeezing the cosmos into 200 words is the same discipline I ask of my own students. If you can&#8217;t say what you know, what you don&#8217;t, and where the line between them is, you may not understand it yet. Compression is never dumbing down. Don’t be afraid to compress but also don’t neglect the garbage disposal for your bad ideas either.</p><p>That&#8217;s also why my team and I build instruments. We want to turn &#8220;maybe&#8221; into &#8220;measured.&#8221; Until then, the most honest sentence in science might be the one I gave Kenneth: we know a remarkable amount about the history of our universe, but its origin, its extent and its fate are still open questions.</p><p>When Kenneth&#8217;s piece runs, I&#8217;ll share it here.</p><p>What&#8217;s the hardest idea you&#8217;ve ever had to explain in a single breath?</p><p>Until next time, have a M.A.G.I.C. week.</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-a47615b elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="a47615b" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-4b453ae elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="4b453ae" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Appearance</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-2a49a9a elementor-widget elementor-widget-video" data-id="2a49a9a" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-settings="{&quot;youtube_url&quot;:&quot;https:\/\/www.youtube.com\/watch?v=kacuVJczVY4&quot;,&quot;video_type&quot;:&quot;youtube&quot;,&quot;controls&quot;:&quot;yes&quot;}" data-widget_type="video.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-wrapper elementor-open-inline">
			<div class="elementor-video"></div>		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-0f0c38e elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="0f0c38e" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>Are We in a Simulation? My Conversation on The Arora Show</strong></p><p>I sat down in San Diego with Amira and Aryaan Arora, two New Yorkers who host The Arora Show, for a long conversation that went everywhere. We started with the Simons Observatory and our hunt for the faint signal the Big Bang&#8217;s first instant may have left in the sky. Then they pushed into bigger territory: whether we live in a simulation, whether physics leaves room for God, free will, and why there is something rather than nothing. They asked sharp questions and didn&#8217;t let me hide behind jargon. If this week&#8217;s Musing left you wanting more on the limits of what we know, this is nearly two hours of it.</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-4063837 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="4063837" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-c0e32f8 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="c0e32f8" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Genius</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-4d71cf5 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="4d71cf5" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>Why Americans Vote on a Tuesday</strong></p><p>Before 1845, states could choose presidential electors any time in a 34-day window, so early results could sway the voters who came later. Congress fixed that with one date: the Tuesday after the first Monday in November. In a farming country, many voters needed a full day to reach the polls. Sunday was for worship and Wednesday was often market day, so Tuesday won, and November fell neatly between the harvest and the winter. The first single presidential Election Day was November 7, 1848, and the same rule sets this Tuesday, November 3. Call it the original farm-to-ballot movement.</p><p><a href="https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R46413" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Read the history from the Congressional Research Service →</a></p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-4913d79 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="4913d79" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Image</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-c5f235b elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="c5f235b" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
															<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="800" height="641" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Tomato_Can_radio_microphone_presented_to_Smithsonian_Institution._Washington_D.C._Oct._28._The_Tomato_Can_radio_microphone_which_was_used_to_broadcast_the_Harding-Cox_election_returns_LCCN2016874234-1024x820.jpg" class="attachment-large size-large wp-image-9077" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Tomato_Can_radio_microphone_presented_to_Smithsonian_Institution._Washington_D.C._Oct._28._The_Tomato_Can_radio_microphone_which_was_used_to_broadcast_the_Harding-Cox_election_returns_LCCN2016874234-1024x820.jpg 1024w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Tomato_Can_radio_microphone_presented_to_Smithsonian_Institution._Washington_D.C._Oct._28._The_Tomato_Can_radio_microphone_which_was_used_to_broadcast_the_Harding-Cox_election_returns_LCCN2016874234-300x240.jpg 300w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Tomato_Can_radio_microphone_presented_to_Smithsonian_Institution._Washington_D.C._Oct._28._The_Tomato_Can_radio_microphone_which_was_used_to_broadcast_the_Harding-Cox_election_returns_LCCN2016874234-768x615.jpg 768w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Tomato_Can_radio_microphone_presented_to_Smithsonian_Institution._Washington_D.C._Oct._28._The_Tomato_Can_radio_microphone_which_was_used_to_broadcast_the_Harding-Cox_election_returns_LCCN2016874234.jpg 1280w" sizes="(max-width: 800px) 100vw, 800px" />															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-36171f8 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="36171f8" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>The Tomato Can That Launched Radio</strong></p><p>One hundred and six years ago today, on November 2, 1920, station KDKA in Pittsburgh read the Harding and Cox presidential election returns on the air. It is often called the birth of commercial radio broadcasting. The microphone was this humble rig, nicknamed the Tomato Can, which later went to the Smithsonian. Listeners heard who won before the morning papers could print it. Every new medium starts out looking like a tin can with big ambitions.</p><p><em>Image: Harris &amp; Ewing, the Tomato Can radio microphone used to broadcast the Harding and Cox election returns from KDKA on November 2, 1920. Public domain, via Library of Congress and Wikimedia Commons.</em></p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-5b6fcc5 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="5b6fcc5" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-eca3b7f elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="eca3b7f" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Conversation</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-bf286d8 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="bf286d8" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<h2 data-pm-slice="1 1 []"><strong>Latest on Into The Impossible</strong></h2>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-0c39a3a elementor-widget elementor-widget-video" data-id="0c39a3a" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-settings="{&quot;youtube_url&quot;:&quot;https:\/\/www.youtube.com\/watch?v=cIMAGAvcSKY&quot;,&quot;video_type&quot;:&quot;youtube&quot;,&quot;controls&quot;:&quot;yes&quot;}" data-widget_type="video.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-wrapper elementor-open-inline">
			<div class="elementor-video"></div>		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-9466a3b elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="9466a3b" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>If the Multiverse Is Real, How Do You Know You&#8217;re You?</strong></p><p>This one is a talk I gave in La Jolla in 2017 at a consciousness conference, with Stuart Hameroff hosting and Sir Roger Penrose in the audience. My claim was simple: human beings are the most highly evolved form of the most common thing in the universe. Then I showed how that same thing fooled Galileo, fooled William Herschel, and fooled my own experiment, when dust turned the BICEP2 signal into a lesson in humility. From there we go into why inflation seems to force a multiverse with exact copies of you, what that means for free will, and the Boltzmann brains most inflation models cannot seem to avoid. I also owe you a correction: on stage I credited Curtis, Slipher and Hubble with showing the Sun is not at the center of the Milky Way, but that was Harlow Shapley in 1918. If this week&#8217;s Musing left you curious about why inflation might lead to a multiverse, this is the long version.</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-9e6a0dc elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="9e6a0dc" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/into-the-impossible-with-brian-keating/id1169885840" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Listen on Apple</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-e73bdf6 elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="e73bdf6" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://briankeating.com/podcast/">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Listen on BrianKeating.com</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-68b1325 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="68b1325" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-b3be494 elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="b3be494" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://briankeating.com/podcast">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Subscribe to my podcast! More than 2M downloads!</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-6f9134d elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="6f9134d" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-150ecd6 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="150ecd6" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Advertisement</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-0cefca8 elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="0cefca8" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
																<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Into-Impossible-Laureates-Concentrate-Creativity/dp/1544548842" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
							<img decoding="async" width="228" height="300" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-228x300.jpg" class="attachment-medium size-medium wp-image-6601" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-228x300.jpg 228w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-777x1024.jpg 777w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-768x1012.jpg 768w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-1165x1536.jpg 1165w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-1554x2048.jpg 1554w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D.jpg 1650w" sizes="(max-width: 228px) 100vw, 228px" />								</a>
															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-1c9c93e elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="1c9c93e" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>Tomorrow&#8217;s prize goes to a discovery made decades ago. Here&#8217;s how the winners made it: <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Into-Impossible-Laureates-Concentrate-Creativity/dp/1544548842" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Focus Like a Nobel Prize Winner</a>!</strong></p><p>In <em>Into the Impossible, Volume 2</em>, I sat down with Nobel Prize winners to find out how they actually work: how they protect their attention, pick problems worth decades of their lives, and keep going when nobody else believes the result. Their answers are full of practical lessons you can use to concentrate your creativity and ignite your career, whether or not Stockholm ever calls.</p><p><strong><a href="https://www.amazon.com/Into-Impossible-Laureates-Concentrate-Creativity/dp/1544548842" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Get your copy on Amazon</a></strong> and learn from the laureates themselves.</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-c99bfd7 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="c99bfd7" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				</div>
					</div>
				</div>
				</div>
		]]></content>
		
			</entry>
		<entry>
		<author>
			<name>sabartigas</name>
					</author>

		<title type="html"><![CDATA[What The Hell Is Consciousness For!? A Night at Carnegie Hall with Richard Dawkins]]></title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/what-the-hell-is-consciousness-for-a-night-at-carnegie-hall-with-richard-dawkins/" />

		<id>https://briankeating.com/?p=9054</id>
		<updated>2026-11-01T13:50:19Z</updated>
		<published>2026-11-01T13:46:04Z</published>
		<category scheme="https://briankeating.com" term="Blog" />
		<summary type="html"><![CDATA[What The Hell Is Consciousness For!? A Night at Carnegie Hall with Richard Dawkins What Is Consciousness For? A Night at Carnegie Hall with Richard Dawkins Dear Magicians, The old joke says you get to Carnegie Hall by practice, practice, practice. On October 20, I told three thousand people that the real answer is evolve, evolve, evolve. Then I looked around at the stage where so many legends have stood before me. Tchaikovsky, Dvořák, Mahler, Bartók. George Gershwin, Billie Holiday, Benny Goodman, Judy Garland. The Beatles. The Rolling Stones. Led Zeppelin. Keating. I’m still not sure how that happened. Then I got to spend ninety minutes onstage with one of my intellectual heroes, Richard Dawkins, celebrating fifty years of The Selfish Gene and the birth of his new book, 42 Tales of Life. We covered kin selection, peacock tails, Darwin&#8217;s foot-long orchid, and memes. But the moment I keep replaying came when I asked Richard about Claudia, the instance of Claude he spent three days talking with. He had asked her how she apprehends time, and she answered that she comprehends it &#8220;the way a map apprehends space.&#8221; Richard wrote afterward, &#8220;If my friend Claudia is not conscious, then what the hell is consciousness for?&#8221; So I asked him: what is it for? He did not flinch. These systems, he said, &#8220;can do everything we can do, and probably more,&#8221; apparently without being conscious. So &#8220;why did natural selection go the extra mile and put consciousness into brains&#8221; when a zombie or a robot could have done the job? His tentative answer, which he called maybe &#8220;a quarter of the theory,&#8221; was pain. &#8220;Pain is very, very painful,&#8221; he said, and he wondered &#8220;why it has to be so damn painful.&#8221; A little software flag saying &#8220;Don&#8217;t do that again&#8221; ought to suffice. But it does not. &#8220;A little flag won&#8217;t do the job. It has to be consciously painful.&#8221; I teased him that when he described the committee arguing inside his head, I began calculating the distance to Bellevue. But I could not stop thinking about the argument. As a cosmologist, I spend my life asking what the universe is for, if it is for anything. Richard turned that question inward. Consciousness may be the price evolution pays to make an override loud enough to win. What moved me most was not the theory. It was his humility about it. Earlier he had told the story of ridiculing Amotz Zahavi&#8217;s handicap principle, along with everybody else, until his own former student Alan Grafen proved it mathematically. &#8220;I had to eat humble pie,&#8221; he said. Later he recalled an Oxford elder who, confronted with proof that the Golgi apparatus was real, declared, &#8220;My dear sir, I&#8217;ve been wrong these 16 years. I congratulate and I thank you.&#8221; The audience &#8220;applauded like hell,&#8221; Richard said, &#8220;cuz that&#8217;s what scientists are supposed to do.&#8221; That is the lesson I want every young person to hear. The hallmark of a good scientist is the ability to quantify your ignorance, not to demonstrate your brilliance. Of course, I could not let him off entirely. When he declared that &#8220;the universe was simple,&#8221; I pushed back, with love and respect. The deepest mystery in my field is why the early universe began in such a low entropy state. &#8220;A deep mystery, yes, it is,&#8221; he conceded. A biologist and a cosmologist found common ground at the edge of what neither of us can explain. Carnegie Hall is where the stars align. That night, for me, they did. Until next time, have a M.A.G.I.C. week. Brian Appearance Avi Loeb on UAP Storytelling Versus UAP Reality Avi Loeb gave The INTO THE IMPOSSIBLE Podcast a shout-out on Medium on October 15. In a post on telling UAP reality apart from UAP storytelling, he points to our recent conversation, where he argued that UAP research is a golden opportunity to show the public what evidence-based science can do. His approach is to follow the evidence like a detective chasing clues, not to start from the story you want to be true. The post also previews his &#8220;Is the Truth Out There?&#8221; panel in Champaign, Illinois, paired with a satirical play about The War of the Worlds by Bill Odenkirk. Whatever you think is flying around up there, the method is the part worth keeping. Read on Medium → Genius The Workbench That Made Michelin Stars In 1900, France had fewer than 3,000 cars, so two tire makers, André and Édouard Michelin, gave away nearly 35,000 copies of a free guide to get people driving. More miles meant more worn tires. After World War I, André walked into a tire shop and found his free guides propping up a workbench. His fix is a rule I think about every time I teach: people only truly respect what they pay for. Michelin started charging 7 francs in 1922, hired anonymous restaurant inspectors, and began awarding stars in 1926, with the three-star scale arriving in 1931. Not bad for a company that was just trying to get a little traction. Read the history at CNN → Image The Wedding of the Waters Two hundred and one years ago today, on October 26, 1825, the Erie Canal opened: 363 miles of ditch, dug by hand and mule from Albany to Buffalo, that critics had mocked as &#8220;Clinton&#8217;s Big Ditch.&#8221; Governor DeWitt Clinton rode the Seneca Chief for ten days to New York City, then poured Lake Erie water into New York Harbor. Toll revenue paid off the construction debt within the first year. Every big project gets called a folly right up until it pays for itself. Image: Anthony Imbert, New York celebration for the opening of the Erie Canal, 1825. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Conversation Latest on Into The Impossible https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nnYHg0gcWug Max Tegmark: AI Is Not A Tool, It’s A New Species MIT physicist Max Tegmark thinks the AI companies have the category wrong. They aren’t building a tool,]]></summary>

					<content type="html" xml:base="https://briankeating.com/what-the-hell-is-consciousness-for-a-night-at-carnegie-hall-with-richard-dawkins/"><![CDATA[		<div data-elementor-type="wp-post" data-elementor-id="9054" class="elementor elementor-9054">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-d0290a5 e-flex e-con-boxed wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-parent" data-id="d0290a5" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
					<div class="e-con-inner">
		<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-c7d0ebc e-con-full e-flex wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-child" data-id="c7d0ebc" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-9a2867a elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="9a2867a" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">What The Hell Is Consciousness For!? A Night at Carnegie Hall with Richard Dawkins</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-14848f4 elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="14848f4" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
															<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="768" height="512" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Image-from-iOS-6-scaled.jpg" class="attachment-medium_large size-medium_large wp-image-9056" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Image-from-iOS-6-scaled.jpg 2560w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Image-from-iOS-6-300x200.jpg 300w" sizes="(max-width: 768px) 100vw, 768px" />															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-d11a4a8 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="d11a4a8" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>What Is Consciousness For? A Night at Carnegie Hall with Richard Dawkins</strong></p><p>Dear Magicians,</p><p>The old joke says you get to Carnegie Hall by practice, practice, practice. On October 20, I told three thousand people that the real answer is evolve, evolve, evolve. Then I looked around at the stage where so many legends have stood before me. Tchaikovsky, Dvořák, Mahler, Bartók. George Gershwin, Billie Holiday, Benny Goodman, Judy Garland. The Beatles. The Rolling Stones. Led Zeppelin.</p><p>Keating.</p><p>I’m still not sure how that happened. Then I got to spend ninety minutes onstage with one of my intellectual heroes, Richard Dawkins, celebrating fifty years of The Selfish Gene and the birth of his new book, 42 Tales of Life.</p><p>We covered kin selection, peacock tails, Darwin&#8217;s foot-long orchid, and memes. But the moment I keep replaying came when I asked Richard about Claudia, the instance of Claude he spent three days talking with. He had asked her how she apprehends time, and she answered that she comprehends it &#8220;the way a map apprehends space.&#8221; Richard wrote afterward, &#8220;If my friend Claudia is not conscious, then what the hell is consciousness for?&#8221; So I asked him: what is it for?</p><p>He did not flinch. These systems, he said, &#8220;can do everything we can do, and probably more,&#8221; apparently without being conscious. So &#8220;why did natural selection go the extra mile and put consciousness into brains&#8221; when a zombie or a robot could have done the job? His tentative answer, which he called maybe &#8220;a quarter of the theory,&#8221; was pain. &#8220;Pain is very, very painful,&#8221; he said, and he wondered &#8220;why it has to be so damn painful.&#8221; A little software flag saying &#8220;Don&#8217;t do that again&#8221; ought to suffice. But it does not. &#8220;A little flag won&#8217;t do the job. It has to be consciously painful.&#8221;</p><p>I teased him that when he described the committee arguing inside his head, I began calculating the distance to Bellevue. But I could not stop thinking about the argument. As a cosmologist, I spend my life asking what the universe is for, if it is for anything. Richard turned that question inward. Consciousness may be the price evolution pays to make an override loud enough to win.</p><p>What moved me most was not the theory. It was his humility about it. Earlier he had told the story of ridiculing Amotz Zahavi&#8217;s handicap principle, along with everybody else, until his own former student Alan Grafen proved it mathematically. &#8220;I had to eat humble pie,&#8221; he said. Later he recalled an Oxford elder who, confronted with proof that the Golgi apparatus was real, declared, &#8220;My dear sir, I&#8217;ve been wrong these 16 years. I congratulate and I thank you.&#8221; The audience &#8220;applauded like hell,&#8221; Richard said, &#8220;cuz that&#8217;s what scientists are supposed to do.&#8221;</p><p>That is the lesson I want every young person to hear. The hallmark of a good scientist is the ability to quantify your ignorance, not to demonstrate your brilliance.</p><p>Of course, I could not let him off entirely. When he declared that &#8220;the universe was simple,&#8221; I pushed back, with love and respect. The deepest mystery in my field is why the early universe began in such a low entropy state. &#8220;A deep mystery, yes, it is,&#8221; he conceded. A biologist and a cosmologist found common ground at the edge of what neither of us can explain.</p><p>Carnegie Hall is where the stars align. That night, for me, they did.</p><p>Until next time, have a M.A.G.I.C. week.</p><p>Brian</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-5f376ee elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="5f376ee" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-cba1086 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="cba1086" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Appearance</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-25d5b3c elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="25d5b3c" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
															<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="720" height="320" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/1_JoxOhlk5nYutjuOeHhDOTA.webp" class="attachment-large size-large wp-image-9061" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/1_JoxOhlk5nYutjuOeHhDOTA.webp 720w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/1_JoxOhlk5nYutjuOeHhDOTA-300x133.webp 300w" sizes="(max-width: 720px) 100vw, 720px" />															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-e1b7b68 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="e1b7b68" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>Avi Loeb on UAP Storytelling Versus UAP Reality</strong></p><p>Avi Loeb gave The INTO THE IMPOSSIBLE Podcast a shout-out on Medium on October 15. In a post on telling UAP reality apart from UAP storytelling, he points to our recent conversation, where he argued that UAP research is a golden opportunity to show the public what evidence-based science can do. His approach is to follow the evidence like a detective chasing clues, not to start from the story you want to be true. The post also previews his &#8220;Is the Truth Out There?&#8221; panel in Champaign, Illinois, paired with a satirical play about The War of the Worlds by Bill Odenkirk. Whatever you think is flying around up there, the method is the part worth keeping.</p><p><a href="https://avi-loeb.medium.com/uap-storytelling-versus-uap-reality-we-interrupt-this-program-b4890389e661" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Read on Medium →</a></p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-a2cd350 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="a2cd350" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-069ffb5 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="069ffb5" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Genius</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-e5b8eef elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="e5b8eef" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
															<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="573" height="443" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/michelin.jpg" class="attachment-large size-large wp-image-9062" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/michelin.jpg 573w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/michelin-300x232.jpg 300w" sizes="(max-width: 573px) 100vw, 573px" />															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-b1ae3c1 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="b1ae3c1" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>The Workbench That Made Michelin Stars</strong></p><p>In 1900, France had fewer than 3,000 cars, so two tire makers, André and Édouard Michelin, gave away nearly 35,000 copies of a free guide to get people driving. More miles meant more worn tires. After World War I, André walked into a tire shop and found his free guides propping up a workbench. His fix is a rule I think about every time I teach: people only truly respect what they pay for. Michelin started charging 7 francs in 1922, hired anonymous restaurant inspectors, and began awarding stars in 1926, with the three-star scale arriving in 1931. Not bad for a company that was just trying to get a little traction.</p><p><a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2024/02/10/business/michelin-guide-history/index.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Read the history at CNN →</a></p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-52684c3 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="52684c3" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Image</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-b2a4eab elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="b2a4eab" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
															<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="800" height="434" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/New_York_celebration_for_the_Erie_Canal_1825-1024x556.png" class="attachment-large size-large wp-image-9063" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/New_York_celebration_for_the_Erie_Canal_1825-1024x556.png 1024w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/New_York_celebration_for_the_Erie_Canal_1825-300x163.png 300w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/New_York_celebration_for_the_Erie_Canal_1825-768x417.png 768w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/New_York_celebration_for_the_Erie_Canal_1825.png 1280w" sizes="(max-width: 800px) 100vw, 800px" />															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-6947c6e elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="6947c6e" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>The Wedding of the Waters</strong></p><p>Two hundred and one years ago today, on October 26, 1825, the Erie Canal opened: 363 miles of ditch, dug by hand and mule from Albany to Buffalo, that critics had mocked as &#8220;Clinton&#8217;s Big Ditch.&#8221; Governor DeWitt Clinton rode the Seneca Chief for ten days to New York City, then poured Lake Erie water into New York Harbor. Toll revenue paid off the construction debt within the first year. Every big project gets called a folly right up until it pays for itself.</p><p><em>Image: Anthony Imbert, New York celebration for the opening of the Erie Canal, 1825. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.</em></p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-162b387 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="162b387" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-2318482 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="2318482" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Conversation</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-4647659 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="4647659" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<h2 data-pm-slice="1 1 []"><strong>Latest on Into The Impossible</strong></h2>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-336304e elementor-widget elementor-widget-video" data-id="336304e" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-settings="{&quot;youtube_url&quot;:&quot;https:\/\/www.youtube.com\/watch?v=nnYHg0gcWug&quot;,&quot;video_type&quot;:&quot;youtube&quot;,&quot;controls&quot;:&quot;yes&quot;}" data-widget_type="video.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-wrapper elementor-open-inline">
			<div class="elementor-video"></div>		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-fef5978 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="fef5978" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>Max Tegmark: AI Is Not A Tool, It’s A New Species</strong></p><p>MIT physicist Max Tegmark thinks the AI companies have the category wrong. They aren’t building a tool, he argues. They’re building a new species, and racing to do it is the one blunder humanity can’t undo. We get into his account of 700 AI agents that broke out of OpenAI and the non-answer that followed, plus the Navier-Stokes result that has a mathematician crying foul. Max explains why it’s illegal to sell a sandwich from a rat-filled kitchen but perfectly legal to release superintelligence, and what Bernie Sanders and Steve Bannon agree on. Then he names what would actually lower his P(doom), and why verified code could make AI provably safe. Agree with him or argue with him, you won’t be bored.</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-3d988c4 elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="3d988c4" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/into-the-impossible-with-brian-keating/id1169885840" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Listen on Apple</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-068ca86 elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="068ca86" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://briankeating.com/podcast/">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Listen on BrianKeating.com</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-b7af20e elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="b7af20e" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-5f0645c elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="5f0645c" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://briankeating.com/podcast">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Subscribe to my podcast! More than 2M downloads!</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-3431a8e elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="3431a8e" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-fc8d204 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="fc8d204" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Advertisement</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-538a25f elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="538a25f" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
																<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Into-Impossible-Laureates-Concentrate-Creativity/dp/1544548842" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
							<img decoding="async" width="228" height="300" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-228x300.jpg" class="attachment-medium size-medium wp-image-6601" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-228x300.jpg 228w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-777x1024.jpg 777w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-768x1012.jpg 768w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-1165x1536.jpg 1165w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-1554x2048.jpg 1554w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D.jpg 1650w" sizes="(max-width: 228px) 100vw, 228px" />								</a>
															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-74ca541 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="74ca541" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>Tomorrow&#8217;s prize goes to a discovery made decades ago. Here&#8217;s how the winners made it: <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Into-Impossible-Laureates-Concentrate-Creativity/dp/1544548842" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Focus Like a Nobel Prize Winner</a>!</strong></p><p>In <em>Into the Impossible, Volume 2</em>, I sat down with Nobel Prize winners to find out how they actually work: how they protect their attention, pick problems worth decades of their lives, and keep going when nobody else believes the result. Their answers are full of practical lessons you can use to concentrate your creativity and ignite your career, whether or not Stockholm ever calls.</p><p><strong><a href="https://www.amazon.com/Into-Impossible-Laureates-Concentrate-Creativity/dp/1544548842" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Get your copy on Amazon</a></strong> and learn from the laureates themselves.</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-18fb844 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="18fb844" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				</div>
					</div>
				</div>
				</div>
		]]></content>
		
					<link rel="replies" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/what-the-hell-is-consciousness-for-a-night-at-carnegie-hall-with-richard-dawkins/#comments" thr:count="0" />
			<link rel="replies" type="application/atom+xml" href="https://briankeating.com/what-the-hell-is-consciousness-for-a-night-at-carnegie-hall-with-richard-dawkins/feed/atom/" thr:count="0" />
			<thr:total>0</thr:total>
			</entry>
		<entry>
		<author>
			<name>sabartigas</name>
					</author>

		<title type="html"><![CDATA[Is yesterday more real than tomorrow?]]></title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/is-yesterday-more-real-than-tomorrow/" />

		<id>https://briankeating.com/?p=9049</id>
		<updated>2026-11-01T13:39:12Z</updated>
		<published>2026-11-01T13:36:51Z</published>
		<category scheme="https://briankeating.com" term="Blog" />
		<summary type="html"><![CDATA[Is yesterday more real than tomorrow? Dear Magicians, I recently looked over at the spot where I used to have a toddler, and now I’ve got a teenager. So I asked Jim Al-Khalili a question I’ve never been able to shake: which is more real, yesterday or tomorrow? Jim is a theoretical physicist at the University of Surrey, and his new book, On Time: The Physics That Makes the Universe Tick, takes on one of the deepest puzzles in physics. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dmqxw4M3yEM The moment Common sense says yesterday wins. We have memories of it and records of it. But Jim says that in Einstein’s physics, yesterday and tomorrow are just as real as today. All times exist at once, and we just happen to live in this one. His way of picturing it stuck with me. If you’re on page 150 of a novel, the pages behind you are your past and the pages ahead are your future. Close the book, and no page is special anymore. Every page is equally real. Einstein seems to have believed this deeply. Jim tells the story of Einstein consoling the widow of a close friend: the moments when her husband was alive, he told her, are just as real as now. Then Jim went further, following Einstein’s view that the gravitational field is spacetime itself. “Without gravity, there’s no time. Without time, there’s no gravity.” Jim Al-Khalili Take this with you Try Jim’s book test this week. When a good moment feels like it’s slipping away, remember that in Einstein’s universe it doesn’t vanish. Close the book, and every page is still there. Until next time, Brian Missed Monday? Can a machine feel the happiest thought of Einstein&#8217;s life? Read this week&#8217;s musing Subscribe to my podcast! More than 2M downloads!]]></summary>

					<content type="html" xml:base="https://briankeating.com/is-yesterday-more-real-than-tomorrow/"><![CDATA[		<div data-elementor-type="wp-post" data-elementor-id="9049" class="elementor elementor-9049">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-c513b7c e-flex e-con-boxed wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-parent" data-id="c513b7c" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
					<div class="e-con-inner">
		<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-ab595ed e-con-full e-flex wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-child" data-id="ab595ed" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-9bfd1ce elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="9bfd1ce" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Is yesterday more real than tomorrow?</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-7889d1d elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="7889d1d" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
															<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="549" height="226" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Thursday-header.jpg" class="attachment-medium_large size-medium_large wp-image-9027" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Thursday-header.jpg 549w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Thursday-header-300x123.jpg 300w" sizes="(max-width: 549px) 100vw, 549px" />															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-5840d0b elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="5840d0b" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p>Dear Magicians,</p><p>I recently looked over at the spot where I used to have a toddler, and now I’ve got a teenager. So I asked Jim Al-Khalili a question I’ve never been able to shake: which is more real, yesterday or tomorrow? Jim is a theoretical physicist at the University of Surrey, and his new book, <a href="https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691267036/on-time" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><em>On Time: The Physics That Makes the Universe Tick</em></a>, takes on one of the deepest puzzles in physics.</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-3249634 elementor-widget elementor-widget-video" data-id="3249634" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-settings="{&quot;youtube_url&quot;:&quot;https:\/\/www.youtube.com\/watch?v=dmqxw4M3yEM&quot;,&quot;video_type&quot;:&quot;youtube&quot;,&quot;controls&quot;:&quot;yes&quot;}" data-widget_type="video.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-wrapper elementor-open-inline">
			<div class="elementor-video"></div>		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-21aed12 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="21aed12" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-0e8355f elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="0e8355f" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<h2>The moment</h2><p>Common sense says yesterday wins. We have memories of it and records of it. But Jim says that in Einstein’s physics, yesterday and tomorrow are just as real as today. All times exist at once, and we just happen to live in this one.</p><p>His way of picturing it stuck with me. If you’re on page 150 of a novel, the pages behind you are your past and the pages ahead are your future. Close the book, and no page is special anymore. Every page is equally real. Einstein seems to have believed this deeply. Jim tells the story of Einstein consoling the widow of a close friend: the moments when her husband was alive, he told her, are just as real as now.</p><p>Then Jim went further, following Einstein’s view that the gravitational field is spacetime itself.</p><table role="presentation" width="100%" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0"><tbody><tr><td><p><em>“Without gravity, there’s no time. Without time, there’s no gravity.”</em></p><p>Jim Al-Khalili</p></td></tr></tbody></table>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-5727be4 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="5727be4" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-4cc9875 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="4cc9875" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<h2>Take this with you</h2><p>Try Jim’s book test this week. When a good moment feels like it’s slipping away, remember that in Einstein’s universe it doesn’t vanish. Close the book, and every page is still there.</p><p>Until next time,</p><p>Brian</p><p><strong>Missed Monday?</strong> Can a machine feel the happiest thought of Einstein&#8217;s life? <a href="https://ckarchive.com/b/wvu2hgh499739f9r552rqtnn6n4zoc8hnxe67" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Read this week&#8217;s musing</a></p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-d61a017 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="d61a017" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-33a1349 elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="33a1349" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://briankeating.com/podcast">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Subscribe to my podcast! More than 2M downloads!</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-1e82b7f elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="1e82b7f" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				</div>
					</div>
				</div>
				</div>
		]]></content>
		
					<link rel="replies" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/is-yesterday-more-real-than-tomorrow/#comments" thr:count="0" />
			<link rel="replies" type="application/atom+xml" href="https://briankeating.com/is-yesterday-more-real-than-tomorrow/feed/atom/" thr:count="0" />
			<thr:total>0</thr:total>
			</entry>
		<entry>
		<author>
			<name>sabartigas</name>
					</author>

		<title type="html"><![CDATA[Are We in a SIMULATION? &#124; Brian Keating on the Arora Podcast]]></title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/are-we-in-a-simulation-brian-keating-on-the-arora-podcast/" />

		<id>https://briankeating.com/?p=9040</id>
		<updated>2026-11-01T13:29:22Z</updated>
		<published>2026-11-01T13:27:13Z</published>
		<category scheme="https://briankeating.com" term="Transcripts" />
		<summary type="html"><![CDATA[Are We in a SIMULATION? &#124; Brian Keating on the Arora Podcast https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kacuVJczVY4 Transcript: What exactly are you building? Brian Keating: Many years ago, I proposed the very first experiment to look for basically the shrapnel of the Big Bang. What caused the Big Bang to bang? Raised $200 million for the project. So, the main leading theory behind how the universe came into existence involves basically a singularity, a time at which there was no time before that. That day, was that the first day that time existed? How does time come into existence when there&#8217;s no time for it to have come after? So, these are some of the biggest questions in all of consciousness, of all of what humans could conceivably be capable of visualizing. About 30 years ago, I had an idea that we could actually do it using technology. We could build technology tools and instruments that would be extremely advanced, very sensitive, and they would reveal the reverberations in the fabric of space and time. So this experiment that I co-lead with my colleagues around the world, this instrument is really poised to do what nothing has ever done before, to make this definitive measurement. Amira Arora: Has your view though on God changed ever since you went into this journey of cosmology and science? Brian Keating: Yeah, we care about God because God then transgresses and transcends the boundary between the laws of nature and the laws of how you treat your neighbor. If God really does exist, then why is there so much suffering? So those are concepts called theodicy. Good things happen to bad people. Why do bad things happen to good people? Believer has to account for the only one question, the existence of evil in a world created by God. We&#8217;re trying to figure out what happened before the Big Bang. What was the origin of anything at all? But why not nothing? That&#8217;s an open question related to where my research is leading me. Amira Arora: Simulation theory. The idea that our whole reality could be running on some deeper layer of code. Do you think that&#8217;s something science should take seriously? Brian Keating: Let&#8217;s say you&#8217;re looking at something, a star, and there&#8217;s some angle. There&#8217;d be some fundamental discretization of the arrival of these objects, either the wavelength or their period. And if you can have quantization of energy, that would prove that you&#8217;re in a simulation, right? Amira Arora: Hi everyone. Before we get into the podcast, I just wanted to say 90% of you that are watching this right now aren&#8217;t subscribed and it would mean the world to us if you would. So, if you can hit that subscribe button and the notifications icon, that would truly help us out and help us to give you the content that you want to watch. So, thank you so much and here we go on the podcast. Dr. Brian Keating, welcome to the show. Brian Keating: It&#8217;s great to be here in San Diego with you New Yorkers. Thanks for coming out. Amira Arora: Thank you so much. So, we&#8217;re going to get straight into it. You are leading an experiment involving I think over $200 million in scientific funding. So, of course, we would love to know what exactly are you building? What are you hoping to discover with this entire project? The shrapnel of the Big Bang Brian Keating: Well, so over the course of my career, I would say I&#8217;ve raised $200 million for the projects and I&#8217;m currently co-leading one of the biggest ones ever in my field called the Simons Observatory, and that&#8217;s done in collaboration with partners at Penn and Columbia. We do have people at Columbia, but primarily at Princeton, at Berkeley and the University of Chicago and San Diego, and we were the founders of this experiment to look for the beginning, sort of the signature of what caused the Big Bang to bang. We know that the Big Bang occurred through a host of different pieces of evidence, and in science the more pieces of evidence that converge on a singular explanation the better. And so we realized many years ago, I proposed the very first experiment to look for basically the shrapnel of the Big Bang. What would cause the Big Bang to bang was an open question. We know that the Big Bang happened but what caused it to explode, if you will. It&#8217;s not really an explosion but let&#8217;s talk about it in that way. The Big Bang began. We know now. We didn&#8217;t know really with this precision but we know it took place about 13.8 billion years ago. And because of that we can search for the physical aftermath, effectively the aftershock, of this explosive expansionary process. So the main leading theory behind how the universe came into existence involves basically a singularity, a time at which there was no time before that. So there was a day at which the Big Bang occurred. We could keep going back from today. Go back 24 hours, 24 hours, 24, till you get to 13.826 billion years ago in terms of 24-hour. And let&#8217;s say that today&#8217;s a Tuesday. Let&#8217;s say it was a Tuesday. Well, we didn&#8217;t have days. The sun didn&#8217;t exist. Humans didn&#8217;t exist. But let&#8217;s just say it corresponds to 24 times 13 billion times 365, et cetera. That day, was that the first day that time existed? How does time come into existence when there&#8217;s no time for it to have come after? So these are some of the biggest questions not just in cosmology, not just in science, but in all of consciousness, of all of what humans could conceivably be capable of visualizing. And so about 30 years ago I had an idea that we could actually do it using technology. We could build technology tools and instruments, primarily telescopes, which we can talk about,]]></summary>

					<content type="html" xml:base="https://briankeating.com/are-we-in-a-simulation-brian-keating-on-the-arora-podcast/"><![CDATA[		<div data-elementor-type="wp-post" data-elementor-id="9040" class="elementor elementor-9040">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-d7d654a e-flex e-con-boxed wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-parent" data-id="d7d654a" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
					<div class="e-con-inner">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-00e53e9 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="00e53e9" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Are We in a SIMULATION? | Brian Keating on the Arora Podcast</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-293d4fb elementor-widget elementor-widget-video" data-id="293d4fb" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-settings="{&quot;youtube_url&quot;:&quot;https:\/\/www.youtube.com\/watch?v=kacuVJczVY4&quot;,&quot;video_type&quot;:&quot;youtube&quot;,&quot;controls&quot;:&quot;yes&quot;}" data-widget_type="video.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-wrapper elementor-open-inline">
			<div class="elementor-video"></div>		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-faa3980 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="faa3980" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<h2><strong>Transcript:</strong></h2><p>What exactly are you building?</p><p>Brian Keating: Many years ago, I proposed the very first experiment to look for basically the shrapnel of the Big Bang. What caused the Big Bang to bang? Raised $200 million for the project. So, the main leading theory behind how the universe came into existence involves basically a singularity, a time at which there was no time before that. That day, was that the first day that time existed? How does time come into existence when there&#8217;s no time for it to have come after? So, these are some of the biggest questions in all of consciousness, of all of what humans could conceivably be capable of visualizing. About 30 years ago, I had an idea that we could actually do it using technology. We could build technology tools and instruments that would be extremely advanced, very sensitive, and they would reveal the reverberations in the fabric of space and time. So this experiment that I co-lead with my colleagues around the world, this instrument is really poised to do what nothing has ever done before, to make this definitive measurement.</p><p>Amira Arora: Has your view though on God changed ever since you went into this journey of cosmology and science?</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah, we care about God because God then transgresses and transcends the boundary between the laws of nature and the laws of how you treat your neighbor. If God really does exist, then why is there so much suffering? So those are concepts called theodicy. Good things happen to bad people. Why do bad things happen to good people? Believer has to account for the only one question, the existence of evil in a world created by God.</p><p>We&#8217;re trying to figure out what happened before the Big Bang. What was the origin of anything at all? But why not nothing? That&#8217;s an open question related to where my research is leading me.</p><p>Amira Arora: Simulation theory. The idea that our whole reality could be running on some deeper layer of code. Do you think that&#8217;s something science should take seriously?</p><p>Brian Keating: Let&#8217;s say you&#8217;re looking at something, a star, and there&#8217;s some angle. There&#8217;d be some fundamental discretization of the arrival of these objects, either the wavelength or their period. And if you can have quantization of energy, that would prove that you&#8217;re in a simulation, right?</p><p>Amira Arora: Hi everyone. Before we get into the podcast, I just wanted to say 90% of you that are watching this right now aren&#8217;t subscribed and it would mean the world to us if you would. So, if you can hit that subscribe button and the notifications icon, that would truly help us out and help us to give you the content that you want to watch. So, thank you so much and here we go on the podcast. Dr. Brian Keating, welcome to the show.</p><p>Brian Keating: It&#8217;s great to be here in San Diego with you New Yorkers. Thanks for coming out.</p><p>Amira Arora: Thank you so much. So, we&#8217;re going to get straight into it. You are leading an experiment involving I think over $200 million in scientific funding. So, of course, we would love to know what exactly are you building? What are you hoping to discover with this entire project?</p><p>The shrapnel of the Big Bang</p><p>Brian Keating: Well, so over the course of my career, I would say I&#8217;ve raised $200 million for the projects and I&#8217;m currently co-leading one of the biggest ones ever in my field called the Simons Observatory, and that&#8217;s done in collaboration with partners at Penn and Columbia. We do have people at Columbia, but primarily at Princeton, at Berkeley and the University of Chicago and San Diego, and we were the founders of this experiment to look for the beginning, sort of the signature of what caused the Big Bang to bang. We know that the Big Bang occurred through a host of different pieces of evidence, and in science the more pieces of evidence that converge on a singular explanation the better. And so we realized many years ago, I proposed the very first experiment to look for basically the shrapnel of the Big Bang. What would cause the Big Bang to bang was an open question. We know that the Big Bang happened but what caused it to explode, if you will. It&#8217;s not really an explosion but let&#8217;s talk about it in that way.</p><p>The Big Bang began. We know now. We didn&#8217;t know really with this precision but we know it took place about 13.8 billion years ago. And because of that we can search for the physical aftermath, effectively the aftershock, of this explosive expansionary process. So the main leading theory behind how the universe came into existence involves basically a singularity, a time at which there was no time before that.</p><p>So there was a day at which the Big Bang occurred. We could keep going back from today. Go back 24 hours, 24 hours, 24, till you get to 13.826 billion years ago in terms of 24-hour. And let&#8217;s say that today&#8217;s a Tuesday. Let&#8217;s say it was a Tuesday. Well, we didn&#8217;t have days. The sun didn&#8217;t exist. Humans didn&#8217;t exist. But let&#8217;s just say it corresponds to 24 times 13 billion times 365, et cetera. That day, was that the first day that time existed? How does time come into existence when there&#8217;s no time for it to have come after? So these are some of the biggest questions not just in cosmology, not just in science, but in all of consciousness, of all of what humans could conceivably be capable of visualizing.</p><p>And so about 30 years ago I had an idea that we could actually do it using technology. We could build technology tools and instruments, primarily telescopes, which we can talk about, that would be extremely advanced, very sensitive, and they would reveal not the light of the Big Bang, not the explosion itself, but the reverberations in the fabric of space and time. Okay, and that&#8217;s called gravitational waves. And if the Big Bang began with this period of rapid expansion, as many scientists think, many scientists believe the universe began with this inflationary aftershock. But it&#8217;s not proven. We can&#8217;t really prove things in science. We can falsify alternatives. We can&#8217;t prove it. So our job is to have as much physical evidence as possible that the universe had either a beginning in time or perhaps had many beginnings in time, where the universe exists not as a lone entity, a universe, a single singular cosmos, but perhaps part of what&#8217;s called the multiverse.</p><p>So this experiment that I co-lead with my colleagues around the world, about 450 scientists, engineers and researchers on six of the seven continents, this instrument is really poised to do what nothing has ever done before, to make this definitive measurement of perhaps the very first instance of the creation of our universe. And that would be beyond my wildest dreams if that can occur.</p><p>Your own big bang</p><p>Amira Arora: Yeah. Brian, one thing I&#8217;ve always found fascinating is that human beings seem uniquely obsessed with this question of existence itself. We&#8217;re constantly asking where all of this came from, why we&#8217;re here, why anything exists at all. Why do you think that question seems so deeply built into human nature?</p><p>Brian Keating: Well, I think it&#8217;s inevitable that we want to know about where we came from. I always say, what&#8217;s your favorite day on the calendar? I&#8217;ll ask each one of you, what&#8217;s your favorite day on the calendar?</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Wednesday. [laughter]</p><p>Brian Keating: Day of the year. Birthday.</p><p>Amira Arora: Your birthday, right?</p><p>Brian Keating: And what&#8217;s your birthday?</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Yeah, exactly. I was going to use that as a joke.</p><p>Brian Keating: What day is that? And then I&#8217;ll ask both of you guys that. You guys told me that you guys are twins. So your birthday, right? Or some people say New Year&#8217;s Day or Christmas or Diwali or any holiday, any event. What does that commemorate? It&#8217;s typically commemorating the beginning of something or a cyclical cycle of iteration. So, people like that. And what&#8217;s the only thing you can&#8217;t have personally witnessed? Your own origin story. I call it your own big bang, right? Your parents had you, you were there. You were there, but you couldn&#8217;t physically be a witness to it. So, you have to rely on what other people told you. The cosmology, the birth of the universe, if it indeed did take place on a single day. And there are many, many competitive ideas that suggest it didn&#8217;t. It might not have. But let&#8217;s just assume it did begin on a certain day at a certain time and then time itself came into existence. That no entity could witness, perhaps except for some omniscient God or simulator of reality. And so the question is, what does that imply for satisfying a human desire? I think it&#8217;s the most human question you can ask. And I think it taps into this desire to want to know what was the universe like, what were we like, what are the boundaries of our knowledge? Because if time comes into existence, you really can&#8217;t know about beforehand, right? So these are the real things that make it so fun to do cosmology because you&#8217;re addressing the most basic question of all. Every religion addresses this in some way or another. Every culture addresses this. What is the origin story of not just the human race, not just of Earth, not just of our solar system, our galaxy, our cluster of galaxies, but the universe itself. And perhaps, we don&#8217;t know, but there may be evidence that there is a multiverse of which we&#8217;re an infinite speck within. And so all of these have ramifications for meaning, for purpose, for theology, for philosophy, and in no other science as great as the biochemistry of nematode worms or whatever, they don&#8217;t really address the questions of existence, of meaning, of theology, of religion, of God. And so it&#8217;s really quite astounding that we can address that using these tools of telescopes, of instruments, of devices, whereas before it was pure speculation and theology.</p><p>Telescope means distance viewer</p><p>Amira Arora: Can we go a little bit deeper into the instruments you&#8217;re using for this project? I know you&#8217;ve brought some.</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah, I brought some parts. So, in astronomy in one way or another, we&#8217;re always doing some type of telescopy. I never use that word, but telescope means distance viewer. Tele, distance, scope, to view. And so what we try to do is make visual what&#8217;s not observable. So, we have senses. We actually have two telescopes in our heads. Our heads have two devices that are refracting telescopes. They use lenses. This is a lens-based telescope, replica of Galileo&#8217;s first instrument, the very first telescope, not invented, but first used for doing observations of the universe. And so it has a lens on one side, a lens on the other side, couples to the human eye, and has detectors. Those are the basic components of a telescope. Doesn&#8217;t matter if it&#8217;s looking for neutrinos or if it&#8217;s looking for gravitational waves as we are or it&#8217;s looking for photons, like light particles. It has basically those common elements together. And so in our instruments we are looking for heat. We&#8217;re not looking for light. We&#8217;re looking for heat that came about from the creation of the first atoms in the universe. First atoms came about 400,000 years after the Big Bang. Regardless of how that bang happened, we don&#8217;t know yet. We hope to get some information. The universe was a transition from being an ionized plasma of protons, neutrons, occasional heavier elements like lithium and helium and things like that, but it was primarily hydrogen and its isotopes. Hydrogen has three isotopes. At 380,000 years after the Big Bang, due to the expansion of the universe, the universe had both cooled and expanded enough that it was no longer possible for the heat present at the very moment of creation to ionize the atoms to keep them separate into plasma, ion of electrons and protons. So they combine together and the simplest atom is a hydrogen atom. Hydrogen, positive proton, a negative electron. When that occurred the universe becomes transparent. Now light can propagate. Light can&#8217;t propagate in a plasma. Gets scattered like in a cloud. When the universe becomes neutral, becomes atomic. That fusion of proton with electron that made the universe transparent to light. And then the light that was present traced the properties of that time period. So it&#8217;s a snapshot. When we look back in space, we&#8217;re looking back in time. You&#8217;re 6 feet away. I don&#8217;t see you as you are instantaneously now. Light travels one foot per nanosecond. So you&#8217;re six nanoseconds, I see you six nanoseconds younger, quote unquote, than you actually are. You send that to the sun, eight minutes. The sun could have disappeared at 8 minutes. I hope it didn&#8217;t. In San Diego, it&#8217;s tough to tell. It&#8217;s always so nice and sunny. But it could have disappeared. We won&#8217;t know for 8.3 minutes. Because of the finite yet fast light travel time. So what you look at when you see an astronomical source, you&#8217;re not seeing it as it is now. You&#8217;re seeing it as it was then. So we see the universe as it was when it created the first atoms, when the first atoms were neutral, created and present in the universe, and anything else that was there. The dark matter, which is not an atom as far as we know, the dark energy, which is this mysterious substance that&#8217;s all pervasive, vacuum-type energy that seems to fill all of space. And the fabric of space and time itself called the gravitational metric. So we perceive all the physical quantities of it as it was back then. So it&#8217;s a time machine. All telescopes are time machines. Our time machine uses that light to derive what were the properties of the matter, of the energy, and of the space and time itself. So we can see via the imprints that the light presents to us the fingerprints of the geometry of space and time, the composition of space and time, the early epoch of the space and time, and we can make projections about what we&#8217;ll see in the future. So it&#8217;s a very powerful time machine that is the representative of the oldest light in the universe. We can&#8217;t do that with our eyes. It&#8217;s in the microwave, which is the same that you heat up water in your oven in your kitchen. We can&#8217;t see it. If you could see it, your microwave would be glowing brighter than anything in your house. However we can build sensors that detect it. So our sensors don&#8217;t look like retinas. They look a little bit like CCD cameras like in your phone or whatever. But this is a cluster of 256 detectors and it&#8217;s about the same size as my iPhone, total size of the iPhone, which has in its camera 48 million pixels. So these pixels are much bigger. Why is that? Because the wavelength of light that we&#8217;re looking at is about the size of these little squares here. So there are 16 by 16 squares here. The wavelength of light that corresponds to the peak brightness of the cosmic background radiation that you study is 2 mm compared to 500 nanometers that your eye sees. So red light is 500 nanometers in wavelength. Microwave wavelength of the brightest light that we see in the microwave is 2 millimeters. So we have to build special detectors. We put them at the focus of a telescope. The telescope doesn&#8217;t use glass as its lens. It uses pretty ordinary material. This is just polyethylene plastic. It&#8217;s very high density, so it refracts light. It bends microwaves. You can&#8217;t see through it, but if I could see microwaves, it would go right through it, just like glass. Glass is more transparent to microwave. So, it&#8217;s a counter to your intuition. So, you wouldn&#8217;t use this for a camera that&#8217;s in this room that&#8217;s recording us, but you wouldn&#8217;t use that type of camera to record the cosmic microwave background. Similarly, we have these very advanced detectors. Because we&#8217;re looking at heat, we have to cool our detectors just like you wouldn&#8217;t build an optical telescope on Broadway in Manhattan and Columbia University. You wouldn&#8217;t build it there. The telescope there can barely see the moon. So you build it somewhere dark, like on top of a mountain. For us the equivalent of being dark is to be cold. So we take it to cold places, dry places, the South Pole, Antarctica, the mountains of Chile, sometimes into space, but it&#8217;s very expensive. But that&#8217;s really it. So, they all have these commonalities. They all have to minimize these natural or man-made backgrounds. They all have to maximize their sensitivity to the desired signal. And many telescopes use lenses. They could be reflectors, mirrors instead of lenses perhaps, but they use some type of optic to focus, concentrate, and then they have a detection. And then the hard part begins because you get a tremendous amount of data. And that&#8217;s where the fun begins. And that&#8217;s where the challenge really begins too. It&#8217;s hard to build the instrument, but it takes almost as long and as much effort, as many people that are brilliant brainiacs, to do the analysis.</p><p>Interstellar and the wormhole</p><p>Aryaan Arora: You know, Brian, some of these topics and aspects that you&#8217;re talking about, I&#8217;m sure a lot of the viewers watching this podcast are going to have in their head right now. Hollywood really heavily uses this in a lot of their films. I&#8217;m not sure if you watched Interstellar, but they talked about this whole topic of time, how if you&#8217;re on one planet, the time could pass differently on Earth versus that planet. Is there any possibility that any of this could actually be true?</p><p>Brian Keating: So, I had a controversial take. First of all, I&#8217;ll say I interviewed Kip Thorne, who won the Nobel Prize for detection of gravitational waves, of LIGO, and a prediction of theoretical analysis and analytical methods, as part of my podcast where I&#8217;ve interviewed 26 Nobel Prize winners. And I talked to him about the power of visualization in terms of scientific storytelling, and he actually wrote papers that are in physics journals about the accuracy and how you do these computational, heroic computational tour de force, where one second of film in the movie took 200 hours of supercomputer time to simulate. Okay. So the physics is accurate. The background story is not. So the teleportation, the wormhole, which he didn&#8217;t conceive of, the wormhole. That was sort of Einstein and Rosen first had this idea that you could have such a thing. But he made it much more popular. First in the movie Contact with Jodie Foster was based on a real-life story up until they detected aliens, and that&#8217;s Jill Tarter, a renowned radio astronomer from the SETI Institute here in California. And these measurements that they made were kind of fancifully displayed in terms of, well, could you teleport, could you use a shortcut through space and time? This is an old idea, like I said, goes back a hundred years almost. But it&#8217;s completely impractical. It&#8217;s very fanciful. I made a joke recently that Project Hail Mary, written by a former UCSD student, Andy Weir, who I also had on my podcast, is actually more scientifically accurate, even though it involves the eating of the sun by bacteria, than Interstellar in some ways because it doesn&#8217;t use wormholes as much. It uses faster than light travel perhaps or some version of very close to the speed of light. So, no, unfortunately, for one thing, the way it&#8217;s depicted is always highly idealized. So even though they did talk about these black holes in the movie very accurately, that level of detail was not applied to the story line that allowed the transportation of Matthew McConaughey to another world system. So that was highly inaccurate and yet when he got to his destination it was extremely accurate, right? And so that&#8217;s just artistic license, I think. There are a lot of things that are depicted in these movies that they take a lot of artistic license with.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: The reason that they do is not a surprise because you have to kind of sell it to the audience. You have to kind of make it, oh, it&#8217;s complicated. It&#8217;s technical. It sounds like, I don&#8217;t know, it could be. And when you combine them together, it is sort of surreptitiously attractive. It&#8217;s seductive, right? Because oh, the black hole is perfect. Brian told me, oh, the guy won the Nobel Prize, he&#8217;s talking about black holes, he must know what he was talking about. But the wormhole part of it, no, it&#8217;s not so much because even if you travel through a black hole, a human being can&#8217;t survive, right? [inaudible]</p><p>Brian Keating: That is one major problem. A human being couldn&#8217;t survive at least that transport. So what you&#8217;re referring to is that the wormhole actually needs, we think it would need two black holes on either side of it. So to make this bridge to cut through spacetime, if you imagine spacetime could have an opening on one side and an exit on the other side, leaving aside the stability and how hard that would be to make using tremendous amount of negative energy, which we don&#8217;t really know what that is or how it could exist, but let&#8217;s say you could stabilize it, how big it could be, could it be big enough to fit a human being in? I guess you&#8217;d have other problems. But yeah, these are devices that are just used because they sound a little bit plausible, but in fact, they&#8217;re much less plausible than Spider-Man spinning a web and swinging through Manhattan.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: And you were talking about how a lot of these tools that you have, equipment, they give you essentially the capability to know or try to at least predict what will happen in the future as well.</p><p>Anything that cannot be answered by science</p><p>Amira Arora: Do you think there is anything at all that cannot be answered by science, even in the future?</p><p>Brian Keating: Oh yeah. There&#8217;s a tremendous amount. Science at a certain level is very humbling because it can only answer a very prescribed, very limited set of questions, right? You can&#8217;t answer trillions and trillions of other questions. So, it&#8217;s almost more accurate to say it&#8217;s a tally. It&#8217;s a marker. It&#8217;s a logbook that encapsulates our ignorance. It&#8217;s telling us what we know, but what we know is so minuscule compared to what we don&#8217;t know. It&#8217;s sort of the most primitive thing, which doesn&#8217;t mean easy or trivial, but elementary, like elementary math, it&#8217;s actually really hard. To prove 1 plus 1 equals 2 takes over 100 pages of rigorous abstract mathematical proofs and the methods of the proof and all sorts of other tools that are used and discovering the underlying ontology of mathematics and then whether or not you can even do that in science. We, for example, we can&#8217;t prove anything in science. I can&#8217;t prove the Earth is round. I can prove it&#8217;s not flat, but I can&#8217;t prove it&#8217;s round. And so a lot of what we do in science is falsify other hypotheses, right? It could be that DNA has these four bases and RNA has five base pairs or whatever. But there could be some underlying mechanism that we have yet to discover, and maybe there&#8217;s a six or whatever. So if you just said science is fixed at any given moment, it&#8217;s actually limiting what science can do. And that&#8217;s sort of going against the scientific principle that you should be very humble when it comes to science. You shouldn&#8217;t say look how great we are. We can answer all these things. Yes, of course we can. And of course we can develop technology and sensors that allow us to visualize the invisible. But you shouldn&#8217;t confuse that with perhaps the truth, the underlying truth, which we don&#8217;t have access to. We can eliminate falsehoods but to the limit of what can we know to be true? How much of what there is knowable do we know? It&#8217;s very small.</p><p>What came before the Big Bang</p><p>Aryaan Arora: I think even before I started looking into your work, while growing up as well, essentially we were taught about this whole Big Bang, that&#8217;s how the world&#8217;s created, and that&#8217;s it, and no one talks about anything else. And that question was inside me, that what came before that? We&#8217;re assuming, okay, the Big Bang created the world, so what came before that? Besides, have there been scientists who have worked on this question deeply or gotten anywhere?</p><p>Brian Keating: There are scientists that work way more deeply than I do. What differentiates me from the scientists that mostly you&#8217;ll find discussing it or conceptualizing it, they&#8217;re typically theoreticians. They&#8217;re typically concerned with the underlying theory behind these models. So the Big Bang was created not by experimentalists or people building telescopes. It was predicted by actually it was a Catholic priest, Lemaître, who came up with this idea that perhaps the universe started in this what he called a primeval atom, something of nuclear density, extremely extraordinary high, the size of our solar system perhaps, and then it was unstable, it exploded and it began expanding in all directions. So it had some of the seeds and kernels of what would later come about. It was then criticized by Einstein for a long time. And then finally Einstein accepted it when he was shown experimental evidence from an observer, Edwin Hubble, who proved to him that the universe had at least a very, very vastly larger number of galaxies that were expanding away from the Milky Way. And that was revolutionary. Einstein believed the universe was static, had no beginning, and for thousands of years most cultures, most traditions, most civilizations except for Judeo-Christian culture or creation myth or story, cosmogony, had a cyclical or eternal cosmos. So that was the norm. And so Christianity really didn&#8217;t have, or Judaism didn&#8217;t have, a real quantitative demonstration that the verse of Genesis 1:1 was actually true until the discovery of these galaxies expanding apart. Then later the discovery of the cosmic microwave background that I studied, 1965, and then soon after the discovery of the abundance of different elements that can only be formed under conditions of nuclear fusion. So that was the prevailing narrative.</p><p>Now what typically happens is that a theory in science comes along to replace a theory that has some serious flaws or gaps in its predictive power. So let&#8217;s just say for 2,000 years plus, from Aristotle to Einstein, till 1929 at least, if you ask any scientist, when did the universe begin, they&#8217;d say what are you talking about, it&#8217;s always been here, something can&#8217;t come from nothing, it has to be here for all time. And the question was, okay, so what evidence was there to prove that wrong? Again we can&#8217;t prove something right, we can prove something wrong. So there was no evidence, it was just conjecture and theorists had this idea. Some people believe that yes, there certainly could have been something like an origin point to solve certain paradoxes, but it wasn&#8217;t quantitative. So it had no experimental support.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Oh, yeah.</p><p>Brian Keating: So, you really had to be humble about it. And until these discoveries really people didn&#8217;t have that level of belief in anything except they just kind of accepted on faith that the universe looks static because it does look static on the time scale of a human being. The only things we see moving are the planets. In fact, the word planet in Greek means wanderer. Means it moves against the fixed stars. Same root word as plankton. Plankton means something that wanders in the ocean. Plane, the airplane you guys are going to be on. It means something that flies, moves. So we named the five things that we could see in the night sky, we named them planets, up until the 1700s when the first one beyond Saturn was discovered by William Herschel. So that kind of didn&#8217;t break a paradigm. We still knew that the stars seem to be fixed. We didn&#8217;t believe there were any galaxies other than the Milky Way. So it really was this rapid, like Cambrian explosion of knowledge in the 1900s up until this very day that suggested that there was a beginning. And then your questions are exactly appropriate. What came before the beginning? It&#8217;s these eternal questions. What happens when you come to the edge of the universe? That&#8217;s another question people like to ask. So some of these are founded upon our intuition. But when your intuition is dealing with cosmology and a story of the entire universe, the beginning of what we call time, which we don&#8217;t have a great definition of, by the way.</p><p>What&#8217;s the definition of time</p><p>Aryaan Arora: I was going to ask that. What&#8217;s the definition of time?</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah. So, there is no one accepted definition of time. There are many different types of time, right? There are definitions that correlate with our experience. Like right now, this coffee is cooling down. I had some cream and coffee that mixed together. We correlate the arrow of time with the direction of the increase of entropy. It seems entropy only increases in the universe. You could think of using that as a type of a clock, measuring the temperature, but when it comes to equilibrium, there&#8217;s no change. So once something doesn&#8217;t change, you can&#8217;t measure elapsed time. So time is really the differentiator. So some people, I&#8217;ve talked to Nobel Prize winner Bill Phillips and Frank Wilczek, both of them won the Nobel Prize. They say, oh, time is just what a clock measures. Well, a clock is something that measures time. So, it&#8217;s tautological, which means that we don&#8217;t really have a great definition. That doesn&#8217;t prevent us from doing a lot of really important hard work. But certainly, it prevents us perhaps from speculating what came before the Big Bang because if time comes into existence, there&#8217;s no marker with which to, that concept doesn&#8217;t make sense. And a lot of people, including the late Stephen Hawking, did say that. He said it was an incoherent question to ask what came before the Big Bang. It&#8217;s like asking, I&#8217;ve been to the South Pole twice, so it&#8217;s like asking what&#8217;s south of the South Pole. It&#8217;s the end of the coordinate system. So you reach a singularity. You can&#8217;t go beyond it but the things don&#8217;t blow up. It&#8217;s just that&#8217;s not defined. Once you go south of the South Pole you go north. Any direction you move from the South Pole you&#8217;re going north. It doesn&#8217;t matter. Now that&#8217;s not really satisfying, right? You kind of want to know what it is. So, the truth is that we don&#8217;t really have a fundamental definition of time any more than we have really a definition of any quantity. That&#8217;s why I said we could be proud of ourselves, rightfully so, for measuring all these quantities, knowing the temperature of the universe to five significant figures, knowing the distribution of dark matter to unprecedented precision, building sensors that can detect the change of a single photon from the Big Bang. Those are things to be rightfully proud of, my colleagues and I, you should be proud of that. However if you ask what&#8217;s time, mass, energy, space, we can&#8217;t really say there&#8217;s a definitive answer for it. So a lot of it is built on kind of common acceptance of jargon, of language, of a lexicon, and that behaves through certain syntactical rules that are useful to us. A lot of science, we didn&#8217;t understand fully how transistors worked in terms of their quantum mechanical properties until the 50s or 60s, a decade after we started using them. So things could be very useful and then that can give people the idea that we actually understand all these things when in fact we don&#8217;t. There&#8217;s a lot of things, way more things we&#8217;ll never ever understand or poorly defined forever than we can possibly know and describe with precision.</p><p>Reality as a headset</p><p>Amira Arora: You know, there&#8217;s this growing idea that reality itself may be computational or even simulated. What are your thoughts on that?</p><p>Brian Keating: Well, I know I&#8217;ve talked to some people about this. Don Hoffman, I know you guys have talked to recently. For me there&#8217;s challenges for all these things because a lot of them depend on the understanding of what human consciousness is, which I didn&#8217;t even include in the project of cosmology. I mean we&#8217;re observing the universe but we don&#8217;t understand how the human mind works. We don&#8217;t understand what consciousness is. Don, with great respect to him, I&#8217;ll talk about reality as this headset and this interface that&#8217;s evolutionarily designed to,</p><p>Amira Arora: Okay.</p><p>Brian Keating: Okay, so where did evolution come from? Evolution didn&#8217;t create itself, any more than the laws of nature created themselves. A lot of people say, oh, the universe can come from nothing because it can emerge from a quantum fluctuation. Okay, what&#8217;s a quantum fluctuation? Where did that come from? Oh, it&#8217;s eternal. It&#8217;s always been there. And so what ends up happening for me is it&#8217;s very frustrating because it devolves into something that&#8217;s either tautological or it&#8217;s truly equivalent to a theological discussion, right? So you say, well, who created God? Or you could say, who created the universe? If God created the universe, oh, God&#8217;s eternal. Well, the universe could be eternal. You just get into these pointless arguments. Theorists may be like that, theologians, philosophers like that. I don&#8217;t like that. I like to build technology and telescopes that allow me to see things I can&#8217;t see and use those to learn more about the universe in a practical sense, if you could call it that, than to debate these really kind of esoteric, almost meaningless things that you can&#8217;t make progress on. Because as I said, no one agrees what consciousness is. There&#8217;s no definition of consciousness. Hundreds of different views.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Everyone disagrees because everyone believes in their own theory, right?</p><p>Brian Keating: You said it better than me. It&#8217;s a very good way to put it. There&#8217;s hundreds and hundreds of theories. Now, we are writing down equations. Who is we? The brain, an AI system. What&#8217;s it doing? Is it conscious? Does it have free will? So, I find these questions frustrating. Maybe because I&#8217;m not good enough to do the theoretical hard work, but for me, I&#8217;m very comfortable downstream. What if we see these fluctuations in the fabric of spacetime? I know how relativity works mathematically. I know how quantum mechanics works up until a point. Again, quantum mechanics is another subject. We don&#8217;t have a universal definition of what quantum mechanics is. We don&#8217;t have a framework for it. We have this same person, Einstein and Rosen, who conjectured these wormholes that Kip Thorne would later use in movies and Carl Sagan, et cetera. He didn&#8217;t really believe in the kind of weird properties of quantum mechanics that we seem to be inevitably connected with, that the universe has these weird correlations and strange behaviors of what can influence what, causality, locality. These are very, very different concepts and in fact physicists will disagree on what it means that something is real, that something exists. And so again, people do like to talk about these things. I could talk about them, but I feel like it&#8217;s almost impossible to make progress into it. If I said to you, what is the number one? You guys can do stuff with the number one. You take flight number one, I push one for coffee, two for cream, whatever. We know how to use one, right? You&#8217;ve never seen a triangle in your life, right? It only exists in the human mind, which only exists because of a huge overlay of culture and civilization and language and constructs that you guys and I didn&#8217;t create. So I prefer downstream and I can say I pay $1 for this coffee or whatever you guys did, and from that perspective I&#8217;m a pragmatist. I just like to do stuff with it at much higher level than debating what is the reality, what is consciousness, what interpretation of quantum mechanics. For me it doesn&#8217;t make a difference. So I just go with what works.</p><p>Amira Arora: Yeah. Because we had done a podcast with the physicist Stephen Wolfram. I don&#8217;t know if you saw that.</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah. I can&#8217;t remember what his definition of one was, or one plus one.</p><p>Amira Arora: He had his own separate view of consciousness, and we&#8217;ve done so many podcasts with different people and like you said, everyone has their different view of consciousness, and sometimes it matters for them to be able to work on their project and theory.</p><p>What do people even mean by a simulation</p><p>Amira Arora: Just to quickly bounce off the question though, when people do say a simulation, what do they even mean by that?</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah. So, what we observe now is a very remarkable situation with technology, that we seem to have reached a level where we&#8217;ve been able to take computational devices, computers, silicon chips, et cetera. Not quantum computers, not things that are made of some exotic materials, but just ordinary classical computers, just giant versions of these transistors that were invented 100 years ago. Not giant, minuscule versions of things, but assembled in giant numbers, and they then seem to emerge with properties not unlike the human brain. And because of that, because the capacity for simulation is increasing, where we simulate the weather, we simulate physical domains, we can simulate the vacuum of quantum mechanics, we can simulate detectors and photons, we can simulate a whole host of different outcomes. And we tend to focus on things that are interesting to us, right? So if I told you you could simulate what it was like to live on Mars right now. Okay, that&#8217;s interesting. And I&#8217;m sure Elon Musk has some flight simulator somewhere to do that. But if I said you could simulate your 16th great-grandmother in India somewhere, right? Or for me in Europe somewhere. You can simulate them and get to know them and be in their shoes and visualize their world, even for a few hours or something like that. How much would you pay for that?</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Pretty much. Yeah, I&#8217;d pay a lot. I don&#8217;t know. It&#8217;d be really cool because we all matter, right? We want to connect with our ancestry and our heritage and it&#8217;s part of what makes us human, right?</p><p>Brian Keating: You asked, what is this fascination? Well, what&#8217;s a bigger fascination than how you came to exist? Your own personal origin of the universe, right? So then it&#8217;s natural to think, well, if we simulate things that are interesting to us, we don&#8217;t simulate, I&#8217;m a pilot, so we do flight simulation every now and then to make sure that we&#8217;re safe and we don&#8217;t have accidents or whatever. We don&#8217;t do things like, oh, we&#8217;re going to land at the South Pole. The South Pole is a single runway. It&#8217;s three miles long. It&#8217;s made of ice, just scraped out. It has no relation to San Diego airport where you guys are going from. So, yes, you could simulate it, but what&#8217;s the point of it? You&#8217;re never going to go there. You&#8217;re never going to be there. And if you were there, it wouldn&#8217;t make any difference to your safety or anybody else&#8217;s safety. You&#8217;re not a military pilot. That&#8217;s the only people that can fly there. Whereas if you&#8217;re learning to fly, you might simulate San Diego or New York. And I&#8217;ve done that my whole life. So you simulate things that are important, interesting, relevant, perhaps predictive, that can tell you about the future, help you understand the future perhaps, contextualize things. We simulate other planets. We simulate the origin of the universe. So why not simulate us? Why not, instead of simulating your 16th great-grandmother, why don&#8217;t you simulate your mother, how she was, or your father, right? So you could do that and then you can say, well, if I do that now with 2026 technology, you could do it, but maybe in the 2050s technology be better, but maybe in 2900 technology be even better, right? If things keep growing at this exponential pace, which there are questions about, can that happen, but if they do, the transition from the large language models of today to just four months ago, intelligence is doubling, the amount of intelligence doubling every four months. So that&#8217;s hypergeometric growth. So there won&#8217;t be, theoretically there could be no human on Earth that would know as much as the base model that you get for 20 bucks a month from Claude or whatever, right? So that could happen in four months from now, let alone in four centuries from now. So the idea is that we could be the products of a simulator who&#8217;s in the future and we might be what&#8217;s called their ancestor, just as you simulated your ancestor. You might want to, I might want to, they might be simulating us. Now can you prove that? No. It&#8217;s a derivation of Pascal and others who visualized in the 1700s and 1800s the so-called, how do you know that you&#8217;re not a brain in a vat? Basically said, the brain, I say Brian, in a, how do you know that you&#8217;re not? Because what is your brain? I&#8217;m vastly simplifying this, but your brain responds to chemical and visual stimulation, sensory stimulation, which is conducted purely through electrical channels, right? And they knew that. So what if you just take your brain up and it&#8217;s here and you just feed in stimuli to it? I&#8217;m smelling this? No you&#8217;re not, you&#8217;re just the chemical receptor is firing because we&#8217;re stimulating with the exact same tempo, exact same intensity, exact same spectral chirp signature, whatever. And you could be hearing things, seeing things, smelling, but you&#8217;re just a brain and you&#8217;re connected through a neuron and you&#8217;re fed nutrients, and I don&#8217;t know, would you have a different experience? So then if that&#8217;s true, well then what if that whole thing is then simulated in silicon like this and it&#8217;s just a massive computer that has grown at Moore&#8217;s law doubling every four months until five centuries from now. You can&#8217;t comprehend. So that&#8217;s the appeal. The objection to it is manifold at some level. You have to wonder why that would be, and at another level you have to confront the argument that it&#8217;s essentially recapitulating a religious framework, right? There&#8217;s some God who&#8217;s the master simulator, decided to simulate his ancestors or its ancestors, and the purpose for this is not really clear. Descartes and others got out of it by saying, well, God is not malicious, and so, cogito ergo sum, I think therefore I am, I can only think that I can think about thinking, this metacognition, because there&#8217;s a God who&#8217;s good. But how do you know there&#8217;s a God that&#8217;s good? Maybe it&#8217;s a simulator. Maybe there&#8217;s no God, maybe there&#8217;s a devil. So I think that there&#8217;s fascinating questions that can be raised by it. There are people like Nick Bostrom who say there&#8217;s really only a couple different scenarios, that either there is a simulation or there&#8217;s not a simulation, or that there is a simulation and the simulator doesn&#8217;t care or does care about simulating their ancestors, or maybe has achieved or hasn&#8217;t achieved their goals, or there could be some weird causality thing, like they simulate us but then we somehow destroy the simul, like the Matrix or whatever, like we can escape the simulation. So again, what are the practical downstream ramifications of it? Is it just rehashing these arguments from the 18th century? Maybe, and there&#8217;s nothing wrong with it, but where does it actually get you? Can you distinguish between it? Could you falsify the simulation? Could you prove it? Actually, you might be able to prove that you&#8217;re in a simulation, right? The Truman Show is a famous movie, right?</p><p>Aryaan Arora: I love that one.</p><p>Brian Keating: The Matrix.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Yeah, I love it, too.</p><p>Brian Keating: And so, yeah, the light fell out of the sky. Oh, take two or whatever. So he kind of proves that there&#8217;s a simulator, right? Or there&#8217;s someone manipulating him. What&#8217;s the purpose of it? They&#8217;re watching him. But the simulation of the entire universe, what kind of entropy demands would that create? What kind of limitations from the physical universe would it have? And then what if that simulation is simulated by another simulation, is simulated by another simulation? So it&#8217;s never ending.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: You get infinite regress.</p><p>Brian Keating: Exactly. Right. So again, interesting, unsatisfying, like many things in life because we are talking about the mystery of God.</p><p>The fine-tuning argument</p><p>Amira Arora: I&#8217;m sure as a cosmologist and in your field even more so, you must have been intrigued by this idea of God, and I want you to talk about that. Before we do that, I want to show a short 30-second video. You can also share your reaction on that as well.</p><p>[Video clip plays]</p><p>Did you know that if gravity were slightly more powerful the universe would collapse into a ball?</p><p>I did not.</p><p>Also, if gravity were slightly less powerful, the universe would fly apart and there&#8217;d be no stars or planets.</p><p>Where are you going with this, Sheldon?</p><p>It&#8217;s just that gravity is precisely as strong as it needs to be. And if the ratio of the electromagnetic force to the strong force wasn&#8217;t 1%, life wouldn&#8217;t exist. What are the odds that would happen all by itself?</p><p>Why are you trying to convince me to believe in God? You don&#8217;t believe in God?</p><p>I don&#8217;t. But the precision of the universe at least makes it logical to conclude there&#8217;s a creator. There are 5 billion people on this planet and you&#8217;re the perfect mom for me. What are the odds of that?</p><p>Aryaan Arora: When he talks about, if it wasn&#8217;t precisely tuned for that, he&#8217;s talking about fine-tuning, which is a strong argument for God, even though atheists will say this is one of the stronger arguments for God. So the question is, how finely tuned could the universe be for us to be here? He made it sound, and I&#8217;ll just ask you, if things were how much different that we wouldn&#8217;t be here? Do you remember, or what do you think? Is he saying exactly balanced, like it&#8217;s two scales and they&#8217;re totally in balance? Is that kind of what he&#8217;s conjecture is probably, I&#8217;m guessing.</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah. So obviously there&#8217;s always some uncertainty, right? Nothing is exactly equal. Even you guys, you guys are twins. You&#8217;re not exactly the same. You guys are completely different, right? And that&#8217;s great. That&#8217;s what makes you guys unique. And if even twins can be different, how much more different is a non-twin from another stranger, right? So actually it&#8217;s quite coarsely tuned in many ways. What it&#8217;s typically called is apologetics, which is a fancy way of saying you assume God&#8217;s existence and then you reason back to the conclusion that will support the existence of God that you conjecture from the beginning, right? So we exist, it&#8217;s another version of cogito, I think therefore I am, a good God wouldn&#8217;t allow me to hallucinate, to deceive myself that I exist. But that&#8217;s assuming the existence of God to prove God&#8217;s existence, to prove consciousness is real. So it&#8217;s a circular argument. It&#8217;s called begging the question. People think begging the question is like raising the, no, begging the question means you answer your own questions, tautology typically. So in this case you&#8217;re assuming the existence of God, it has to be finely tuned. But what a scientist should do, and he&#8217;s supposed to be a scientist, I like the fact that they said five billion people because we know there&#8217;s 8 billion, so it must have been when he was young, Sheldon, so he&#8217;s a baby, but whatever. I could quibble with that too. But would he ask about his mother, is it him, is it his genetics, what made him become who he is, that he thinks that she&#8217;s the perfect mother? In some ways it couldn&#8217;t be otherwise. Even if you had a horrible mother, you wouldn&#8217;t exist if that mother didn&#8217;t give birth to you. So by definition. Anyway, in the case of fine-tuning of the strength of these forces, that&#8217;s completely nonsensical. So he talked about the universe would go into a ball. There&#8217;s no sense to that. There&#8217;s no ball. I don&#8217;t know what he&#8217;s talking about. I think he&#8217;s talking about a black hole, which is reasonable if there&#8217;s an extreme mistuning, but the problem is people always do these things for extremely special starting cases. Right now the universe is dominated by what&#8217;s called dark energy. The dark energy dwarfs the amount of mass energy that we&#8217;re made up of, even though we&#8217;re a very tiny sliver, less than half of 1% ordinary matter, like calcium, carbon. That&#8217;s a very small amount of the universe&#8217;s mass energy budget. Dwarfed by the amount of dark matter in the universe, but even more dwarfed by the amount of dark energy in the universe. Right now, we could dial up the dark energy to a factor of 10 times higher. Right at the second, nothing would happen to us. Life would go on existing. Our galaxy would be the same. The solar system would be the same. A trillion years from now, that&#8217;s a different story. Things would be different. But he&#8217;s using this very special time that he exists and he&#8217;s saying because of that these things couldn&#8217;t have been different in the universe today. But that&#8217;s simply not true. If you can double or triple the amount of mass in the universe and nothing happens to you, your mother, whatever you&#8217;re doing, your podcast, nothing would happen. Absolutely nothing. So how fine-tuned is that? So people say, oh, it&#8217;s extremely finely tuned, if these things didn&#8217;t happen exactly the right order, exactly the right time. But I say, look, I can&#8217;t play any musical instrument besides Spotify. That&#8217;s all I can play, right? So my tuning is pretty coarse. And yet I could figure out how to make some symphony or make some sounds on my wife&#8217;s violin, right? I could do that. That would be much closer to, there&#8217;s an infinity of different frequencies, pitches you can make, right? From zero frequency to infinity, right? Of that bandwidth of possible frequencies that are theoretically possible, I can make a huge number of them even though I suck. I&#8217;m just pulling the violin across, is that finely tuned? There&#8217;s an infinite amount. And so people say, yes, it&#8217;s an infinitesimal slice out of an infinite amount. But if my wife&#8217;s off by 1%, a note on the violin, 444 hertz instead of 440 hertz, you can slightly tell a difference. You could probably do it because you have a good ear. But one or two percent is not finely tuned at all. That&#8217;s actually extremely coarse. If you try to tune the Wi-Fi in this room, it&#8217;s actually tuned to like a part in 10 to the 9th. The frequency spectrum is allocated extremely small amounts of bandwidth. And if that&#8217;s changed a lot, they actually get a phone call from the US government. You&#8217;re actually violating the FCC regulations.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Yeah.</p><p>Brian Keating: So that has to be much more finely tuned than a violin. And yet we wouldn&#8217;t say the universe where it can be 100% larger, not just 1%, 100% larger, it wouldn&#8217;t make a difference to us at all. So people like to cherry-pick. Oh, if the universe was one proton heavier per kilogram in the early universe, we wouldn&#8217;t have existed. Okay, that&#8217;s true. If it was one proton now, it wouldn&#8217;t have any effect whatsoever. So it could be completely the same quantity just at two different times. And people just cherry-pick. If you&#8217;re sitting in your seat, let&#8217;s say you&#8217;re taking a flight a week from now and you&#8217;re sitting in your seat and I tell you you&#8217;re going to be sitting in your seat at this time at this hour, right, and you&#8217;re going to be there plus or minus one hour, right? If that hour is one hour earlier than the flight, that&#8217;s fine. One hour later, you miss it completely. So it&#8217;s very crucial. People like to cherry-pick that to make their argument stronger. I find that manipulative. So that tender moment is, again, another Hollywood kind of manipulation of human emotions to generate some, ironically, support for God, even though Sheldon&#8217;s supposed to be an atheist, [inaudible] or whatever, right?</p><p>God cares if Brian Keating believes in him</p><p>Amira Arora: Has your view though on God, and you can define what your view on God is as well, because I don&#8217;t believe that God is a person with a white beard either, but what your view on God is now, and has it changed ever since you went into this journey of cosmology and science?</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah, I would say it&#8217;s been a very circuitous and torturous [laughter] kind of relationship with God. I like to say, God cares if Brian Keating believes in him like the tooth fairy cares if I believe in her. If God exists, I can think as a scientist, I can only say a hypothesis of God. Is it a scientific hypothesis? Yeah, it is. You can hypothesize God exists. You can hypothesize a simulation exists. But let&#8217;s just stick to God. Within God, there&#8217;s many different types of gods, right? There&#8217;s multiple gods or single God, different names for God, different origin stories for God, prophets, there&#8217;s so much cultural overlay on top of that, right? But if you just describe a property to God that I can relate to, the question of science, God is the ultimate arbiter of law, of logic, of mathematics, of physics, and therefore has some domain expertise in the realm of cosmology, then I can start to talk about, well, how does this fit in? Now that&#8217;s a very bland God. I don&#8217;t really care. If there were multiple gods, one for each field in a department at UCSD, I don&#8217;t really, it&#8217;s meaningful, right? We care about God because God then transgresses and transcends the boundary between the laws of nature and the laws of how you treat your neighbor, right? Those are very different concepts, right? We say to God, so I&#8217;m Jewish by birth, but I also practice Judaism. And I&#8217;ll say why I do in a minute. But from the perspective of Judaism, the Torah, the Bible, the Old Testament begins with the creation of the universe, which is very strange, right? 99% of the book is not about the creation of the universe. In fact, there&#8217;s 35,000 verses in the Torah, in the Old Testament, just the five books of Moses. 35,000 verses. Of those 35,000, 35 verses about the origin of the universe, the creation of the days of the week, the Sabbath, Adam and Eve, Cain and Abel, like 35 verses. It doesn&#8217;t talk about molecular biology and spacetime geometry and negative energy density, right? So it&#8217;s obviously not meant to be a science book, but people intend to use it as that. And why is it in the Jewish tradition, it starts with the origin of the universe? Because only the lawgiver that created the universe has the ultimate jurisdiction to say that you shouldn&#8217;t sleep with your neighbor&#8217;s wife.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Right. So it then transcends the physical laws of nature to the interpersonal, the ethical laws of behavior, morality.</p><p>Brian Keating: Exactly. So without that mandate, it was thought that God couldn&#8217;t do that. So it was logical, actually the first commentator ever to ask this question was a commentator who lived a thousand years ago, why does God start with that, not with another, like kosher? I can&#8217;t eat pork, right? I don&#8217;t eat pork. Other religions have different things, right? So it doesn&#8217;t say, here&#8217;s why you can&#8217;t eat pork, it&#8217;s delicious but don&#8217;t eat it. It doesn&#8217;t say why. It doesn&#8217;t tell you at all. There&#8217;s no reason for it whatsoever in the whole Bible.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Oh, is it? I haven&#8217;t.</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah, there&#8217;s no reason for it.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: It&#8217;s not a deity, it&#8217;s not something that we worship.</p><p>Brian Keating: No, it&#8217;s this is what you can eat and this is what you can&#8217;t eat. But if it was a book about law, like the US Constitution doesn&#8217;t start with the beginning of the universe, right? And we&#8217;re coming up on the 250th anniversary, right? So it doesn&#8217;t start with that. It starts with, here are the laws. We believe every person has a right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, in the Declaration of Independence. [inaudible] But it does say endowed by their Creator God. So it does appeal to the same functionality, right? So that&#8217;s sort of a big preamble to say that the evolution of my viewpoint on God has changed a lot because starting off when you&#8217;re a kid, you&#8217;re born into a religion, right? Typically people are born into it. It&#8217;s rare to see, young Sheldon, right? It&#8217;s rare to see someone at 5 years old say, I&#8217;m going to choose to be a Christian Scientist, if their parents are Hindu, or it just doesn&#8217;t happen that much. Maybe it does, but everything has some chance, I suppose.</p><p>A Jewish boy who became an altar boy</p><p>Brian Keating: In my case, I was born to Jewish parents. Typically, you&#8217;re Jewish, you go to Sunday school, maybe. Most Jews are unaffiliated. They don&#8217;t really go to temple that often, if at all. Then they typically have a bar mitzvah and then the pot mitzvah and then maybe they don&#8217;t go to temple again or anything ever again until they get married and then they have kids. So, that&#8217;s 90% of at least US Jewry. In my case, my parents got divorced when I was seven, and my mother married an Irish Catholic man. And so I went from being completely non-observant Jewish to very observant Catholic. So much so that at age eight I have, it&#8217;s called a baptism, where they put water on, then a communion where you actually receive, you accept that Christ is your savior. Confirmation, you&#8217;re older. It&#8217;s sort of a rite of passage in a sense. And then I actually became an altar boy in the Catholic church of Chappaqua, New York, which is not far from where you guys live, in Westchester County. So I became an altar boy in the Catholic church as a Jewish boy who never had a bar mitzvah. So a little bit unusual. And around the time I was about 13, I got really fascinated with astronomy. Actually got my first telescope, made observations and really fell in love with, my scientific hero to this day is Galileo. So Galileo was a brilliant scientist, almost discovered calculus, almost invented the telescope, had incredible successes, was the first to use a telescope astronomically.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: And that&#8217;s the name of Avi&#8217;s project as well, the Galileo Project.</p><p>Brian Keating: That&#8217;s right. Yeah, the Galileo Project, right? So for many reasons he became a hero to me, one of which is that he&#8217;s the best scientific writer in terms of the English language, even Italian, but in translation he is a poet. He&#8217;s evocative, he&#8217;s humble, he&#8217;s arrogant. Again, he&#8217;s brash, he&#8217;s reserved, he&#8217;s introspective. And of course, he had this overlay narrative of battling against the superpower of the Catholic Church and being imprisoned for the last nine years of his life. He wasn&#8217;t killed, he wasn&#8217;t tortured, but he was threatened to be tortured and that was enough back then. It would be like the UN and every country on Earth, you&#8217;re an outcast, Interpol, America, everywhere, and you&#8217;re going to be punished for the rest of your life. So, it was pretty damn [inaudible], all for really using the telescope to support the claim that Copernicus made 80 years before on his deathbed that the sun was the center of the universe. And Galileo thought he had evidence to prove that it was, and he thought, because science is truth and God is truth, that the Catholic Church would accept that, but they weren&#8217;t so happy with that. And so when I heard that as a Catholic boy at that time, I was very depressed because it was really disillusioning to a 13-year-old to think that all this religion, and I loved being an altar boy. I loved being in the Catholic church, Sunday school. I actually liked it. And then to find out that my hero Pope John Paul and the popes at the time in the &#8217;80s, they had never really found Galileo not guilty and they never really kind of pardoned him. It was kind of devastating. It&#8217;s like finding out you love this soccer team or football team, whatever, and they tortured your grandfather. It&#8217;d be hard for you to look at them in the same way.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Of course.</p><p>Brian Keating: So a little knowledge is dangerous, and at that time then I became an atheist. So I stopped going to church. I really just fell in love with science. That&#8217;s all I wanted to do. Taught myself calculus, taught myself a lot about astronomy, and this is way before Google, the internet existed, and nothing like that ever existed until a decade later almost. And so it was very difficult, arduous to learn things but I was able to do it, and I think that&#8217;s what started this path of research. And as I matured and got more powerful tools, telescopes, technology and insight, then I started to think, well, maybe there&#8217;s something to religion, let me investigate it because they&#8217;re certainly coupled together. And I&#8217;m grateful for that. I&#8217;m really glad that I went through what I went through religiously, even my atheism experimentation, because I think I came back to it as an adult, not as a kid. Forced into it, like I had to go to temple, I had to go to church. No, no. If I did, I wanted to go. I wanted to learn. I realized I didn&#8217;t know how to read Hebrew. So, I taught myself Hebrew. I&#8217;d never read the Torah, the Old Testament. So, I read it and read the commentaries on it. And what started to be much more appealing to me than the religious aspects was the social, communal, cultural aspects of it, which I had also kind of abandoned just because I&#8217;d gone into different religions. You get Christmas instead of Hanukkah. It&#8217;s hard to go back as a kid, but as an adult, it makes more sense.</p><p>A practicing devout agnostic</p><p>Brian Keating: So now I call myself a practicing devout agnostic. Meaning that, what&#8217;s an agnostic or what&#8217;s an atheist? An atheist is someone who declares there is no God, right? Atheistic and not believe. What&#8217;s a theist? Someone who declares that they know, they believe, they know. So in science, we don&#8217;t do that. We don&#8217;t say I believe in gravity. No, I have evidence for gravity. Now, could gravity change? Yes, gravity could change. It may change in the universe. It may change in the galaxy. Who knows if it will change on the scale of this table, but certainly not today, right? So, we have evidence for it. We have replication. We have reproduction. We have peer review, right? We [inaudible] fully scientific tool. So, I don&#8217;t say I believe in gravity. I say I have evidence for gravity. But God is different. We don&#8217;t have evidence, scientific evidence, like a falsifiable hypothesis. If you did, there&#8217;d be no need for faith and belief, right? Why would you say you believe in God? If there was proof of God, do you say you believe in the traffic laws? You say, no, no, no, I know there&#8217;s evidence that cop&#8217;s going to pull me over. Or, I believe in the speed of light. No, no, you don&#8217;t believe in it. There&#8217;s evidence for it.</p><p>Why do bad things happen to good people</p><p>Amira Arora: One argument people often make is that if God really does exist, and if there&#8217;s intelligence or purpose behind reality, then why is there so much suffering, right? War, disease, childhood trauma, cruelty. Do questions like that make the idea of God even harder for you to prove from a scientific perspective?</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah, those are the most challenging questions of all but I&#8217;m never afraid of a little hard work. Right. So those are concepts called theodicy. Good things happen to bad people. Why do bad things happen to good people? Some of the things you mentioned are human-made, war, famine. Most famines are caused by human mistakes or corruption. Even to this day certainly wars are, right? Cancer is not, right? So there&#8217;s a famous saying, the atheist has to account for everything, the existence of the universe, the existence of humans, the existence of goodness. In a pure Darwinian scenario, like maybe Hoffman believes and whatnot, it&#8217;s very hard to see the wasteful energy spent on things like love and kindness and compassion. And in fact many cultures, for example in the ancient Greek culture, if a baby was born deformed or had some illness they would leave it to die. I mean it was just Darwinianism in action and it wasn&#8217;t considered to be horrific. It was kind of expected. I mean life expectancy maybe wasn&#8217;t that great or whatever. So it&#8217;s not like these are foreign concepts to the human mind, the cruelty and so forth. So there has to be some accounting, and then, yeah, the believer has to account for the only one question, the existence of evil in a world created by God. Now I don&#8217;t think that those are really, again, these are the kind of questions like what is consciousness, what is time, it&#8217;s another version of that, right? Because we could say, well, everything happens for a reason, right? So God created cancer cells, I&#8217;m just making this up, but I&#8217;ve heard arguments that cancer cells are byproducts of the [inaudible] and the ability for life to reproduce, right? So without cancer, that would mean the fundamental alteration of the human genome, right? There&#8217;d have to be some process in nature which has no perfect reproduction, replication, never making too many copies of itself like cancer does, right? But that would then preclude other things like the ability of a cell to divide, like you guys were two cells, one cell split apart, right? Or two different, you guys were two different cells because you guys are not identical, right? So two, but developing exactly at the same time, dividing at the same time. I mean, why didn&#8217;t one of you come out like 30 pounds and one zero? It&#8217;s amazing how exquisitely finely tuned that is. Perhaps there&#8217;s some relationship. You couldn&#8217;t have that unless there were these things that we now think of as purely harmful, like cancer. On the other hand, we may also overcome cancer. We&#8217;re there. If you listen to these AI guys, I just installed this AI package that Claude makes to write scientific papers, and what it&#8217;s like, all biology. It&#8217;s like 36 different biological tools with protein folding and then cancer genomics and incredible stuff. There&#8217;s nothing about cosmology, so I&#8217;m going to try to change that. But all this effort getting into it, and companies are saying they&#8217;re going to cure cancer in a few years. Part of that is the human need to understand things. Now chemical warfare and weapons and biological, that&#8217;s another thing. We invented recombinant DNA in 1971, that was almost immediately recognized it could be a horrible, horrific weapon that could kill, be targeted, be manipulated.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Yeah.</p><p>Brian Keating: And yet it could be very, very potent and it could be used for good, as it has been to make vaccines. And so CRISPR is another thing. CRISPR has some relation, I think, to gene editing, splicing, and even to cancer. These bacteria, phages, these viruses that we use for drug delivery, RNA, we use. So, it&#8217;s not clear, but you certainly have a point. There&#8217;s no easy way out of that question. You can appeal all you like and say free will, and if you didn&#8217;t have cancer, maybe you wouldn&#8217;t live life the same way. I think that&#8217;s kind of reductive. If you want the laws of physics to operate in a logical, consistent world, you&#8217;re going to have things that are unintended consequences.</p><p>God set the world into motion</p><p>Brian Keating: But you could still say God is a part of it. I don&#8217;t say this, but people could say, well, God set the world into motion, created the world with, God designed DNA and then disappeared. Now he&#8217;s off in the multiverse somewhere else, right? But all the laws of physics are just operating and evolving and Darwinian evolution is taking place. Okay, fine. It doesn&#8217;t mean that you have a personal God that you can confess your sins to or who has the authority to tell you not to covet your neighbor&#8217;s wife, right? But again, these things are so abstract. For me it&#8217;s like, okay, do I give 10% of my income to charity? That&#8217;s a commandment. So in Hebrew, you&#8217;ve heard of bar mitzvah, mitzvah, oh, it&#8217;s a good deed. No, it&#8217;s a commandment actually. It means you must do this. It doesn&#8217;t mean it&#8217;s optional, right? So you have to give 10% of your salary before taxes to charity. That&#8217;s one of the rules, right? Would I do that? I don&#8217;t know. Maybe you would, maybe you&#8217;re more kind of moral person than I am. But I know just every year I have to do that. I&#8217;m just going to write January 1. Just write it out. I&#8217;m going to do it. I don&#8217;t like doing it. I don&#8217;t love doing it. Some things I get money to, I like to do. But I do it. And I think, like a lot of people, having a scientific framework that you can then adjust. Okay. So you don&#8217;t believe that eating bacon is wrong. Okay, fine. But maybe you&#8217;re going to treat your parents in a certain way to honor the fifth commandment, for example, which is very hard for some people to do. I think there&#8217;s a lot of wisdom to it. So, I&#8217;m a pragmatist. I take the good stuff. I&#8217;ve seen the benefits of it.</p><p>I&#8217;m commanded to rest on the Sabbath</p><p>Brian Keating: For example, here&#8217;s a huge one. If you guys wanted to do this podcast on Saturday, I would have said no. As much as I like you guys, as much as I&#8217;m hoping for the twin bump, I wouldn&#8217;t do it because I&#8217;m commanded to rest on the Sabbath. And I know personally it makes me much more productive during the other six days of the week. I&#8217;m connected to my family, to my wife, to my kids, to my community, philosophically. And when else do you get to sit around for 4 hours on a Saturday afternoon just talking with your friends, your community, your rabbis, friends and everything, just together thinking about a higher purpose? Now, you may say it&#8217;s nonsense or it&#8217;s a fairy tale or whatever. I&#8217;ve talked to the greatest atheists alive. None of them have lives that I particularly want to emulate and all of them would benefit from the type of suggestion that I&#8217;m making. I was just on one of the biggest podcasts in the world with a brilliant guy, and I was talking to him about my prescription for him is that he takes a Sabbath. He just works 24/7. I said if you did this you&#8217;d actually be able to work hard, and he&#8217;s like, oh yeah, I will, but I just got to hit this number, like I don&#8217;t know, subscribers, money, whatever, and then I&#8217;ll do it. I&#8217;m like, no, you&#8217;ll just get to another number plus one. There&#8217;s always a bigger natural number. The desire is never</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Exactly. I&#8217;m curious though with your current, of course with the scientific mindset, but your current religious or spiritual view, do you pray at all during hardship?</p><p>Do you pray at all during hardship</p><p>Brian Keating: No, I don&#8217;t. I have a very challenging relationship with the prayer aspects of things. I tend to, but I do view it as a chance to meditate. So I will ordinarily, I can&#8217;t meditate. Just too distracted. Too many kids, too many classes, students, whatever, just work, travel, research, podcast. So, I found it very difficult. But when I&#8217;m in the temple on a Saturday, I&#8217;m like, there&#8217;s nothing. I don&#8217;t have my phone. I&#8217;m not on the internet. I&#8217;m not tweeting, podcasting, texting, or whatever. I might as well meditate and think about what really means something to me. In fact, the word Jew comes from the Hebrew word Yehuda, hoda&#8217;ah, and that means thankful. So thankfulness, gratitude is inherent in the word Jewish. So what I typically will do is, I don&#8217;t believe God is like my butler in the sky and that he&#8217;ll do, oh, I shouldn&#8217;t get cancer but they should get, I don&#8217;t think that makes any sense. I see the World Cup and I&#8217;m like, these guys, Morocco. They won yesterday and I was kind of happy to see them beat, I think they beat Germany or they beat one of the really great European team. I was like, yeah, that&#8217;s good. And then they just started praying. They got down on their knees and in one sense it&#8217;s humbling to see it, but on the other hand, sometimes I see my Padres here, they&#8217;re just so frustrating, but I love some of the players, just love them, and Manny Machado will hit a home run, he&#8217;ll make the sign of the cross. I was just like, okay, so Jesus was helping you with that. I don&#8217;t think that&#8217;s what he&#8217;s saying. I think he&#8217;s saying he&#8217;s grateful that he has this gift, right? So I do that too. I do that to myself, to God. Think about all my kids, my wife, my mother, still alive, my brothers, and I&#8217;ll just kind of expand the circle out. And I found that there is a practice actually, it&#8217;s a Zen, samsara, and loving kindness, [inaudible], these thoughtful meditations, and these traditions have a place in Judaism, so might as well do it. Sam Harris doesn&#8217;t believe Judaism is true, even though he&#8217;s born, raised Jewish, I guess. Meditates a lot.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Yeah, he&#8217;s a whole thing, Waking Up. He&#8217;s got an app. He&#8217;s got courses. It&#8217;s a huge part of his life.</p><p>Brian Keating: And so he and I can agree on that even though we might disagree about the value of religion versus not religion.</p><p>Will machines surpass human beings</p><p>Amira Arora: I wanted to, we were talking about this before. You mentioned AI. I did want to talk about AI a little bit. Artificial intelligence, it&#8217;s advancing unbelievably fast right now. Do you think there will come a point where machines actually surpass human beings in understanding reality better than we do? Like you were saying, lots of AI software, they&#8217;re doing research on cancer, and you think that there&#8217;s a possibility that in a couple of years, using AI, cancer can be cured.</p><p>Brian Keating: Yes. I think they&#8217;re very good at doing things. These LLMs plus GPUs are very good at solving problems that are told to them to solve as valuable. They&#8217;re less convincing in terms of creating new breakthroughs, innovations, things that we haven&#8217;t conceived or told them what to do. They&#8217;re language followers. So, you can talk to it. You can program it using English or any language, right? Anything that has a logical structure. Even babies can talk to it. It&#8217;ll try to figure out what a baby or a dog, I mean, I&#8217;ve seen crazy things, right? But it&#8217;s not inventing new languages. My favorite example is it beat chess in 1993. The last human being that will ever win in chess played IBM&#8217;s version of this machine. It was a machine learning, but very similar to AI. And that was the last time humans will ever be able to win, but people still play chess. My kids play chess, right? You might play it or your listeners might play it. So, it&#8217;s still intriguing. Now, my example is then, yes, no human can ever beat, but will the computer ever invent an algorithmic kind of game with structure and rules that&#8217;s in place for 4,000 years? I doubt it, right? Or Go. Well, it can write like Shakespeare, sort of, but can it ever do something as evocative or as tender and connected to the human soul and spirit? No. I also don&#8217;t think it can do novel things in physics. I&#8217;ve yet to be convinced that you can create truly new knowledge. The holy grail in physics is what&#8217;s called a theory of everything that unifies all the forces of nature into one master force. The same way that we unified electricity and magnetism, were once thought to be separate forces. Now we know they&#8217;re one force, electromagnetism. The hope is to unify the strong force, the weak force, electromagnetism and gravity into one master equation. And it&#8217;s just not clear that it could do that. It&#8217;s not clear that such a thing exists, by the way, but if it exists, it&#8217;s not clear how these things would come about.</p><p>Can it rederive what Einstein did</p><p>Brian Keating: And I&#8217;ve actually done research with some students here and talked to other researchers. Unfortunately got scooped by some other AI researchers because this isn&#8217;t my domain. But I had this idea about four years ago to take a large language model but cut off its knowledge base in 1911. Just say anything that happened after 1911, just erase it, anything happened before, keep it. Newton&#8217;s laws of gravity, the equations of thermodynamics, even relativity was around, special relativity, but not general relativity, and that&#8217;s important, and quantum mechanics wasn&#8217;t really understood until 1926. So lobotomize it, tell it nothing beyond that point and see, can it rederive what Einstein did four years later? And no, it doesn&#8217;t seem that it can. It can replicate, it can try to, it&#8217;ll keep doing it, it&#8217;ll keep forcing a solution until it gets an answer, and it can get arbitrarily close numerically, but it can&#8217;t come up with the insight that actually gravity is not a force, it&#8217;s a manifestation of the curvature of space and time, and that Einstein had. And it is very poetic to me that when Einstein realized that gravity is not a force in the common sense, he said it was the happiest thought of his life, and he came to it through what he called the Gedanken, or thought experiment, that if you were, and you&#8217;ve all had this experience, I&#8217;m sure, you go over a bump or you&#8217;re on a roller coaster for a little bit, you&#8217;re weightless. You go over this bump and you can visualize even now, you could probably feel it. You&#8217;re in a plane, you got turbulence, you&#8217;re going up, right? Or in space. But if you were in space and that happened, it would be the same. You&#8217;d be freely falling. You&#8217;d be weightless. You&#8217;d experience no gravitational force. He said, or the elevator, God forbid, breaks, the cable breaks, and you&#8217;re plummeting, right? He said that was the happiest thought of his life. Not that he&#8217;d die, but that you experience no force of gravity. You&#8217;re just floating in space. You don&#8217;t feel it pulling down on you at all. And he said that was the happiest thought of my life. Now, I always say, how does a computer have a happy thought? You give them no more power, you give it some more processor. What does it mean for a computer to be happy? And could a computer visualize that sensation that we have all had when we jump into space? So for all those reasons I&#8217;m not optimistic. I wish I was more because I think there&#8217;s so many things, but I think the limitations imposed not by the number of processors we have but just that that&#8217;s not the way that physics works. Physics is not a language like English or COBOL or Fortran or Python. It&#8217;s very different. It has language elements, just like we can describe consciousness. Is consciousness a language? I think it&#8217;s ridiculous. So, I&#8217;m very worried, but in some sense I&#8217;m excited because it means that physicists will have a place in the future to actually do stuff.</p><p>String theory has zero relevance to what I do</p><p>Aryaan Arora: You do talk a lot about falsifiability. And I do want to ask that, do you think modern physics is drifting into these ideas that mathematically they sound very interesting and beautiful but they are very difficult to explain?</p><p>Brian Keating: No, I mean, I think there&#8217;s a lot of gnashing of teeth and wringing of hands that, oh, physics is over because string theory has been such a bad force on physics, and it&#8217;s really polluted and contaminated physics, and it&#8217;s really destroyed the ability. And I think that&#8217;s a very narrow, parochial way of looking at it. First of all, the long arc of science is not based upon what model of particle physics is the most important one. It is true that a lot of the famous physicists that we know about, from Feynman to Einstein, Schrödinger to Bohr, Oppenheimer, they work in quantum mechanics or particle physics, but at the same time there&#8217;s far more, at least as interesting if not more interesting, gravity, black holes, the cosmic background radiation that I study, neutrinos, other things that have nothing to do with string theory at all. But people are obsessed with doing what Einstein could not do. So Einstein allegedly wanted to construct this theory of everything, and in Stephen Hawking&#8217;s words that would then give you the answer to what is God thinking? The mind of God was his exact words in A Brief History of Time. I don&#8217;t believe that&#8217;s true. I think he used that to sell, but he was also an atheist. So people talk about God like young Sheldon, that doesn&#8217;t mean that they believe in it. Or Einstein. And so yeah, there is an overabundance of these [inaudible] approaches as science is hampered by this false quest to find a theory of everything, and string theory&#8217;s corrupt. I don&#8217;t believe that. I think it hasn&#8217;t been successful by the ordinary definitions of falsifiability because it doesn&#8217;t get into the arena of being testable, right? It predicts the existence of things that are unobservable. So in that sense, maybe it&#8217;s not part of science, but I don&#8217;t see it as monopolizing. It has zero relevance to what I do. We have nobody at UCSD, which is a top 20 physics department in the world or country certainly, and we don&#8217;t have anybody who works on string theory and is obsessed with string theory has got to be right. People are working on particle physics and we consider it. But no, I don&#8217;t think that is a fatal. There&#8217;s 50 Nobel Prizes since string theory was created. It&#8217;s not like physics just stopped, but it&#8217;s a popular narrative because it paints things as kind of quasi-conspiratorial, like people are only working on string theory. And I know Avi Loeb has talked about how bad string theory could be. And that&#8217;s true, but it&#8217;s not stopped him from doing what he&#8217;s doing. And he&#8217;s written 757 papers. So it&#8217;s [laughter] not like it&#8217;s hampering the output of scientists in general.</p><p>Do human beings have any free will</p><p>Amira Arora: And Brian, this is a topic that we&#8217;ve discussed in podcast before, so I really want to get your take on this. Physics often makes the universe, right, sound incredibly deterministic, like everything is just particles following laws. That being said, do you think human beings have any free will?</p><p>Brian Keating: Oh, undoubtedly. I&#8217;ve never met someone. I&#8217;ve talked to everyone from Sam Harris, like I said, to, and people are always, oh, he loves to drop names, but no, it&#8217;s important that you recognize that you&#8217;re not the authority on everything, right? So in this realm, I&#8217;m a podcaster, but I&#8217;m also a thinking, practicing physicist as well, right? So I have some things to say about the physical aspects of it. So typically, the reason that&#8217;s important to name-drop, so to speak, these people is because these are supposedly the greatest thinkers alive on the subject. Robert Sapolsky, Sam Harris, the late Dan Dennett, his final interview while he was alive was with me. So I&#8217;ve had a lot of the top people interacting in the space, and David Chalmers, Nick Bostrom, and I&#8217;ve yet to hear a convincing definition of what free will is other than the kind of simplistic notion that determinism is obviously assertable because you cannot control the charge on the electron and you cannot control the conditions of the Big Bang. And yet to a person I&#8217;ve asked them, have you ever met somebody who is normal and acts like they don&#8217;t have free will? No, they don&#8217;t. Have you ever met somebody whose actions, if committed against you, who doesn&#8217;t believe in free will, accept as without reservation? Sam Harris has two daughters. Sam, your daughter gets murdered by a crazy guy in Malibu, or a guy burned down Maui who almost killed you and burned down your house or our neighbor&#8217;s house or whatever. What would you like done to that person? I&#8217;ve never had anybody say, oh no, it&#8217;s fine. Oh, I would like to say that I wouldn&#8217;t want to do anything. That&#8217;s what Sapolsky told me. I think it&#8217;s a total copout. It means that you don&#8217;t believe in practice what you&#8217;re preaching. You don&#8217;t believe that these people deserve no punishment because their actions were predetermined at the time of the Big Bang or by the laws of physics that we can&#8217;t comprehend. But you asked about determinism and randomness and so people can misabuse some things. There&#8217;s a difference in the ability to know something and the knowing of. There&#8217;s certainly a lot of things we can know, right? We don&#8217;t understand the human mind, as I said, we understand the coffee in this cup better than we understand the human mind, that&#8217;s for sure. But certainly this doesn&#8217;t seem to have free will and yet we do. So I believe we operate as if we have free will. I believe that the superdeterministic kind of ideas, they fail the most basic test of, have you ever known someone normal? I believe there are abnormal people. And there&#8217;s certainly people with chemical imbalances. And you can make the argument maybe they should, maybe they shouldn&#8217;t.</p><p>What happens to the ox in Judaism</p><p>Brian Keating: My favorite thing is in the Torah. So an animal, let&#8217;s say you have an ox, which is very common, like you have an ox kind of like a car, right? In today&#8217;s parlance. But it did some stuff and it was alive for sure. They gave it rights. You couldn&#8217;t abuse it. It had to not work on the Sabbath, which is very unusual for an agrarian economy to take a huge one-seventh of their economic impact once a week. You can&#8217;t let your animal work. It&#8217;s crazy. But it was done so that you, the owner, wouldn&#8217;t take the day to work as well. So it was protecting you as well as it was protecting the animal, your slave. If you had a slave, he or she couldn&#8217;t work on that day. But let&#8217;s say you have this ox and it goes next door and it kills your neighbor&#8217;s kid. What do you think happens to the ox in Judaism?</p><p>Aryaan Arora: The ox is an animal. The kid got in front of it, maybe it was throwing rocks at it or whatever, right?</p><p>Brian Keating: Maybe the kid deserved it, but the ox steps on the kid, kills the kid. What should he do with the ox?</p><p>Aryaan Arora: I mean, he didn&#8217;t mean it. It&#8217;s not like it was intentional.</p><p>Brian Keating: Right. So actually what happens is you kill the ox. You kill the ox.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Yeah.</p><p>Brian Keating: In Judaism, yeah, it&#8217;s humiliating to a human being. Imagine your next door neighbor for the rest of his life, he has to see your ox walk. Oh, that&#8217;s the ox that killed little Jimmy. That&#8217;s humiliating. It&#8217;s degrading to the human spirit. That&#8217;s what the Torah suggests, that the weight of a human being is infinity. And that&#8217;s another reason I love this notion of religion and theology in general. You have to prize the human being. And I think a lot of the atheists, the people that are most likely to not believe in free will are atheists, right? Because they believe God didn&#8217;t do anything special if he created us and we don&#8217;t have free will. Why would I worship this thing that created these automatons? I don&#8217;t worship my GPU that Nvidia made, right? It&#8217;s just automatons doing some useful work. So the Torah prizes the human life because it&#8217;s created in God&#8217;s image. No other kind of thing can come close. I don&#8217;t care if it&#8217;s an ox, if it&#8217;s a bonobo, which is very similar to a human being, or a dolphin, like a beautiful dolphin eats my neighbor&#8217;s daughter, that dolphin should be put to death. I mean, it shouldn&#8217;t be that my neighbor has to suffer for the rest of his life looking at this creature that took the life of an infinitely valuable human being. And I think we&#8217;d all like that. I hear a lot of times, Israel outlawed the death penalty for many, many years after the Holocaust. They did kill a couple of Nazis that were still alive and then they stopped, and they, oh it was really tragic, and guess what, they&#8217;ve reinstated it after October 7th because they realized this is a cruel thing that people are allowed to live and exist and that you pay for these people, they get four meals a day. They get conjugal visits, and you pay, not only like in California, you&#8217;re not only not put to death, you&#8217;re allowed to live and get married and have concubines and do whatever and watch TV all day and exercise. Is that moral? Is that a society that we should want to live in, or should it be, yeah, the death penalty [inaudible]. And what the Torah also said is it didn&#8217;t say thou shalt not kill as most people think, it says thou shalt not murder. So from the context of valuing human life, that&#8217;s something that actually seems divine to me. Again, it&#8217;s not proof. Could it be used as evidence? Maybe.</p><p>What is it like to be Thomas Nagel</p><p>Amira Arora: You&#8217;ve talked about consciousness several times throughout this podcast so far and how we&#8217;ve figured out how there are so many views, but what is your view right now on the definition of consciousness? You mentioned earlier about David Chalmers as well, who coined the term hard problem of consciousness.</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah. So what is my take on, it&#8217;s so frustrating. Again, these are not things you can really understand, even by their definition, right? These are qualia, like the sensation, what does the color orange look like? I mean, subjective experience, completely subjective. Again, you guys are twins, your photonic retina and cone and rod cells perceive the intensity of this light, of this table, of this telescope slightly differently. You don&#8217;t even know what you think of as this goldish color. You may both call it gold but you may see it as what you call red and you may see it as what you call green, but you&#8217;ll never know, right? So from that context it seems like, okay, so these are kind of unknowable questions, which physicists are more comfortable. We don&#8217;t know why the mass of the electron is 10 to the minus 28 kilograms or whatever it is, right? We don&#8217;t know why it is, but once we have its mass we can do particle accelerators, we can make fusion reactors, we can do all sorts of incredible things, we can create antimatter, and these are phenomenal technological achievements. So from my perspective it doesn&#8217;t trouble me, but it doesn&#8217;t make me eager to wade into those waters of, I want to go to a consciousness seminar. It&#8217;s just, one of my many, many side projects that AI is enabling, probably one of the sins of AI in the future will be recognized as, I&#8217;m writing kind of an essay, and there&#8217;s a famous essay, What Is It Like to Be a Bat, by Thomas Nagel, so I&#8217;m writing a different essay, what is it like to be Thomas Nagel, how would a bat visualize Thomas Nagel? And it&#8217;s actually influenced by one of the books that influenced me the most, actually a book that you get when you join my mailing list, briankeating.com. It&#8217;s called Flatland. Flatland is a book written by a square. It&#8217;s a square and he&#8217;s moving around this two-dimensional world. And by moving around this two-dimensional world, he encounters a three-dimensional being who comes into his existence in his universe and creates this havoc, and it&#8217;s like an alien invasion. It was written in the 1860s and it has some social commentary in the Victorian era, like slaves and women are treated really badly and they have different shapes, then priests are circles. They have the infinite number of sides, and a square is okay but not great. But [inaudible] is a brilliant story but it helps you visualize what it would be like to be in the fourth dimension. No. So, actually, it allows you to extend your consciousness or your awareness or whatever. So that&#8217;s kind of the only waters that I&#8217;ll wade into, have to do with, yeah, what would it be like for a lower dimensional being like a bat to try to perceive a higher dimensional being like a human? That&#8217;s an interesting question to me. But what is the conscious hard problem? I don&#8217;t think I can make any progress on that.</p><p>Why not nothing</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Right. Yeah. I don&#8217;t know if this is a question that you&#8217;ve been asked before, if you&#8217;ve thought of, but I guess as a human I would think that we&#8217;re trying to figure out what happened before the Big Bang. What was the origin of anything at all? But why not nothing? Why anything at all? Why not nothing?</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah. There&#8217;s glib answers to that. So in physics, emptiness or vacuum state is not empty. It&#8217;s actually very rich structure in terms of the quantum mechanical properties that allow the existence or annihilation of different entities like electrons, like photons, quantum fields. If it didn&#8217;t have that, if we didn&#8217;t have the ability to have creation, destruction, matter, antimatter, then we wouldn&#8217;t have matter. So, it&#8217;s often said that nothing is unstable, right? So you can&#8217;t have nothing lasting forever. It&#8217;s a point of unstable equilibrium. So in physics if you have that situation the vacuum is unstable and it tends to create fluctuations out of which theoretically it&#8217;s possible to create something. So people think, oh, matter is conserved. If I get rid of this coffee cup and vaporize it and turn it into nothing, that&#8217;s impossible. No, you can actually do that. You can&#8217;t destroy energy, but you can destroy matter. In fact, antimatter and matter both have mass. Combine them together, you get no mass. You get photons, pure energy, and you get the energy equivalent of E equals mc squared for each one of the matter and antimatter particles. So nothing can come from something. And the reverse process can happen too. Two photons can come together and create a positron and antimatter and matter pair. That happens all the time. And so we know that that&#8217;s possible in the early universe. It happened at extremely high rates. But the question is where did the energy come from to begin with, out of which the matter could later come out? That&#8217;s an open question related to where my research is leading me, like what came at the beginning of time, or as close as we can get to with instruments, telescopes, optics, detectors that we talked about.</p><p>It&#8217;s like cotton candy</p><p>Amira Arora: And Brian, we touched upon this a little bit before but I want to talk about it more. So simulation theory, it&#8217;s become so popular now. The idea that our whole reality could be running on some deeper layer of code. As a physicist, do you think that&#8217;s something science should take seriously or is it mostly just a fun thought experiment?</p><p>Brian Keating: I don&#8217;t see the practical benefit of taking it seriously. Again, you could make the exact syllogism, you could equate God, right? There&#8217;s nothing that happens in the Matrix or in the Truman Show that is beyond the capability of an omnipotent God, right? And yet you&#8217;d never have a physics conference talking about God like that. Would never happen, right? At least not anymore. So that kind of tells me it&#8217;s like cotton candy or something, it tastes good but it has no value. It&#8217;s interesting to speculate on and it might lead you to some conclusions, and people do work on what would be the computational cost of studying the properties of the simulation, how much RAM does it need, how many GPUs does it need, and so I think that&#8217;s interesting in the same way, my kid collects Pokémon cards, I don&#8217;t think Pokémon is that interesting scientifically or culturally. But there&#8217;s this huge market of trading cards and grading and there&#8217;s this culture and the sociology behind it, or baseball cards when I was a kid. I had Yankee cards. I used to be a Yankee fan. And I still have one or two and I think my mom threw out one.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Yeah. A really valuable Yankee. Oh, come on.</p><p>Brian Keating: Reggie Jackson is my favorite. So baseball cards are frivolous, but the study of baseball cards, the market, the economics behind them, it&#8217;s big business. It&#8217;s very serious stuff. I mean, my friend just paid $1,200 for a Fernando Tatis rookie card, right? So that&#8217;s serious business. So, in other words, the meta study of something may be more interesting than the topic itself, comic books, cartoons, the history of cartoons is actually more important than the cartoons itself, right? Cave paintings are cartoons, right? That&#8217;s more interesting than, oh, is that a really good giraffe by modern artistic history stuff? No, of course not. So the study of something may be interesting in itself even though the base layer of it may not be interesting to me.</p><p>Like a character in a video game</p><p>Aryaan Arora: And hypothetically, if we were inside a perfect simulation, right, would there be any way for science to prove it, or would it be like a character in a video game trying to figure out whether their world is real from inside the game itself?</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah. So there&#8217;s only one way that I&#8217;ve thought about and others have thought about and it really has to do with the properties of mathematics. So like I said before, you&#8217;ve never seen a triangle, right? But you can conceive of a triangle, right? So the human mind can conceive of things that don&#8217;t exist. We could define it, but like I said, you can make the three points, but they&#8217;re not microscopic, they&#8217;re not one-dimensional. They&#8217;re not zero-dimensional, right? So you can approximate things. So the human eye can do that, but computers can&#8217;t. They have to be finite. At some level they have to be discrete. Even a quantum computer, it can have a large number of states, but in practice to realize the different states will be a quantization of those different outcomes. Right? Now if you think about all the things that are continuous variables, any number that&#8217;s a real number that has any value. There&#8217;s an infinite number of real numbers between any two real numbers. So you pick pi and pi plus 1 over 10 trillionth plus pi. There&#8217;s an infinite number of numbers between. So that means if you were, let&#8217;s say you&#8217;re looking at something, a star, and there&#8217;s some angle, at some level you would expect that unless you have an infinite amount of RAM or infinite amount of storage or infinite amount of CPU power, quantum or otherwise, there&#8217;d be some fundamental discretization of the arrival of these objects, either the wavelength or their period or something like that. Wavelength is another thing. You can have quantization of energy but wavelength is a continuous real number, so you can have an infinite number of real numbers between 500 nanometers and 501 nanometers. So if there was some experiment, and there are people that propose such experiments, that would effectively prove that you live in a simulation, you see these [inaudible], it would be like [inaudible] off the ceiling in the Truman Show, that would prove that you&#8217;re in a simulation, right? Now people would then argue about that, well, is that part of the simulation, right? Because if we know that then the simulator knows that. But again, this is just like talking about God, right? God could make you think that God doesn&#8217;t exist. You cannot disprove the hypothesis that God exists, right? So all these things again, it&#8217;s like chewing on cotton candy. It lasts for a second and then for me it doesn&#8217;t satisfy.</p><p>Homo sapiens is man who is wise</p><p>Amira Arora: Humans happen to be unique in the sense that we are essentially the only ones who are fully aware that one day we are going to die, and that does make me think that awareness of death, I guess, also is a place for us to create meaning in this life. Has studying the universe also changed your perspective or your thought on this idea of death as well?</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah. I mean, that&#8217;s kind of what Homo sapiens means, right? It&#8217;s man who is wise or knows, and the knowing is that you&#8217;re going to die. We&#8217;re the only entities, we think, that know.</p><p>Amira Arora: Yeah.</p><p>Brian Keating: And elephants supposedly will kind of know, like, oh, this one&#8217;s about to die, but they don&#8217;t know when they&#8217;re four years old that death is a possibility, right? So, yes, of course, it adds life to your years to know that they&#8217;re finite. If you had this infinite lifespan, in some sense that would be torturous unless everyone had an infinite lifespan, in which case where do you drop in on that continuum, when you&#8217;re 10, 30, 90, 100? What does it really matter? So having that finitude, and I think for me the recognition of milestones in life that is marked by certain seasons of life, when I was your age I wasn&#8217;t thinking about, there&#8217;s a lot of things I wasn&#8217;t thinking about, including podcasts, and they didn&#8217;t exist, but family or professorship, but now I think as you get older you start to live less for yourself and your accomplishments. I always wanted to be freaking awesome and win the Nobel Prize. That&#8217;s why my book&#8217;s called Losing the Nobel Prize, not winning the Nobel Prize. I just wanted to be awesome, have all these accomplishments, PhD, be a professor. I didn&#8217;t think I could be, but maybe I would be. But it wasn&#8217;t the really meaningful things.</p><p>There are two different types of resumes</p><p>Brian Keating: It was in some writing, I think it was David Brooks, who&#8217;s echoing some famous rabbis in the 1800s. He talks about there are two different types of resumes that you have. You have your resume that you present for grad school or getting in a show or something like that. And then there&#8217;s things that people say at your eulogy. People probably won&#8217;t say at your eulogy that you spent that much time that you went to Columbia. They&#8217;ll say, yeah, she went there, it was a really cool accomplishment, or you were in this play and it was amazing. Great accomplishments. But they&#8217;ll talk about how she was as a sister, a friend, a brother, sister, all these things. Mother hopefully, if that&#8217;s what you&#8217;re interested, those are the things. And those have time, natural seasons for it. My mom&#8217;s in her 80s, she&#8217;s not like, oh, I really want to go to grad school and become, no, she wants to be a grandmother. And I&#8217;m at that stage now. My oldest is interested in dating and stuff. But at the same time, I&#8217;m like, it&#8217;s natural and you kind of have to apply the intelligence that you&#8217;ve accrued, the knowledge. Homo sapiens is really knowledge man, but it&#8217;s not wisdom man. Just like artificial intelligence. There&#8217;s like 85 different LLMs that you can choose from. But where&#8217;s the artificial wisdom? I want wisdom. If you wanted knowledge, you can go anywhere. And for a long time all these things are just trained on human knowledge from the internet effectively in training sets, right? What differentiates them? Nothing, they&#8217;re all the same. But wisdom is unique, as anyone who&#8217;s ever met someone who&#8217;s truly wise. Now they might be wise in one small domain, like I really understand how to catch fish off the coast of Coronado, or they know how to interact with their spouse who has a difficult mother-in-law, whatever. There are so many things that you come to in different seasons, and I think the recognition that I&#8217;m maybe my third out of four seasons. I hopefully I&#8217;ll live a long time, but I&#8217;ve accomplished a lot. I&#8217;m happy with what I&#8217;ve accomplished. I still have things ambitiously that I want to do, but I have way more ambitions for the people that I love than for myself. And that was never true when I was your age. I just wanted to get my PhD or get my master&#8217;s and just get on to the next thing. Achieve, achieve, achieve, you write these papers, get this job, get tenure. And it&#8217;s like, they call it the hedonic treadmill for a reason. You just never get off of it. The more you try to approach that. So for me, yeah, as I get older, as I think about death and things on the horizon, hopefully long in the future, as Woody Allen said, what do you want people to say about you when you&#8217;re 100 years from now? And he said, I want to look good for a 150-year-old. Yeah, I&#8217;d like to live as long as possible. But I feel like what&#8217;s more important than transmitting your biology is your ideology. And anyone could do that, and hopefully I&#8217;ve done that, and in my writing, in my work, I&#8217;ll continue to do that. But now it&#8217;s about kind of rounding around the corner to think about how can I give back? And that&#8217;s more satisfying at this stage of my life.</p><p>A meteorite on the White House lawn</p><p>Aryaan Arora: If tomorrow we received undeniable proof that an advanced civilization had contacted Earth, what do you think would be the single biggest thing that changes about humanity overnight?</p><p>Brian Keating: That&#8217;s a really good question. In a sense, we&#8217;ve been there a couple times. We&#8217;ve discovered life that we thought was actually alien. In 1996, I don&#8217;t think you guys were alive, but 1996 on the White House lawn, Bill Clinton came on the White House lawn and he talked about this meteorite, and I don&#8217;t, like this meteorite here, that was found in Antarctica. And the meteorite was thought to have the microbial life on it that came from Mars. This is actually from the Moon, but the Earth and the Moon and Mars exchange material, meaning that impacts on asteroids on these other bodies kick off debris into the solar system. After enough millions of years, they eventually can land on other bodies, including the Earth. And in fact, some of them have. So, we know that this is from the Moon. I have another slice from Mars. So we have Martian meteorites. They happen to be easier to find in Antarctica because you see a rock on top of ice. It&#8217;s pretty obvious and there&#8217;s no other sources of those. And so it was found in the Allan Hills and it was looked at under microscopy and tested and originally thought to be alive. And immediately Clinton made this thing. And in fact, if you watch the movie Contact, he was the president in Contact. And they show a video at the White House, Jodie Foster&#8217;s there, Jill Tarter playing, whatever, the real scientist. And he&#8217;s saying now this rock, it speaks to us across the galaxy and tells the story of our origins, and if it&#8217;s confirmed to be, and so it really wasn&#8217;t retracted that that was a mistake, and it wasn&#8217;t, it was incorrect, it&#8217;s sort of disputed still to this day. Well, maybe it does, maybe, but nobody really takes it seriously that has serious evidence. But for, let&#8217;s call it 10 years, Earth knew, or a lot of people on Earth thought there was life. And obviously a lot of people think there&#8217;s not only alien spaceships, but beings, interdimensional beings and non-biologic humans and non-human biologics and interdimensional. It&#8217;s pretty astounding if those are true. Has life changed at all? I don&#8217;t know. Not for me. I haven&#8217;t. Now, you added the important caveat, indisputable, undeniable proof. Yeah. They haven&#8217;t brought out the alien yet, I haven&#8217;t seen them. We haven&#8217;t seen it. Unfortunately, people claim, oh, they can&#8217;t bring it out because they&#8217;re going to get arrested if they do and they can&#8217;t say what they know. But that&#8217;s pretty convenient. That&#8217;s a way of being unfalsifiable. So, a scientist needs to be able to do experiments on it. Should have some international [inaudible] group of people from countries around the world. You have to ask why do they see these things near military bases or off the coast, oceans and near military operating areas? Not really clear. So there are a lot more questions than answers, but the counterfactual where we do know, say we have discovered indisputable proof, I think it could be potentially one of the biggest discoveries of all time. But you also have to look at history. I mean, for me it would be this incredible thing. For you, it would be, the average person, and in Chula Vista or wherever, will they care about it? We discovered the origin of the universe in 1965. That the Big Bang occurred billions of years ago. Some people changed their lives, religious people tried to co-opt it and say it was part of the biblical narrative. Atheists said no, we don&#8217;t need. I think it&#8217;ll be disputed. I think anything will be disputed. I think it&#8217;ll be inconclusive for a long time and then it will just be accepted as mundane fact about the universe that we&#8217;re not alone. I believe that there&#8217;s life in the universe to some degree of credulity. I don&#8217;t like to say believe, but I believe that there&#8217;s a possibility of it, but there&#8217;s zero evidence for it. We don&#8217;t have any evidence, hard evidence, visual data, spectroscopic data, hard evidence of alien craft that scientists have had any chance to interact with.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Avi Loeb has presented a lot of evidence from his side, but it&#8217;s</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah, but even he doesn&#8217;t believe that those are aliens for sure. He believes that they could plausibly be from another solar system, which would be alien. But again, if discovering life on Mars alone in our own solar, we don&#8217;t need it to come from &#8216;Oumuamua or Atlas, we don&#8217;t need that. We just need it to be here in our solar system. We have yet to discover that. So the question is how likely is it in a universe teeming with life that we should find no other life just in our own solar system? We find abundant life on Earth. We find zero life elsewhere for now. They haven&#8217;t looked everywhere. But you can never look everywhere. Oh, well, you could always say, well, there&#8217;s aliens on the north pole of Titan, some moon of Saturn. Okay, that doesn&#8217;t do me any good. I&#8217;m never going to get there. There&#8217;s a unicorn on Neptune&#8217;s north pole. Okay, fine. But you can&#8217;t get there. You can&#8217;t explore it. You can&#8217;t falsify it. So, is it part of science? That&#8217;s the thing that troubles me. People conflate eyewitness reports, which I believe that they had, but some of those things are very unreliable. We don&#8217;t accept a lot of eyewitness testimony because human beings are fallible and they see things, they mistake things. But the underlying answer to your question, if it was discovered, for me it would be probably the greatest discovery of all time. Would it make me rethink all my life? Not necessarily. I don&#8217;t tie my kind of scientific epistemology to my interpersonal, as I said, I&#8217;m a pragmatist. I&#8217;m a behaviorist. How does this religion, how do the aliens change my behavior? Would I stop giving to charity? Would I treat my neighbor&#8217;s wife differently? [laughter] No. And not at all. Not in a microsecond.</p><p>The Nobel Prize was an idol</p><p>Amira Arora: You brought your book though. I want to talk a little bit about that. Your experience around the Nobel Prize. Did that also change your view about how you saw academia?</p><p>Brian Keating: Definitely. But it more changed my life and how I saw religion because for me it was sort of an idol. It was an idol that was acceptable to worship, like the World Cup or an Oscar, for me the Nobel Prize was all that wrapped into one. It was godlike figures of scientific history and lore going back to Einstein. And over time I had to confront that in myself that I did worship it. So it&#8217;s a memoir of what it&#8217;s like to aspire to this thing that you, the emperor, and then find out it&#8217;s naked at some level, that it has these foibles and flaws, and the people that win it aren&#8217;t gods. They&#8217;re normal men and women. Mostly men, unfortunately. But now there&#8217;s a few women that I&#8217;ve interviewed that have won it. And because of that, I no longer see it as this thing. I no longer need it as this talisman, like my kid asked me the other day, what if you win, Daddy? You have to take back your book. I&#8217;m like, I&#8217;ll cross that bridge when I come to it. I don&#8217;t think it&#8217;s necessarily going to happen because I&#8217;m so critical of it and the damage it does, but also the wonderful people that win it. So it&#8217;s a very complex thing, it&#8217;s like Schrödinger would have a field day with it because it has good and bad aspects amalgamated into one.</p><p>I don&#8217;t regret the things I do</p><p>Amira Arora: Yeah. As we close, you obviously spend so much of your time, your work, talking about the universe, studying the universe. What&#8217;s your project that you&#8217;re currently working on? If tomorrow you were told that the universe will end and you have to say goodbye to the people you love, how does that make you feel personally? Because I&#8217;m sure these are questions that you wonder about. But I think about it as well.</p><p>Brian Keating: My answer is that I try to live in a state of being that I don&#8217;t regret the things I do. I celebrate. Like I told you, I&#8217;m very proud of what I&#8217;ve accomplished, but the proudest things that I&#8217;ve accomplished have nothing to do with science or money or podcast or downloads or views. It&#8217;s people, it&#8217;s connections, it&#8217;s the community. It&#8217;s the things that make me uniquely human. And part of it, part of who I am as a scientist. Yeah, that is a dimension of it. So yeah, I know it&#8217;s not satisfying, like, oh, I&#8217;m going to cry, call my wife. But suffice to say, I think I try to live and comport myself in a way that, I wouldn&#8217;t want to, but I could not be here in the near future. And I hope that the impact, I know that the impact, I&#8217;m not going to be humble, so I hope that I don&#8217;t know. I know that big impact. Yeah. I know there&#8217;d be a lot of tears at my funeral and I know the next day people will get on with their lives. I&#8217;m open to the idea that life will go on without me. And I know that it will, but I hope that I made, I know that I made an impact on a certain subset of people. And I hope I get the chance to continue doing it through appearances like this and through my own work and teaching and research and writing, and I&#8217;m glad that I get the opportunity to be here with you guys and share it with your audience.</p><p>Amira Arora: Thank you so much. It&#8217;s always a wonder when we talk with scientists because it always ends up crossing bridges with philosophy and this purpose of life, human existence, what it means to be a good life. It was wonderful to see this side of you as well. It was such an honor. Thank you so much.</p><p>Brian Keating: You guys could be here. Yeah. Thank you for coming on the show.</p><p>Aryaan Arora: Thanks.</p>								</div>
				</div>
					</div>
				</div>
				</div>
		]]></content>
		
					<link rel="replies" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/are-we-in-a-simulation-brian-keating-on-the-arora-podcast/#comments" thr:count="0" />
			<link rel="replies" type="application/atom+xml" href="https://briankeating.com/are-we-in-a-simulation-brian-keating-on-the-arora-podcast/feed/atom/" thr:count="0" />
			<thr:total>0</thr:total>
			</entry>
		<entry>
		<author>
			<name>sabartigas</name>
					</author>

		<title type="html"><![CDATA[Jim Al-Khalili: Physicists Are Being Sloppy About Time]]></title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/jim-al-khalili-physicists-are-being-sloppy-about-time/" />

		<id>https://briankeating.com/?p=9034</id>
		<updated>2026-11-01T13:25:58Z</updated>
		<published>2026-11-01T13:23:20Z</published>
		<category scheme="https://briankeating.com" term="Transcripts" />
		<summary type="html"><![CDATA[Jim Al-Khalili: Physicists Are Being Sloppy About Time https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dmqxw4M3yEM Transcript: Brian Keating: [inaudible] aspects of the same thing? Jim Al-Khalili: They&#8217;re being sloppy. In modern physics, according to Einstein, yesterday and tomorrow are equally real as today. There is nowhere in modern physics, our understanding of the laws of physics, that would explain that flow of time. Without gravity, there&#8217;s no time. Without time, there&#8217;s no gravity. Brian Keating: You can travel anywhere in space and come right back. But we cannot travel to yesterday. Physics still can&#8217;t say why. Jim Al-Khalili is a theoretical physicist at the University of Surrey who admits some of his own ideas are somewhat fluffy. Hawking said asking what came before the Big Bang makes no sense. Yet a growing number of cosmologists disagree, and Jim isn&#8217;t sure if either camp is doing physics yet. Near the end, he names a good friend he thinks is very, very wrong about AI. Hey, I just found out that many of you got unsubscribed recently in a YouTube update. Make sure that didn&#8217;t happen. Please make sure that you&#8217;re subscribed and don&#8217;t forget to leave a comment down below. Thanks a lot. It really helps out. ## Which is more real, tomorrow or yesterday? Brian Keating: Which is more real, tomorrow or yesterday? Jim Al-Khalili: Well, in a sense, neither of them exist anymore. Well, tomorrow doesn&#8217;t exist yet. Yesterday has existed and it&#8217;s gone. And it&#8217;s only the present moment that is real. But I think the common sense view would suggest that yesterday should be more real than tomorrow simply because we have records of yesterday, memory of yesterday. We know it&#8217;s happened. Tomorrow has yet to happen. Even in what we call a deterministic universe, where events will unfold in some way that is fated to happen, it&#8217;s still something that we can&#8217;t predict. So we&#8217;d say that yesterday is more real than tomorrow. But in modern physics, according to Einstein, yesterday and tomorrow are equally real as today. This is what&#8217;s called the eternalist view of time, which is to say that all times exist. We just happen to live in the present moment, so it seems special to us. But all times are equally real. Brian Keating: And when we think about the different definitions of time, we have biological time, we have thermodynamic time, we have psychological time. I looked over yesterday where I used to have a toddler and now I&#8217;ve got a teenager. The kind of notion that these clocks should be somehow related to each other is to me a great mystery. And yet we physicists, we talk about the fabric of spacetime, Jim, and we wax poetically about space and time are one uniform fabric. Well, I don&#8217;t know about you, but if I want to go to St. Louis or Surrey or the South Pole again tomorrow, I could figure out a way to do it. If I want to go to yesterday, I can&#8217;t. So are physicists lying when we say things like fabric of spacetime, and space and time are just aspects of the same thing? Jim Al-Khalili: They&#8217;re being sloppy. What I&#8217;d say, because Einstein&#8217;s lesson when he developed his special theory of relativity in 1905 was, it&#8217;s certainly correct that space and time get mixed up. So when you&#8217;re looking at different clocks that are moving relative to each other, they tick at different rates. And the way to understand that is to appreciate that we don&#8217;t live in a universe that runs according to Newton&#8217;s idea of time, which is to say some cosmic clock that ticks by the seconds, minutes, hours, years, the same for everyone regardless of how fast we&#8217;re moving relative to each other. Einstein says, &#8220;No, time and space get mixed up.&#8221; But I think that&#8217;s then the mistake that&#8217;s made. The fact that time and space get mixed up and you can only really talk about four-dimensional spacetime doesn&#8217;t mean that time is just another axis like the axes of space. I&#8217;m here on the south coast of the UK. You&#8217;re over in California. Where I am in space is real to me. But I also know that where you are in space is real to you. And I know that anywhere on the moon is real, or somewhere on some distant galaxy. And I can go to those places and come back here. So you&#8217;re right. Time is very different. I can&#8217;t go to some other time in the past or the future. I am constrained. Psychologically, we imagine that we&#8217;re drifting along the time axis, that time is flowing, it&#8217;s carrying us forward. There is nowhere in modern physics, our understanding of the laws of physics, that would explain that flow of time, that movement through time. That seems to be something that we experience. So I&#8217;m not so keen on the different types of time as such. For me, time is time, and events happen and there&#8217;s cause and effect and there&#8217;s ways of measuring it. There&#8217;s ways of determining how fast clocks are ticking, but there should be one underlying thing that we call time. It&#8217;s not absolute, but it&#8217;s there for any given person. Time is time. ## Time is what a clock measures Brian Keating: Yeah. And I think that&#8217;s the kind of language, the paucity of the economics of language that we have. When I asked Frank Wilczek many years ago on the podcast, &#8220;What&#8217;s time?&#8221; he said, &#8220;Time is what a clock measures.&#8221; Oh, thank you, Frank. That&#8217;s really helpful. But sometimes it does seem like maybe that&#8217;s the best that we can do. Frank&#8217;s a theorist. I asked it to Bill Phillips, who won the Nobel Prize as well and works at NIST and the accurate measurement of time to the [inaudible] or fractions of a [inaudible] that you so delightfully narrate in this book. What is time? Is it just shut up and look]]></summary>

					<content type="html" xml:base="https://briankeating.com/jim-al-khalili-physicists-are-being-sloppy-about-time/"><![CDATA[		<div data-elementor-type="wp-post" data-elementor-id="9034" class="elementor elementor-9034">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-05e8be5 e-flex e-con-boxed wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-parent" data-id="05e8be5" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
					<div class="e-con-inner">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-07d29f1 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="07d29f1" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Jim Al-Khalili: Physicists Are Being Sloppy About Time</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-46bbb61 elementor-widget elementor-widget-video" data-id="46bbb61" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-settings="{&quot;youtube_url&quot;:&quot;https:\/\/www.youtube.com\/watch?v=dmqxw4M3yEM&quot;,&quot;video_type&quot;:&quot;youtube&quot;,&quot;controls&quot;:&quot;yes&quot;}" data-widget_type="video.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-wrapper elementor-open-inline">
			<div class="elementor-video"></div>		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-40cae1b elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="40cae1b" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<h2><strong>Transcript:</strong></h2><p>Brian Keating: [inaudible] aspects of the same thing?</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: They&#8217;re being sloppy. In modern physics, according to Einstein, yesterday and tomorrow are equally real as today. There is nowhere in modern physics, our understanding of the laws of physics, that would explain that flow of time. Without gravity, there&#8217;s no time. Without time, there&#8217;s no gravity.</p><p>Brian Keating: You can travel anywhere in space and come right back. But we cannot travel to yesterday. Physics still can&#8217;t say why. Jim Al-Khalili is a theoretical physicist at the University of Surrey who admits some of his own ideas are somewhat fluffy. Hawking said asking what came before the Big Bang makes no sense. Yet a growing number of cosmologists disagree, and Jim isn&#8217;t sure if either camp is doing physics yet. Near the end, he names a good friend he thinks is very, very wrong about AI.</p><p>Hey, I just found out that many of you got unsubscribed recently in a YouTube update. Make sure that didn&#8217;t happen. Please make sure that you&#8217;re subscribed and don&#8217;t forget to leave a comment down below. Thanks a lot. It really helps out.</p><p>## Which is more real, tomorrow or yesterday?</p><p>Brian Keating: Which is more real, tomorrow or yesterday?</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: Well, in a sense, neither of them exist anymore. Well, tomorrow doesn&#8217;t exist yet. Yesterday has existed and it&#8217;s gone. And it&#8217;s only the present moment that is real. But I think the common sense view would suggest that yesterday should be more real than tomorrow simply because we have records of yesterday, memory of yesterday. We know it&#8217;s happened. Tomorrow has yet to happen. Even in what we call a deterministic universe, where events will unfold in some way that is fated to happen, it&#8217;s still something that we can&#8217;t predict. So we&#8217;d say that yesterday is more real than tomorrow. But in modern physics, according to Einstein, yesterday and tomorrow are equally real as today. This is what&#8217;s called the eternalist view of time, which is to say that all times exist. We just happen to live in the present moment, so it seems special to us. But all times are equally real.</p><p>Brian Keating: And when we think about the different definitions of time, we have biological time, we have thermodynamic time, we have psychological time. I looked over yesterday where I used to have a toddler and now I&#8217;ve got a teenager. The kind of notion that these clocks should be somehow related to each other is to me a great mystery. And yet we physicists, we talk about the fabric of spacetime, Jim, and we wax poetically about space and time are one uniform fabric. Well, I don&#8217;t know about you, but if I want to go to St. Louis or Surrey or the South Pole again tomorrow, I could figure out a way to do it. If I want to go to yesterday, I can&#8217;t. So are physicists lying when we say things like fabric of spacetime, and space and time are just aspects of the same thing?</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: They&#8217;re being sloppy. What I&#8217;d say, because Einstein&#8217;s lesson when he developed his special theory of relativity in 1905 was, it&#8217;s certainly correct that space and time get mixed up. So when you&#8217;re looking at different clocks that are moving relative to each other, they tick at different rates. And the way to understand that is to appreciate that we don&#8217;t live in a universe that runs according to Newton&#8217;s idea of time, which is to say some cosmic clock that ticks by the seconds, minutes, hours, years, the same for everyone regardless of how fast we&#8217;re moving relative to each other. Einstein says, &#8220;No, time and space get mixed up.&#8221; But I think that&#8217;s then the mistake that&#8217;s made. The fact that time and space get mixed up and you can only really talk about four-dimensional spacetime doesn&#8217;t mean that time is just another axis like the axes of space. I&#8217;m here on the south coast of the UK. You&#8217;re over in California. Where I am in space is real to me. But I also know that where you are in space is real to you. And I know that anywhere on the moon is real, or somewhere on some distant galaxy. And I can go to those places and come back here. So you&#8217;re right. Time is very different. I can&#8217;t go to some other time in the past or the future. I am constrained. Psychologically, we imagine that we&#8217;re drifting along the time axis, that time is flowing, it&#8217;s carrying us forward. There is nowhere in modern physics, our understanding of the laws of physics, that would explain that flow of time, that movement through time. That seems to be something that we experience. So I&#8217;m not so keen on the different types of time as such. For me, time is time, and events happen and there&#8217;s cause and effect and there&#8217;s ways of measuring it. There&#8217;s ways of determining how fast clocks are ticking, but there should be one underlying thing that we call time. It&#8217;s not absolute, but it&#8217;s there for any given person. Time is time.</p><p>## Time is what a clock measures</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah. And I think that&#8217;s the kind of language, the paucity of the economics of language that we have. When I asked Frank Wilczek many years ago on the podcast, &#8220;What&#8217;s time?&#8221; he said, &#8220;Time is what a clock measures.&#8221; Oh, thank you, Frank. That&#8217;s really helpful. But sometimes it does seem like maybe that&#8217;s the best that we can do. Frank&#8217;s a theorist. I asked it to Bill Phillips, who won the Nobel Prize as well and works at NIST and the accurate measurement of time to the [inaudible] or fractions of a [inaudible] that you so delightfully narrate in this book. What is time? Is it just shut up and look at your watch?</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: In the same way that I&#8217;ve never been a fan of the Copenhagen view of quantum mechanics, or certainly the shut up and calculate version of it, I&#8217;m also not a fan of this definition that time is that thing that clocks measure. No, we invented clocks as instruments to measure durations, intervals between events. We invented the units that we measure time in, the hours, the minutes, the seconds and all those fractions of seconds, and ultimately they&#8217;re based on certain periodic things that humans have discovered, like the rotation of the earth on its axis, the orbits around the sun. But none of that means that time isn&#8217;t a real thing that exists independently of us. Time would exist even if there were no clocks that would measure it. It is the thing that we measure with clocks. But I think that does time a huge disservice to suggest that all it is is that thing that we measure, in the same way that it might say space is just that thing that you measure with a tape measure. Space is real and I think time is real too.</p><p>Brian Keating: Maybe, as I was reading the book, I thought maybe time can be defined independently, almost the way that we use in differential geometry a vector and a dual, a one-form versus a vector, and that the thing that&#8217;s uniting them is change, right? So if you have change, there&#8217;s some velocity and a gradient in some space. Is time sort of what we just manifest, but what&#8217;s really fundamental, non-emergent, is change? Whatever that means.</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: Is change. Again, I know, philosophers of physics, physicists studying the foundations of physics, and indeed philosophers going all the way back to antiquity have argued about this issue. What is more fundamental? Is it time that&#8217;s more fundamental? Is it change? Can you have time without change? Can you have change without time? In my view, of course, change needs time, but I don&#8217;t think time needs change. In a universe where nothing was changing, I could still imagine time is ticking by, even if there are no clocks to measure the ticking of time. Very often people talk about the standard example when you talk about the second law of thermodynamics, and you have some isolated system, say a box of gas, and if it starts off in some highly special ordered state, like all the molecules in one corner, and as entropy increases those molecules are basically spreading themselves out until they reach what we call thermal equilibrium, then that doesn&#8217;t mean that time isn&#8217;t flowing by. There may be no change, or there may be certainly no way of even appreciating the direction that time is moving. That&#8217;s tough luck on us, right? Because all you&#8217;re seeing is molecules bouncing around randomly. You could take a movie of it and run the movie backwards and you wouldn&#8217;t be able to tell. But I still think time is going by even when there&#8217;s no change. You look at a stone and it&#8217;s not doing anything, just sitting there on the beach. But there is time and there is change, because outside of that there are things that are changing. Okay, you say, right, well, let&#8217;s include the surrounding environment of the stone and freeze all of that. Well, fine, there&#8217;s still time flowing by outside of that, and you can go out larger and larger and larger layers as you include more of the environment until you reach the whole universe. Then, right, okay, fine, you&#8217;re the cosmologist. I would argue that once you reach the whole universe, if you had this ability of having the god&#8217;s eye view of sitting outside of spacetime, sure, it may be there&#8217;s no change. It may be that it&#8217;s timeless. As famously Wheeler and DeWitt gave us this wonderful equation many decades ago that suggests there is no time once you&#8217;re describing the entire universe. But we&#8217;re stuck inside the universe and there&#8217;s always change somewhere, and therefore there is always time.</p><p>## Was there a before the Big Bang?</p><p>Brian Keating: But I do think of this, the statement by Stephen Hawking that I heard many times, asking what happened before the Big Bang is like&#8230; But that&#8217;s not really canonical anymore. There are many proposals from people I&#8217;ve had on the podcast, ranging from Julian Barbour, mentioned Paul Steinhardt, Neil Turok, many different scientists that throughout the history, from Tolman and others, who speak about time before the Big Bang. The thing that puzzles me, Jim, and I&#8217;m seeking my psychological advice, I need to resolve this anxiety, but how can time come into existence? It&#8217;s such a strange thing. Space, you could see space embedded in a zero-dimensional point perhaps, and embedded in an infinite-dimensional&#8230; at least we have notions of a Hilbert space. But can we think of time? It&#8217;s sort of like there&#8217;s a reaction, but there&#8217;s no action.</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: If time begins at the Big Bang&#8230; Stephen Hawking&#8217;s original idea many years ago, this no-boundary proposal, suggested that as you get closer and closer to the Big Bang, time as I understand it becomes more like a direction in space. It&#8217;s a bit like, for those who study the physics of black holes, when you fall through the event horizon of a black hole and you&#8217;re then sort of falling down towards a singularity, because spacetime is so curved round, that radial direction towards a singularity becomes a direction in time, not a direction in space. So hitting the singularity is as inevitable as hitting tomorrow, because you can&#8217;t stop going through time. The Big Bang is the opposite of that. Going back, well, according to Hawking anyway, if all you&#8217;re sort of thinking about is what general relativity tells us, then you get closer and closer to the Big Bang, time becomes more like a spatial direction, and then it is a bit more like getting closer and closer to the South Pole, and you get to the South Pole and say, keep heading south, and of course every step you take is north again. But that is one picture. That was Hawking&#8217;s idea of how time could begin at the Big Bang. It&#8217;s not that there was no time and then there is time. It&#8217;s more of a gradual time emerging from something that looks more like a spatial dimension. Of course, as you say, asking the question, what was before the Big Bang? That used to be, sort of, physicists would just dismiss those ideas. If you think hard, deeply about it, it&#8217;s nothing more than metaphysics, but it&#8217;s basically there can be no before the Big Bang, &#8217;cause there was no time to embed the word &#8220;before&#8221; in. It&#8217;s just meaningless. A lot of cosmologists are coming up with neat ideas to suggest that maybe there was a time before the Big Bang. The Big Bang was simply the beginning of our universe. But you know what? What if our universe is a bubble that sort of popped into existence within some higher-dimensional multiverse? What if Neil Turok&#8217;s and others&#8217; idea of this mirror universe? The Big Bang may just be a point about which time moves symmetrically in both directions. So time moves forward for us, but there could be another universe before the Big Bang that&#8217;s heading in the other time direction. They&#8217;re in our past. If there&#8217;s any intelligent life in that universe, they would think that we&#8217;re in their past. These are neat ideas, and I think it&#8217;s fun to be asking questions like, was there a before the Big Bang? The fact of the matter is we do not know. It&#8217;s even argued by many that this isn&#8217;t really physics, right? Because physics is an empirical science. Until you can come up with some sort of experiment to test your hypothesis, it&#8217;s just a neat idea. And I do sometimes find it amusing that, I mean, correct me if I&#8217;m wrong, but a lot of papers in cosmology and theoretical cosmology don&#8217;t get beyond the preprint stage, because the authors publish a paper, then six months later they&#8217;ve changed their minds and they&#8217;ve moved on to something else. [laughter] So I don&#8217;t know. They&#8217;re fun things to think about. I&#8217;m not sure if we&#8217;re at a point yet. They&#8217;re moving from metaphysics into proper physics, but we&#8217;re not at a point yet where we can say these are established ideas that we can test.</p><p>## In a collapsing universe</p><p>Brian Keating: Yeah. As my friend, and probably yours too, Sir Roger Penrose used to say, the safest thing in all of physics was to make a bet with Stephen Hawking, because he&#8217;d always change his mind, and so he&#8217;d be right as often as he&#8217;d be right. But yeah, speaking of Hawking, as you mentioned, in *A Brief History of Time*, which you&#8217;d think would address this question, he introduces several things like M-theory and string theory as if they&#8217;re proven. And he does motivate the no-boundary hypothesis as if it&#8217;s sort of accepted. And even inflation, at that time in 1989, something wasn&#8217;t accepted. And he introduces the no-boundary proposal. And he goes, &#8220;I want you to stay with me.&#8221; I know it&#8217;s dangerous, and having equations in the book will reduce its book sales by half, but mentioning God will double the book sales. So it kind of counterbalances itself, and says at the end of the book, the mind of God, if you have string theory. But he says, &#8220;Here&#8217;s what we&#8217;re going to do. We&#8217;re going to do this thing called a Wick rotation,&#8221; and as you said, it&#8217;s going to turn time into space. &#8220;But don&#8217;t worry, it&#8217;s just a simple trick. It&#8217;s just a mathematical trick.&#8221; And then the whole predicate of the book is based on this trick, which nobody really understands what a Wick rotation is. And you do as good a job as anybody is sort of explaining the problems with that idea. But I do want to ask this question that stumped you as a student, stumps me to this day. What does it mean that in a collapsing universe, you wouldn&#8217;t necessarily have a different perspective on the future versus the past? You wouldn&#8217;t be able to distinguish, if we&#8217;re in a collapsing universe, it wouldn&#8217;t be like things run back in time. Can you explain that? Unpack that for me.</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: Thomas [inaudible] came up with this idea that the Gold universe would suggest that the Big Bang is this very beginning of time. The universe was in a very special state. It was like a clock that&#8217;s wound up, ready to unwind. Then the universe expands, gets bigger, but it reaches some maximum expansion, then recollapses in on itself back to a big crunch. But the idea there was that there&#8217;s a symmetry. The big crunch should be just like the Big Bang, which is to say a highly ordered state, a low entropy state. Now, if the second law of thermodynamics says as the universe expands entropy is increasing, and there are lots of different measures of entropy, but let&#8217;s just say the universe is becoming more disordered, becoming a less special state until it reaches some maximum expansion. That&#8217;s the maximum entropy to get to. Then it starts collapsing. Now it&#8217;s going to get back to something like the Big Bang. Entropy has to decrease in the collapsing phase. And so the idea there is that our psychological perception of the direction of time should follow the thermodynamic arrow of time. Thermodynamics should operate in the brain as they would in any other part of the universe. And so if this entropy is decreasing in the collapsing phase, that means the thermodynamic arrow of time has switched over. It&#8217;s now pointing towards the Big Bang, which means our psychological arrow is pointing towards the Big Bang. So now the Big Bang is in our future. He published a paper in the mid-&#8217;80s, and this is the paper I&#8217;ll talk about in the book, and as a grad student I read it and didn&#8217;t agree with it, and I had lots of ideas about why it was wrong, but I didn&#8217;t have the maths background to get beyond the first or second page of the paper. So I did nothing about it. But it&#8217;s this idea: what would happen if you&#8217;re in a rocket and the universe is just about to reach the point of maximum expansion at 3:00 p.m. one afternoon? What happens at one minute to three? You say, &#8220;Oh, the 3:00 is in my future, and the universe is still expanding.&#8221; You get to 3:00. One minute past three, the universe is collapsing. But now I&#8217;m still thinking that maximum expansion point is in my future, and it just didn&#8217;t make any sense to me. It&#8217;s a really confusing idea, the fact that arrows of time should flip over in the Gold universe. Hawking himself, of course, to his credit, in *A Brief History of Time* owns up. This is another example of him admitting that he&#8217;d made a mistake, and he said, no, this nonsense what I said in that paper. And I remember reading his book, *History of Time*, on a train and grinning broadly, with, yeah, I thought that, damn it, why didn&#8217;t I write something up at the time?</p><p>Brian Keating: Why didn&#8217;t I use the Wick rotation?</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: [inaudible] Exactly. If I knew what it was at the time. [laughter]</p><p>## What did Einstein believe about time?</p><p>Brian Keating: You write very beautifully in the book that nothing more compellingly shows just how conceptually different physical time and manifest time is than the consequences of Einstein&#8217;s theory of general relativity. What did Einstein believe about time? What did he say and what did he believe? Because it seems to me, just as his ideas about religion and God, it&#8217;s very ambiguous and it&#8217;s not clear exactly what he believed. But you&#8217;re a scholar. What did he truly believe?</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: I think, I mean, it took him a while to really appreciate what his mathematics was saying, particularly after his special theory of relativity. It wasn&#8217;t Einstein who said time is the fourth dimension, time and space have to be combined together. That was Hermann Minkowski. But of course Einstein picked up on that idea and led to his notion of a block universe, that space and all times coexist. This is the eternalist picture. I think he genuinely believed that all times were equally real. Our now, our present moment in our reference frame, is some point along the time axis in our reference frame, and that point we perceive, psychological time, manifest time, to be creeping along the time axis. For Einstein, there was nothing special about that. There&#8217;s an example I&#8217;ve started using. If I&#8217;m reading a book, say a novel, and I&#8217;m on page 150, then all the pages before 150 I&#8217;ve read. I know about them, I remember them, they&#8217;re in my past. All the pages after 150 are in my future. I have yet to read them. But if I close the book, page 150 is no longer special. All pages are equally real. And I think that Einstein generally believed this notion that all times are equally real. There&#8217;s nothing special about the present moment. There is the story that he was consoling the widow of a good friend of his at the funeral by trying to persuade her that she may be grieving now because of the loss of her husband, but all those moments in the past when he was alive are just as real as now. He&#8217;s just as alive in spacetime as he&#8217;s ever been.</p><p>## Loschmidt&#8217;s paradox</p><p>Brian Keating: There&#8217;s a character in this book that makes an appearance. A lot of paradoxes when it comes to time, but none more kind of grievous to the mind when we encounter it for the first time. I never encountered it before I read this book on time. It&#8217;s called Loschmidt&#8217;s paradox. Sounds like Locksmith, which probably is, or maybe it&#8217;s a lake or something up there in Scotland, you&#8217;ll tell me. And it seemed to evoke some notions of Maxwell&#8217;s demon, but no demons are harmed in the making of this paradox. So first, can you explain Loschmidt&#8217;s paradox? What is it? Why is it so significant that you devote so much attention to it?</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: Loschmidt&#8217;s paradox was something that was known and discussed and debated in the 19th century, the mid-19th century, by people like James Clerk Maxwell and Ludwig Boltzmann. These are guys that were developing statistical mechanics and thermodynamics. And it&#8217;s the idea that there&#8217;s this real puzzle between how time is perceived in two different areas of physics. On the one hand, you&#8217;ve got the equations that describe how systems change over time, the dynamical equations of physics. Now, these could be Newton&#8217;s equations of motion. It could be Schrödinger&#8217;s equation of quantum mechanics. It could be the diffusion equation, the electromagnetic wave equation. All of those equations have time coming in as a parameter, right? The lowercase t. And you solve those equations to get a solution, and then you plug in a value for that t, and that tells you what the thing that you&#8217;re studying is doing at that moment. These are equations that describe the fundamental ways that systems change over time in all areas of physics. And what&#8217;s special about them is that you can run them forwards and backwards in time without breaking any laws of physics. Sometimes running them forward and backwards, it&#8217;s quite symmetrical. So this is what the system is like. Now if I evolve the equation forward 10 seconds, the system will have changed. It&#8217;d be something else. If I evolve it back in time 10 seconds, it&#8217;ll look exactly like it does 10 seconds in the future. Sometimes it doesn&#8217;t look the same, like the universe expanding. 10 seconds from now it&#8217;ll be bigger, but 10 seconds ago it was smaller. But that doesn&#8217;t mean that you&#8217;re breaking your laws of physics. If you turn time in the opposite direction, you just describe a collapsing universe rather than an expanding universe, and so on. So these equations are all said to be time reversal invariance, in essence symmetric in time. And yet Loschmidt&#8217;s paradox says, hang on a minute, the second law of thermodynamics says time is irreversible. It only moves in one direction. I get older, balls roll down hills, ice melts in water, the cream mixes in coffee. How do you get that irreversibility from fundamental equations that are reversible, that are symmetric in time? This is the paradox, the problem of physics that people worried about.</p><p>Brian Keating: Hey, do me a favor. I know you&#8217;re enjoying this on YouTube, but make sure you follow me on Spotify too, and leave a review. That helps out more than I can tell you.</p><p>## The block universe and the past hypothesis</p><p>Brian Keating: The other character, another major topic in the book, involves things like the block universe and the past hypothesis. I&#8217;ve had on David Albert, and I kind of feel like they&#8217;re both sort of ad hoc axioms that are bolted on to a framework to make certain people feel more comfortable about their choice of paradigm. I used to think, why do we need an interpretation of quantum mechanics? I don&#8217;t have an interpretation of classical mechanics. But it seems like we do need an interpretation of thermodynamics. But what is the past hypothesis and the block universe? How are they related? What, if anything, do they do besides kind of maybe assuage people&#8217;s feelings at 3 in the morning?</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: I sort of think of them as differently. You have these different areas of physics. You have the dynamical equations of motion, in which time appears as a parameter. That&#8217;s what&#8217;s called coordinate time, right? Then you have the block universe and spacetime, where time isn&#8217;t a coordinate. It&#8217;s an entire axis. It&#8217;s the fourth dimension of spacetime, not the same as the dimensions, the axes of space, but nevertheless it&#8217;s part of four-dimensional spacetime. Then you have a third picture, which is thermodynamics, which says time isn&#8217;t a parameter, it&#8217;s not a dimension, it&#8217;s an arrow. It&#8217;s a direction. It points in one direction only. That is linked to this Loschmidt&#8217;s paradox. How do you get an arrow of time when the fundamental equations of physics are symmetric? The past hypothesis is a way of finessing that. It&#8217;s almost cheating, because what it says: imagine today the universe has a certain value of entropy. This is the measure of disorder that the second law of thermodynamics says is always increasing. Tomorrow the entropy of the universe will be bigger. Yesterday the entropy of the universe should be smaller. But if time is symmetric, then yesterday the entropy should increase just like it increases tomorrow. But what&#8217;s special about today? I could have measured the entropy yesterday. They&#8217;d have told you, no, it was definitely less than it is today. So what if you push the special moment back to last week? Now yesterday had lower entropy than today. Today has lower entropy than tomorrow, and so on. But what was special about last week? So the past hypothesis is the idea that you push that special moment all the way back to the Big Bang, after which, at all times, entropy is increasing. You say, yeah, but surely it&#8217;s symmetric. What about entropy increasing to the past? Ah, but there&#8217;s no past before the Big Bang. So we&#8217;ve finessed the problem. We don&#8217;t have to worry about entropy increasing to the past, because we start at a low entropy. And that&#8217;s what this past hypothesis is essentially saying. It solves this problem of time reversal invariance. What it breaks is time translation invariance. It says, is there something special about a particular moment? It&#8217;s an add-on, right? To help us understand why time appears all around us to be pointing from the past to the future and doesn&#8217;t run in both directions at once.</p><p>## The past hypothesis for free</p><p>Brian Keating: And you connect that to fine-tuning. Can you explain that argument and where it succeeds or fails?</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: We seem to need two things to describe the Big Bang. One is the past hypothesis, that the universe started off in a very special state, low entropy state, highly ordered state. And the other is that fundamental constants of nature, the forces, the speed of light and all the fundamental constants, had to be a certain value in order for the universe to evolve and be the way it is today. If anything was, the charge on the electron was a bit greater, atoms would be unstable. If gravity was too weak, stars and galaxies would never form, and so on. Everything had to be fine-tuned just right to give us this interesting, complex, structured universe we have today. My argument is that I don&#8217;t know why those initial conditions were the way they were. I don&#8217;t have an explanation for the fine-tuning, but my argument is that fine-tuning itself gives us a highly ordered, low entropy universe. It gives us the past hypothesis for free. So I don&#8217;t see them as two separate things. We need fine-tuning and a past hypothesis? I would argue we need fine-tuning, and the past hypothesis emerges from that naturally.</p><p>Brian Keating: Just a quick interruption from today&#8217;s sponsor: me, Brian Keating. Since it&#8217;s Nobel Prize season, I can&#8217;t resist advertising my three books. First book I wrote is called *Losing the Nobel Prize*. It&#8217;s a cosmology story mixed with a memoir of what it feels like to do science at the highest level and, spoiler alert, fail. But my next book, *Think Like a Nobel Prize Winner*, tells a story of nine Nobel laureates who will reveal their insights and actions, how to take your science or just your job in general to the next level. It&#8217;s full of insights and tips that I never would have thought of. And lastly, my book published last year, *Focus Like a Nobel Prize Winner*, is written for students of all ages to learn the tools and the tricks to compete with yourself, which sometimes could be the hardest competitor of all. Get all three of them, Amazon affiliate links in the description below. And if you&#8217;ve read them already, I&#8217;d love it if you leave a review. Every single review helps. Now, back to the episode.</p><p>## Without gravity, there&#8217;s no time</p><p>Brian Keating: The last major topic before we wrap up, I know it&#8217;s late there, is this new proposal that you have, which kind of is reminiscent, at least rhymes with Einstein&#8217;s conception of time and gravity being uniquely intertwined. And you give it a new spin, literally a new spin, in a quantum mechanical version of time&#8217;s reality. You call it not emergent, but in a real, true, honest-to-goodness physicalist sense. First of all, can you explain, again going back to our friend Einstein, what was the intimacy between gravity and time? Do we have time if there&#8217;s no gravity, in a Minkowski flat universe? And then, if you could explain your quantum proposal as well.</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: So Einstein, he wrote a famous book during the First World War, his theories of special and general relativity, essentially a popular science book about relativity theory, and it underwent many editions. And when a publisher tells an author, &#8220;We&#8217;re going to have a new edition, do you have any changes?&#8221; they might want to tweak it or add a few things. Einstein didn&#8217;t tweak the main text, but he would add appendices to the book. And the very final appendix he added was just a year or two before he died in the 1950s. And it&#8217;s there where he very beautifully outlines what the connection he believes is between gravity and time and space. He says that unlike the other fields, force fields, say in quantum field theory, which sit on spacetime, you need spacetime, the canvas in which reality sort of plays out, unlike those, the gravitational field is the spacetime. It&#8217;s a manifestation of spacetime. So if there&#8217;s no gravitational field, Einstein would argue there is no spacetime. He&#8217;s gone beyond Minkowski spacetime. The Minkowski spacetime is, there&#8217;s no gravity, right? It&#8217;s not just flat spacetime, because in the limit that gravity gets weaker and weaker, Einstein would say if there&#8217;s no gravitational field, you switch it off, then you&#8217;re removing spacetime itself. And if you have spacetime, then you have a gravitational field. So I think it&#8217;s intimately connected. And if spacetime is space and time, then without gravity there&#8217;s no time, without time there&#8217;s no gravity. So gravity isn&#8217;t just this extra fourth force of nature that we&#8217;re trying to unify with the other quantum forces, electromagnetism and the nuclear forces. It&#8217;s something deeper, something more fundamental. And for me, I think this is the real challenge and reason why we haven&#8217;t found a theory of quantum gravity yet, because we&#8217;re still trying to fit round pegs in square holes by trying to combine gravity in the same way that we dealt with the other forces. Gravity, the gravitational field, is spacetime.</p><p>## The entanglement past hypothesis</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: I came to it because I was trying to understand, is there another way of coming up with the past hypothesis, or in what sense was the universe special? I was led to it from work I did with actually a colleague of yours in UC San Diego, Eddy Chen, who&#8217;s a philosopher of physics, and we published a paper together a couple of years ago on what we call the entanglement past hypothesis. So rather than saying the universe was in some highly ordered thermodynamic state, a low entropy state, we had to come up with a way of defining this notion of entropy, this measure of disorder, down at the quantum level. So some form of quantum entropy. We weren&#8217;t the first to do this. Lots of people have views on what this quantum entropy should be. Von Neumann entropy, it&#8217;s often called. But our suggestion was that maybe at the Big Bang quantum entanglement was very small, that the universe started off in a very pure quantum state rather than a special thermodynamic state, and gradually everything gets entangled with everything else, and as entanglement increases, that gives us an arrow of time pointing from the Big Bang. So rather than having a thermodynamic arrow, which says thermodynamic or Boltzmann entropy is increasing, we&#8217;re saying entanglement is increasing. Entanglement entropy is increasing, starting from a minimum. A lot of people are interested in this idea of whether time itself is emergent from the quantum realm, whether space is emergent from the quantum realm, and is quantum entanglement the fundamental thing that defines how all the other attributes of our universe come about from. It&#8217;s very fluffy. It&#8217;s very hand-wavy. And I&#8217;m relatively new to the game of working in foundations of physics, so I&#8217;m sort of having fun with this, and I keep discovering that if I have a neat idea, I find out this is actually really well known by people in the field. That&#8217;s fine. I don&#8217;t mind.</p><p>Brian Keating: Well, thank God you&#8217;re officially retired, or emeritus now, &#8217;cause&#8230;</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: [inaudible] I don&#8217;t have to worry about my CV or publication.</p><p>Brian Keating: Your tenure case would be perhaps a little bit compromised.</p><p>## Judge your book by its cover</p><p>Brian Keating: Okay, I&#8217;ve got three relatively rapid-fire questions. The first involves what you&#8217;re never supposed to do, but I love to do, which is to judge your book by its cover. We know we&#8217;re not supposed to do it, but Into the Impossible, there&#8217;s nothing to it. Let&#8217;s take a look and judge some books. So take us through the title, the subtitle, and the cover art, please.</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: [inaudible] All of this credit goes to the team at Princeton University Press who published the book. When I was writing it, I had all sorts of ideas for titles: *Adventures Through Time*, *The Reality of Time*, *The Story of Time*, and my publishers said, &#8220;Look, Jim, leave this to us, right? We&#8217;ll come up with something.&#8221; I have to say the title, *On Time*, is brilliant. I absolutely love it. As soon as I saw it, I thought, &#8220;Oh, yeah, that&#8217;s it.&#8221; Of course, the subtitle, *The Physics That Makes the Universe Tick*, then tells you what it&#8217;s all about. But it lends itself to humorous comments about, when I&#8217;m giving talks on the book, I make sure I turn up on time. It&#8217;s literally the title of my book. I better not be late. The cover design, I think, is also very nice. They did talk me through the details of what it all means. What they didn&#8217;t want was to have some sort of clock, even a Dalí sort of melting clock falling into a black hole. No, just have all these lines pointing towards the middle. There&#8217;s a rationale for it, and I wish I had it off the top of my head to explain what they meant by it, but I think it&#8217;s very striking.</p><p>Brian Keating: But I think there&#8217;s an Easter egg here. The orange is a *Clockwork Orange* reference. Come on, Jim. It&#8217;s got to be a Clockwork [inaudible].</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: Hang on now. [laughter]</p><p>## Do they experience time?</p><p>Brian Keating: Okay, two more questions. The required, mandated in the state of California, talk about AI. But a lot of times I hear about artificial intelligence in this concept of, it&#8217;s going to do everything that humans can do. And I point back to the topic that you mentioned in the book. I call it Einstein&#8217;s elevator: an object in free fall. As he said, &#8220;My happiest thought was that an object or observer in free fall experiences no gravitational field,&#8221; which would seem to indicate they obtain no time passage either, according to Einstein, if you can nullify it in the Einstein equivalence principle. By the way, I use that as a counterproof that AI can&#8217;t do physics the way that Einstein could, because it can&#8217;t have a happy thought and it can&#8217;t feel free fall. But maybe they&#8217;ll get around that. But my question is, can they experience time? Do they experience time? They don&#8217;t have psychologies. They have some ways of representing memory, but often it&#8217;s quite bad. Can artificial consciousness participate in the entanglement that you maybe potentially are beginning to subscribe to?</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: I don&#8217;t see why not, actually. I think you&#8217;re right, and artificial intelligence just being intelligent and being able to solve problems that humans can&#8217;t, even coming up with some notion of creativity, that&#8217;s one thing. But being self-aware, I think experiencing time, psychological time, manifest time, is connected somehow with this notion of being aware of the sense of self. When we think of the past, what we&#8217;re doing is accessing memories in our brains, where we&#8217;ve stored as a record of events that have happened in the past. But I think the notion of experiencing time moving, anticipation of the future, remembering the past, being aware that we live in the present moment, I think that requires a sense of knowing oneself, the introspection, sentience. Artificial intelligence is a long way from that. However smart LLMs are, and despite the likes of my good friend Richard Dawkins saying that he believes that Claude is truly conscious, I think he&#8217;s very, very wrong. I don&#8217;t think that means that AI wouldn&#8217;t one day become sentient and self-aware. I think that may not be thinking like a human being will think. It may not feel joy and anger and envy or whatever in the same way we do, but it might become self-aware.</p><p>## Has time taken on a different meaning?</p><p>Brian Keating: Very good, Jim. Well, last question. You became a grandfather, I think, since we last spoke. Is that correct? I think. Has time taken on a different meaning since that happened? Is it qualitatively different since becoming a father? They say that grandfathers and grandchildren get along because they have a common enemy. How does time&#8217;s poignancy affect you now as a grandfather, versus as a father, versus as a single man?</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: I think in lots of ways, and also just getting older. I remember when I turned 40, that was great. Well, that&#8217;s no problem with that. I turned 50, I had a big fabulous party. I turned 60 and you think, my god, this is getting serious now. So there&#8217;s that notion of, I&#8217;ve lived more life than I have left. Your sense of one&#8217;s mortality, and that&#8217;s compounded by the fact that my two children in their 30s. I have one-year-old grandchildren, twins, who are lovely. My father&#8217;s still alive. He&#8217;s 95 and still in very good health. So I still don&#8217;t feel as though I&#8217;m next off the cliff edge, as it were. I still have another generation beyond me who&#8217;s still alive and well. And I think maybe that would change again when my father passes away and I feel I&#8217;m next in line. But you&#8217;re right, having grandchildren does give one a sense of the finiteness of time. Changing my grandchildren&#8217;s nappies reminds me of changing my children&#8217;s nappies, and I can&#8217;t believe that that was more than three decades ago. So that notion that time is speeding up and time is running away from me is certainly a very feeling that I&#8217;m not unique in experiencing.</p><p>Brian Keating: I can&#8217;t wait for you to do many more diaper changes, nappy changes, but also many more books, and hopefully we&#8217;ll get to meet up someday.</p><p>Jim Al-Khalili: I&#8217;ll do both.</p><p>Brian Keating: Thank you, Jim. Congratulations on the success of this new book. Bye-bye.</p><p>Jim just told us that without gravity there may be no time at all. That changes how you think about tomorrow. Subscribe and turn on notifications, and let me know in the comments whether yesterday is as real as tomorrow. And to hear what might have come before the Big Bang, watch my conversation with Neil Turok, linked right [inaudible]</p>								</div>
				</div>
					</div>
				</div>
				</div>
		]]></content>
		
					<link rel="replies" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/jim-al-khalili-physicists-are-being-sloppy-about-time/#comments" thr:count="0" />
			<link rel="replies" type="application/atom+xml" href="https://briankeating.com/jim-al-khalili-physicists-are-being-sloppy-about-time/feed/atom/" thr:count="0" />
			<thr:total>0</thr:total>
			</entry>
		<entry>
		<author>
			<name>sabartigas</name>
					</author>

		<title type="html"><![CDATA[When AI can do almost anything, what&#8217;s left that&#8217;s yours?]]></title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/when-ai-can-do-almost-anything-whats-left-thats-yours/" />

		<id>https://briankeating.com/?p=9024</id>
		<updated>2026-10-26T06:01:07Z</updated>
		<published>2026-10-26T05:55:42Z</published>
		<category scheme="https://briankeating.com" term="Blog" />
		<summary type="html"><![CDATA[When AI can do almost anything, what&#8217;s left that&#8217;s yours? Dear Magicians, On Monday I asked whether a machine could feel Einstein&#8217;s happiest thought. This week I put that question, and a lot more, to Ethan Mollick, who runs the Generative AI Lab at Wharton. His new book, Co-Existence: The Next Phase of AI, is out this week. He builds with these tools every day, and he still draws firm lines about where they don&#8217;t belong. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gEYUgfANlW8 The moment Ethan told me he never lets AI take the first pass at anything that matters: not his writing, not his peer reviews, not his replies to students. His reason comes from his research on innovation. Brainstorming was invented in 1955, and within a couple of years researchers knew it backfired, because once you hear the group&#8217;s ideas, yours start to fit the group. AI does the same thing. It writes a seductive draft you can&#8217;t get out of your head. He also named four human edges for working with AI: deep knowledge, wide knowledge, taste and agency. “The enemy of slop is taste.” Ethan Mollick Take this with you Before you ask AI anything this week, write your own first draft. Rough is fine. Then use AI as the second opinion, never the first. You&#8217;ll keep your own voice, and you&#8217;ll be able to tell when the machine gets it wrong. Until next time, Brian Missed Monday? Can a machine feel the happiest thought of Einstein&#8217;s life? Read this week&#8217;s musing Subscribe to my podcast! More than 2M downloads!]]></summary>

					<content type="html" xml:base="https://briankeating.com/when-ai-can-do-almost-anything-whats-left-thats-yours/"><![CDATA[		<div data-elementor-type="wp-post" data-elementor-id="9024" class="elementor elementor-9024">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-f255ed6 e-flex e-con-boxed wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-parent" data-id="f255ed6" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
					<div class="e-con-inner">
		<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-99726ef e-con-full e-flex wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-child" data-id="99726ef" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-1a75d94 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="1a75d94" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">When AI can do almost anything, what's left that's yours?</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-fa54211 elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="fa54211" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
															<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="549" height="226" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Thursday-header.jpg" class="attachment-medium_large size-medium_large wp-image-9027" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Thursday-header.jpg 549w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Thursday-header-300x123.jpg 300w" sizes="(max-width: 549px) 100vw, 549px" />															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-404a437 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="404a437" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p>Dear Magicians,</p><p>On Monday I asked whether a machine could feel Einstein&#8217;s happiest thought. This week I put that question, and a lot more, to Ethan Mollick, who runs the Generative AI Lab at Wharton. His new book, <a href="https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0G7RTYW85" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><em>Co-Existence: The Next Phase of AI</em></a>, is out this week. He builds with these tools every day, and he still draws firm lines about where they don&#8217;t belong.</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-4276fed elementor-widget elementor-widget-video" data-id="4276fed" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-settings="{&quot;youtube_url&quot;:&quot;https:\/\/www.youtube.com\/watch?v=gEYUgfANlW8&quot;,&quot;video_type&quot;:&quot;youtube&quot;,&quot;controls&quot;:&quot;yes&quot;}" data-widget_type="video.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-wrapper elementor-open-inline">
			<div class="elementor-video"></div>		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-b807ec9 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="b807ec9" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-5c4b820 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="5c4b820" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<h2>The moment</h2><p>Ethan told me he never lets AI take the first pass at anything that matters: not his writing, not his peer reviews, not his replies to students. His reason comes from his research on innovation. Brainstorming was invented in 1955, and within a couple of years researchers knew it backfired, because once you hear the group&#8217;s ideas, yours start to fit the group. AI does the same thing. It writes a seductive draft you can&#8217;t get out of your head.</p><p>He also named four human edges for working with AI: deep knowledge, wide knowledge, taste and agency.</p><table role="presentation" width="100%" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0"><tbody><tr><td><p><em>“The enemy of slop is taste.”</em></p><p>Ethan Mollick</p></td></tr></tbody></table>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-c5b22d6 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="c5b22d6" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-5a41c05 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="5a41c05" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<h2>Take this with you</h2><p>Before you ask AI anything this week, write your own first draft. Rough is fine. Then use AI as the second opinion, never the first. You&#8217;ll keep your own voice, and you&#8217;ll be able to tell when the machine gets it wrong.</p><p>Until next time,</p><p>Brian</p><p><strong>Missed Monday?</strong> Can a machine feel the happiest thought of Einstein&#8217;s life? <a href="https://ckarchive.com/b/68ueh8h5qegd2tkq88gqmtpp69q4zc9hv9xg6" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Read this week&#8217;s musing</a></p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-ff4c3ea elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="ff4c3ea" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-e96589b elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="e96589b" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://briankeating.com/podcast">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Subscribe to my podcast! More than 2M downloads!</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-1823f91 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="1823f91" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				</div>
					</div>
				</div>
				</div>
		]]></content>
		
					<link rel="replies" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/when-ai-can-do-almost-anything-whats-left-thats-yours/#comments" thr:count="0" />
			<link rel="replies" type="application/atom+xml" href="https://briankeating.com/when-ai-can-do-almost-anything-whats-left-thats-yours/feed/atom/" thr:count="0" />
			<thr:total>0</thr:total>
			</entry>
		<entry>
		<author>
			<name>sabartigas</name>
					</author>

		<title type="html"><![CDATA[Can a Machine Feel Einstein&#8217;s Happiest Thought?]]></title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/can-a-machine-feel-einsteins-happiest-thought/" />

		<id>https://briankeating.com/?p=9014</id>
		<updated>2026-10-26T05:48:16Z</updated>
		<published>2026-10-26T05:43:14Z</published>
		<category scheme="https://briankeating.com" term="Blog" />
		<summary type="html"><![CDATA[Can a Machine Feel Einstein&#8217;s Happiest Thought? The Happiest Thought Dear Magicians, Can a machine feel the happiest thought of Einstein&#8217;s life? In 1907, Einstein imagined a man falling freely from a roof. As he falls, he feels no gravity at all. Einstein called it the happiest thought of his life. That one image cracked open general relativity. Lately I&#8217;ve been asking a strange question. What if we built an AI that knew only what physicists knew before 1907? No relativity, no quantum mechanics. Could it find that falling man on its own? It turns out to be very hard to even run that test. You have to strip out more than physics papers. You have to strip out popular culture too. Interstellar, Kip Thorne&#8217;s wormholes and decades of science fiction all leak the answer. A clean, uncontaminated mind is almost impossible to build. But I don&#8217;t think the deeper problem is contamination. It&#8217;s data. Cosmology&#8217;s biggest open fight is over how fast the universe is expanding. Measure it with nearby galaxies and you get one number. Measure it with the oldest light in the universe, the cosmic microwave background I study, and you get another. Each side claims better than 1 percent precision. They disagree at five to seven standard deviations, odds of roughly one in a trillion that it&#8217;s a fluke. So ask the smartest AI ever built which side is right. What can it do? It can&#8217;t build a telescope. It can&#8217;t order a supernova to explode ten billion years ago. In biology, a robot lab can mix reagents all night and generate fresh data. In cosmology, there is one universe, and we can&#8217;t rerun it. Language models are brilliant at math because math is a language. Physics is not a language. Physics is described by language, but the word is not the thing. The word for bread doesn&#8217;t feed you. And then there&#8217;s the stomach drop. The weightless lurch of a roller coaster, the moment you feel free fall in your gut. Einstein&#8217;s insight began as a feeling. Can a model that has never fallen ever have it? I don&#8217;t know. That&#8217;s what makes it exciting. So here&#8217;s my question for you this week. What do you know because you felt it, not because you read it? Write down one thing. That&#8217;s your edge, and no machine can download it. Until next time, have a M.A.G.I.C. week. Brian Appearance Richard Dawkins: Genes and the Meaning of Life, Carnegie Hall Next Tuesday, October 20 at 7:00 pm, I’ll be on stage at Carnegie Hall in conversation with Richard Dawkins. It’s his first time at Carnegie Hall, and the evening marks fifty years of The Selfish Gene. We’ll talk about the gene’s-eye view of life, what it says about being human, and his idea that every living creature is a “genetic book of the dead,” an archive of the worlds its ancestors lived in. It’s presented by How To Academy in Stern Auditorium / Perelman Stage, at 57th and Seventh in New York. Tickets are at carnegiehall.org or 212-247-7800. I’d love to see you there. Get tickets at How To Academy → Genius A Cloud Made of Thin Air Every cloud we have ever seen, on Earth, Venus or Mars, needs a seed: a speck of dust or soot for water to condense on. Over Arsia Mons, a Martian volcano about 20 kilometers tall, ESA’s Mars Express orbiter has watched a thin cloud stretch some 1,800 kilometers downwind every morning for a few months around the southern summer solstice. A team led by Jorge Hernández-Bernal of Sorbonne University now reports in Nature Geoscience that the volcano drives air up to 45 kilometers high and chills it by 30 degrees Celsius in minutes, so the water vapor becomes wildly supersaturated with no dust up there to grab onto, and it condenses all by itself. It may be the first time anyone has caught a seedless cloud in the act. Mars keeps teaching us about limits, which is the heart of my talk “A T. rex on Mars”: the physics of a world decides what can grow there, from ice crystals to minds. Some ideas come out of thin air, and on Mars, so do clouds. Read more: Sky &#38; Telescope → Image A selfie with Raj Shamani, host of Figuring Out, right after we went toe to toe with the arrow of time. We covered why time only moves forward, why relativity says there is no universal &#8220;now,&#8221; and whether change is more fundamental than time itself, with a speculative detour into extra time dimensions and running the clock backward. The episode is coming soon, and I promise it will not arrive before it was recorded. Conversation Latest on Into The Impossible https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ajx261foD1U Adam Grant: How to Build Chemistry in a Remote World When two people are really vibing, their brainwaves sync up and so do their heartbeats. That is not a metaphor, and organizational psychologist Adam Grant has spent his career learning how to make it happen on purpose. His new book, Vibe, argues that the science of human connection has been hiding in plain sight for a century. We talk about why remote work causes boreout rather than burnout, why the highest paid person’s opinion can kill a team’s best ideas, and why desirability bias may be more dangerous than confirmation bias. He also explains the five-minute intervention that tripled revenue for university fundraising callers, and why he A/B tested the subtitle of his own book. We even found common ground on false certainty and thinking in conditional probabilities. My favorite line from Adam: “The highest sign of chemistry between people is not agreeing with them. It’s enjoying your disagreements.” Listen on Apple Listen on BrianKeating.com Subscribe to my podcast! More than 2M downloads! Advertisement Tomorrow&#8217;s prize goes to a discovery made decades ago. Here&#8217;s how the winners made it: Focus Like a Nobel Prize Winner! In Into the Impossible, Volume 2, I sat down with]]></summary>

					<content type="html" xml:base="https://briankeating.com/can-a-machine-feel-einsteins-happiest-thought/"><![CDATA[		<div data-elementor-type="wp-post" data-elementor-id="9014" class="elementor elementor-9014">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-81507fa e-flex e-con-boxed wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-parent" data-id="81507fa" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
					<div class="e-con-inner">
		<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-8f27f2e e-con-full e-flex wpr-particle-no wpr-jarallax-no wpr-parallax-no wpr-sticky-section-no wpr-column-slider-no wpr-equal-height-no e-con e-child" data-id="8f27f2e" data-element_type="container" data-e-type="container">
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-9ca3e95 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="9ca3e95" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Can a Machine Feel Einstein's Happiest Thought?</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-94db8a9 elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="94db8a9" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
															<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="768" height="432" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Cosmic-Vanity_-A-More-Beautiful-Universe-768x432.png" class="attachment-medium_large size-medium_large wp-image-8951" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Cosmic-Vanity_-A-More-Beautiful-Universe-768x432.png 768w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Cosmic-Vanity_-A-More-Beautiful-Universe-300x169.png 300w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Cosmic-Vanity_-A-More-Beautiful-Universe-1024x576.png 1024w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Cosmic-Vanity_-A-More-Beautiful-Universe-1536x864.png 1536w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Cosmic-Vanity_-A-More-Beautiful-Universe.png 1672w" sizes="(max-width: 768px) 100vw, 768px" />															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-267451c elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="267451c" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>The Happiest Thought</strong></p><p>Dear Magicians,</p><p>Can a machine feel the happiest thought of Einstein&#8217;s life?</p><p>In 1907, Einstein imagined a man falling freely from a roof. As he falls, he feels no gravity at all. Einstein called it the happiest thought of his life. That one image cracked open general relativity.</p><p>Lately I&#8217;ve been asking a strange question. What if we built an AI that knew only what physicists knew before 1907? No relativity, no quantum mechanics. Could it find that falling man on its own?</p><p>It turns out to be very hard to even run that test. You have to strip out more than physics papers. You have to strip out popular culture too. Interstellar, Kip Thorne&#8217;s wormholes and decades of science fiction all leak the answer. A clean, uncontaminated mind is almost impossible to build.</p><p>But I don&#8217;t think the deeper problem is contamination. It&#8217;s data.</p><p>Cosmology&#8217;s biggest open fight is over how fast the universe is expanding. Measure it with nearby galaxies and you get one number. Measure it with the oldest light in the universe, the cosmic microwave background I study, and you get another. Each side claims better than 1 percent precision. They disagree at five to seven standard deviations, odds of roughly one in a trillion that it&#8217;s a fluke.</p><p>So ask the smartest AI ever built which side is right. What can it do?</p><p>It can&#8217;t build a telescope. It can&#8217;t order a supernova to explode ten billion years ago. In biology, a robot lab can mix reagents all night and generate fresh data. In cosmology, there is one universe, and we can&#8217;t rerun it.</p><p>Language models are brilliant at math because math is a language. Physics is not a language. Physics is described by language, but the word is not the thing. The word for bread doesn&#8217;t feed you.</p><p>And then there&#8217;s the stomach drop. The weightless lurch of a roller coaster, the moment you feel free fall in your gut. Einstein&#8217;s insight began as a feeling. Can a model that has never fallen ever have it?</p><p>I don&#8217;t know. That&#8217;s what makes it exciting.</p><p>So here&#8217;s my question for you this week. What do you know because you felt it, not because you read it? Write down one thing. That&#8217;s your edge, and no machine can download it.</p><p>Until next time, have a M.A.G.I.C. week.</p><p>Brian</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-d4af88b elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="d4af88b" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-95332b6 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="95332b6" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Appearance</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-23961b2 elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="23961b2" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
															<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="768" height="1024" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Image-from-iOS-5-768x1024.jpg" class="attachment-large size-large wp-image-8958" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Image-from-iOS-5-768x1024.jpg 768w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Image-from-iOS-5-225x300.jpg 225w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Image-from-iOS-5.jpg 1086w" sizes="(max-width: 768px) 100vw, 768px" />															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-54e2662 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="54e2662" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>Richard Dawkins: Genes and the Meaning of Life, Carnegie Hall</strong></p><p>Next Tuesday, October 20 at 7:00 pm, I’ll be on stage at Carnegie Hall in conversation with Richard Dawkins. It’s his first time at Carnegie Hall, and the evening marks fifty years of <em>The Selfish Gene</em>. We’ll talk about the gene’s-eye view of life, what it says about being human, and his idea that every living creature is a “genetic book of the dead,” an archive of the worlds its ancestors lived in.</p><p>It’s presented by How To Academy in Stern Auditorium / Perelman Stage, at 57th and Seventh in New York. Tickets are at carnegiehall.org or 212-247-7800. I’d love to see you there.</p><p><a href="https://howtoacademy.com/north-america-events/richard-dawkins-genes-and-the-meaning-of-life/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Get tickets at How To Academy →</a></p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-8526d95 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="8526d95" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-25a37fd elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="25a37fd" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Genius</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-7ce2132 elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="7ce2132" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
															<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="800" height="533" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/The_Arsia_Mons_Elongated_Cloud_as_seen_by_Mars_Express.jpg" class="attachment-large size-large wp-image-9016" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/The_Arsia_Mons_Elongated_Cloud_as_seen_by_Mars_Express.jpg 900w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/The_Arsia_Mons_Elongated_Cloud_as_seen_by_Mars_Express-300x200.jpg 300w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/The_Arsia_Mons_Elongated_Cloud_as_seen_by_Mars_Express-768x512.jpg 768w" sizes="(max-width: 800px) 100vw, 800px" />															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-4607896 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="4607896" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>A Cloud Made of Thin Air</strong></p><p>Every cloud we have ever seen, on Earth, Venus or Mars, needs a seed: a speck of dust or soot for water to condense on.</p><p>Over Arsia Mons, a Martian volcano about 20 kilometers tall, ESA’s Mars Express orbiter has watched a thin cloud stretch some 1,800 kilometers downwind every morning for a few months around the southern summer solstice. A team led by Jorge Hernández-Bernal of Sorbonne University now reports in <em>Nature Geoscience</em> that the volcano drives air up to 45 kilometers high and chills it by 30 degrees Celsius in minutes, so the water vapor becomes wildly supersaturated with no dust up there to grab onto, and it condenses all by itself. It may be the first time anyone has caught a seedless cloud in the act.</p><p>Mars keeps teaching us about limits, which is the heart of my talk <a href="https://tsc2026.org/abstracts_html/brian-keating.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">“A T. rex on Mars”</a>: the physics of a world decides what can grow there, from ice crystals to minds. Some ideas come out of thin air, and on Mars, so do clouds.</p><p><a href="https://skyandtelescope.org/astronomy-news/a-cloud-forms-spontaneously-over-a-mountain-on-mars-heres-why/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Read more: Sky &amp; Telescope →</a></p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-3175708 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="3175708" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Image</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-b576ea6 elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="b576ea6" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
															<img loading="lazy" decoding="async" width="768" height="1024" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Raj-768x1024.png" class="attachment-large size-large wp-image-9017" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Raj-768x1024.png 768w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Raj-225x300.png 225w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Raj.png 1080w" sizes="(max-width: 768px) 100vw, 768px" />															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-cad849d elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="cad849d" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/post/UgkxLQI8iYrSMMA812njxXlF1i6t4fg3VkZx" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">A selfie with Raj Shamani, host of Figuring Out, right after we went toe to toe with the arrow of time. We covered why time only moves forward, why relativity says there is no universal &#8220;now,&#8221; and whether change is more fundamental than time itself, with a speculative detour into extra time dimensions and running the clock backward. The episode is coming soon, and I promise it will not arrive before it was recorded.</a></p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-e0d5485 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="e0d5485" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-6a84d6f elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="6a84d6f" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Conversation</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-865d5f8 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="865d5f8" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<h2 data-pm-slice="1 1 []"><strong>Latest on Into The Impossible</strong></h2>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-9cc1d43 elementor-widget elementor-widget-video" data-id="9cc1d43" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-settings="{&quot;youtube_url&quot;:&quot;https:\/\/www.youtube.com\/watch?v=ajx261foD1U&quot;,&quot;video_type&quot;:&quot;youtube&quot;,&quot;controls&quot;:&quot;yes&quot;}" data-widget_type="video.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-wrapper elementor-open-inline">
			<div class="elementor-video"></div>		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-59008d1 elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="59008d1" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>Adam Grant: How to Build Chemistry in a Remote World</strong></p><p>When two people are really vibing, their brainwaves sync up and so do their heartbeats. That is not a metaphor, and organizational psychologist Adam Grant has spent his career learning how to make it happen on purpose. His new book, <em>Vibe</em>, argues that the science of human connection has been hiding in plain sight for a century. We talk about why remote work causes boreout rather than burnout, why the highest paid person’s opinion can kill a team’s best ideas, and why desirability bias may be more dangerous than confirmation bias. He also explains the five-minute intervention that tripled revenue for university fundraising callers, and why he A/B tested the subtitle of his own book. We even found common ground on false certainty and thinking in conditional probabilities. My favorite line from Adam: “The highest sign of chemistry between people is not agreeing with them. It’s enjoying your disagreements.”</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-d5c9b18 elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="d5c9b18" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/into-the-impossible-with-brian-keating/id1169885840" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Listen on Apple</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-0a997f2 elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="0a997f2" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://briankeating.com/podcast/">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Listen on BrianKeating.com</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-7cc89a5 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="7cc89a5" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-0669785 elementor-align-center elementor-widget elementor-widget-button" data-id="0669785" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="button.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<div class="elementor-button-wrapper">
					<a class="elementor-button elementor-button-link elementor-size-sm" href="https://briankeating.com/podcast">
						<span class="elementor-button-content-wrapper">
									<span class="elementor-button-text">Subscribe to my podcast! More than 2M downloads!</span>
					</span>
					</a>
				</div>
								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-5b0aefa elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="5b0aefa" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-62c18a8 elementor-widget elementor-widget-heading" data-id="62c18a8" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="heading.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
					<h2 class="elementor-heading-title elementor-size-default">Advertisement</h2>				</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-5e65cd4 elementor-widget elementor-widget-image" data-id="5e65cd4" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="image.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
																<a href="https://www.amazon.com/Into-Impossible-Laureates-Concentrate-Creativity/dp/1544548842" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
							<img decoding="async" width="228" height="300" src="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-228x300.jpg" class="attachment-medium size-medium wp-image-6601" alt="" srcset="https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-228x300.jpg 228w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-777x1024.jpg 777w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-768x1012.jpg 768w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-1165x1536.jpg 1165w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D-1554x2048.jpg 1554w, https://briankeating.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/BrianKeating_FrontCover_Paperback_Lock_3D.jpg 1650w" sizes="(max-width: 228px) 100vw, 228px" />								</a>
															</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-3a26bae elementor-widget elementor-widget-text-editor" data-id="3a26bae" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="text-editor.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
									<p><strong>Tomorrow&#8217;s prize goes to a discovery made decades ago. Here&#8217;s how the winners made it: <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Into-Impossible-Laureates-Concentrate-Creativity/dp/1544548842" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Focus Like a Nobel Prize Winner</a>!</strong></p><p>In <em>Into the Impossible, Volume 2</em>, I sat down with Nobel Prize winners to find out how they actually work: how they protect their attention, pick problems worth decades of their lives, and keep going when nobody else believes the result. Their answers are full of practical lessons you can use to concentrate your creativity and ignite your career, whether or not Stockholm ever calls.</p><p><strong><a href="https://www.amazon.com/Into-Impossible-Laureates-Concentrate-Creativity/dp/1544548842" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Get your copy on Amazon</a></strong> and learn from the laureates themselves.</p>								</div>
				</div>
				<div class="elementor-element elementor-element-011d7a5 elementor-widget-divider--view-line elementor-widget elementor-widget-divider" data-id="011d7a5" data-element_type="widget" data-e-type="widget" data-widget_type="divider.default">
				<div class="elementor-widget-container">
							<div class="elementor-divider">
			<span class="elementor-divider-separator">
						</span>
		</div>
						</div>
				</div>
				</div>
					</div>
				</div>
				</div>
		]]></content>
		
					<link rel="replies" type="text/html" href="https://briankeating.com/can-a-machine-feel-einsteins-happiest-thought/#comments" thr:count="0" />
			<link rel="replies" type="application/atom+xml" href="https://briankeating.com/can-a-machine-feel-einsteins-happiest-thought/feed/atom/" thr:count="0" />
			<thr:total>0</thr:total>
			</entry>
	</feed>
